Notes from history

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — AUGUST 24, 1910
By Arthur H. Leland, Sporting Times

WAGNER REACHES 2,500 HITS AS PIRATES BLANK PHILLIES, 3–0
Pittsburgh Veteran Marks Milestone in Season of Frustration

PITTSBURGH, Aug. 24 — The Pittsburgh Pirates, whose pennant hopes have wavered and dipped throughout the summer, enjoyed a welcome bright spot this afternoon at Exposition Park as they shut out the Philadelphia Phillies, 3 to 0, bringing their season mark to 56–60.

The victory was notable, but the moment that brought the crowd roaring to its feet came in the eighth inning, when Honus Wagner, the incomparable titan of the Pittsburgh infield, collected the 2,500th hit of his illustrious career.

With the Pirates already holding a 3–0 advantage, Wagner opened the home half of the eighth by driving a clean, well-struck single past the first baseman. Though the inning yielded no further runs and the great shortstop was left stranded, the hit itself stood as a testament to his enduring excellence.

Wagner finished the day 1-for-4, raising his season average to .295, and continues to show remarkable consistency at 36 years of age. Since debuting in 1897, he has fashioned a career batting mark of .329, a figure placing him among the finest ever to play the game.

After the contest, Wagner received the milestone in his customary modest way.
“I’ve just tried to put the bat on the ball for all these years,” he said with a shrug. “If a few more of them have fallen in than I ever expected, I’m thankful for it.”

Pirates manager Jason Leach praised his shortstop’s durability and example.
“Honus is the kind of ballplayer a club builds itself around,” Leach remarked. “He shows up every day, works harder than anyone, and still finds a way to make history. The boys feed off that.”

In a season marked by inconsistency, Wagner’s milestone provided Pittsburgh fans with a moment of enduring pride—proof that even in a turbulent campaign, greatness remains constant.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — SEPTEMBER 1, 1910
By George F. Winthrop, Sporting Times

PENNANT RACES TIGHTEN AS SEPTEMBER ARRIVES
Senators Under Pressure; Reds Holding Firm in Senior Circuit

With the last days of summer fading and a crisp hint of autumn settling over the ballparks of America, the 1910 pennant races have entered their final and most dramatic stretch. Both leagues remain very much in doubt, promising a stirring September for clubs and supporters alike.

In the American League, the once-comfortable lead of the Washington Senators has dwindled to a mere three games. The Senators have shown signs of faltering, and the pack behind them has taken full advantage. The Chicago White Sox and Detroit Tigers now stand as the closest pursuers, while the New York Highlanders lurk only another half game behind, ready to pounce should the leaders stumble further.

At the foot of the standings, the St. Louis Browns remain anchored in last place, but their recent play has given supporters faint glimmers of encouragement. Meanwhile, the Philadelphia Athletics—once expected to fare far better—have slipped to seventh, adding an unwelcome twist to their uneven campaign.

Across the divide in the National League, the Cincinnati Reds continue to set the pace, maintaining a four-and-a-half–game lead over their nearest rivals, the Philadelphia Phillies. With the rest of the league now far off the mark, the battle for the flag appears to be narrowing to a two-club contest. At the bottom, the St. Louis Cardinals remain deeply adrift, their struggles long since casting them out of contention.

As September brings expanded rosters, the closing month promises added intrigue. Clubs in the hunt will look for any sliver of advantage, while those already out of the race will turn their attention to the testing of young talent in hopes of better fortunes ahead.

Monthly Awards

American League

Top Batter: Nap Lajoie, Philadelphia Athletics — .353, 13 RBI, 23 runs scored

Top Pitcher: Louis Drucke, New York Highlanders — 6–1, 0.89 ERA

Rookie: Louis Drucke, New York Highlanders — 6–1, 0.89 ERA

National League

Top Batter: Eddie Collins, Brooklyn Superbas — .346, 16 RBI, 19 runs scored

Top Pitcher: Walter Johnson, Brooklyn Superbas — 6–1, 1.41 ERA

Rookie: George Suggs, Pittsburgh Pirates — 4–2, 2.41 ERA

With everything still to play for, the final month of the 1910 season promises thrills—and no shortage of heartbreak—as the push for the pennant reaches its decisive hour.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — SEPTEMBER 7, 1910
By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times

