Coaching

[quillenl]

PS - To clarify what I was suggesting I believe you would likely see the same career tracks for Koufax and Clemente with TCR set to 100 in the test you ran.

[quillenl]

I'm mixed on how I feel about turning off development. I'd also like more realism but have to chose between issues with players like Koufax and Clementre playing to 50 or turning development on and having the engine try to destroy Nolan Ryan in May each season after he hits 40. :/

[Brad K]

Originally Posted by thehef

I was just running a test, historical with no historical transactions, with minors, with development on, 1-yr re-calc. Koufax played until age 50, and was dominant except for his final season, where he was merely very good. Clemente played until 49 and was also excellent.

I tried another test, same settings except I turned development on but had Talent Change Randomness set to 2 (meaning development was in effect, but just barely). In that test, the development engine apparently took over after Koufax & Clemente ran out of real-life stats, and their OOTP careers then took believable paths: Koufax was excellent for 5 more seasons (after his real-life retirement), then had a mediocre final season at age 36, and retired. Clemente played two more seasons as a part-timer before retiring at age 39. (Also, Lyman Bostock had a reasonable OOTP career: a couple decent seasons before fading away.)

So I think - based upon limited testing - the answer to quillenl's question is to play with the development engine on, and having the number set very low. That's assuming you want guys to have seasons similar to their real-life seasons, and want guys who retired early IRL to keep playing in OOTP, but not to unrealistic levels and age.

Finally, it may be worth noting that the Retire According to History and Miss Seasons Accdg to History checkboxes do not work if you are playing with historical transactions. This used to work - you could play with historical transactions, uncheck Retire Accdg to History, and Koufax would not retire early. Several versions ago this was changed for some unknown reason, and the ability to play that way no longer exists.

I thought TCR and development engine were two different things.

Anyway I play with TCR 100 dev on 3 year recalc not weighted and don't have people playing effectively until they're 50. OTOH I occasionally have a guy who played decently for a couple of years have a 20 year career.

I posted about George Korinc doing this. I think I may have also posted about Ken Hubbs.