REDS WIN WILD CONTEST, BUT LOSE BELL TO GRIEVOUS INJURY
Cincinnati Triumphs 11–7, Yet Pennant Hopes Take a Blow

Chicago, Sept. 7 — The Cincinnati Reds, locked in a ferocious struggle for the National League pennant, emerged victorious in a hard-hitting 11–7 decision over the Chicago Cubs this afternoon. Yet the triumph came tinged with misfortune, as the club suffered the grave loss of pitcher George Bell, whose injury may cast a long shadow over Cincinnati’s September hopes.

With the Reds entering the day at 77–53, every contest holds heightened meaning, and manager Patrick Pinnow handed the ball to Bell due to the recent injury to regular starter Orval Overall. Bell rewarded that confidence early, dealing four excellent innings that staked Cincinnati to a commanding 6–0 lead.

But as the fifth inning began, disaster struck. After issuing a walk to John Titus, Bell visibly winced, clutching at his elbow as the final pitch left his hand. The trainers rushed to his aid, and it was immediately apparent the young right-hander could not continue.

Bell’s line for the day — 4 innings, 1 hit, 1 run, 1 walk — reflected the same steadying presence he has offered all year. With a 2.00 ERA and a 7–4 record across 11 starts and 14 total appearances, his loss will be keenly felt.

Following the contest, the Reds delivered the grim news: Bell has suffered a torn flexor tendon in his elbow and is expected to miss seven months of action, ending his season at the moment his club needs him most.

Postgame Reactions

George Bell, stoic despite the setback, said:
“It’s a hard blow, especially with the club fighting as it is, but a pitcher knows his arm better than anyone, and the moment I felt it go, I knew something was amiss. I only wish I could stay in the thick of the fight with the boys.”

Manager Patrick Pinnow, trying to hold the club’s spirits aloft, remarked:
“George has been a rock for us all season, and losing him now hurts more than I can rightly say. But this club has met adversity before, and we’ll meet it again. We’ll keep pressing for that pennant — for George as much as for ourselves.”

As September grows shorter and the stakes sharper, Cincinnati will now attempt to forge ahead without one of its steadiest arms. Whether today’s victory proves the beginning of a final surge or the prelude to a harder struggle remains to be seen.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — SEPTEMBER 8, 1910
By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times

MATHEWSON HERO OF THE DAY AS GIANTS TRIUMPH IN EXTRA INNINGS
Big Six Claims 200th Career Victory in 4–3 Win Over Beaneaters

New York, Sept. 8 — The season’s fortunes for the New York Giants have risen and fallen like a skiff on a restless tide, but today the waves broke kindly upon them. Before an appreciative Polo Grounds crowd, the Giants edged the Boston Beaneaters 4–3 in ten innings, lifting their record to 62–67 and providing a moment of triumph in an otherwise uneven campaign.

At the heart of the victory stood none other than Christy Mathewson, who delivered a performance that will be remembered long after the dust of the season settles. With calm precision and iron endurance, the veteran right-hander went the full ten innings, yielding 8 hits and 3 runs, while striking out nine men. In so doing, he secured the 200th win of his illustrious career.

But pitching alone did not satisfy “Big Six.” Mathewson took to the bat as though determined to secure every inch of the day’s glory himself. His fifth-inning home run pulled the Giants even at 2–2, and in the tenth, his ringing double set the stage for the winning tally. Moments later, he crossed the plate to the roar of the faithful, sealing the hard-fought victory with his own feet.

For the season, Mathewson now stands at 19–13, owning a 2.74 ERA, steady as ever in a year marked by fluctuation. Since debuting with the Giants in 1900, he has compiled a 200–151 record and a sterling 2.60 career ERA, cementing his place among the game’s greats.

Postgame Reflections

Christy Mathewson, modest even in triumph, remarked:
“A pitcher can ask for no finer day than one where the arm holds up, the bat finds its mark, and the club comes away with the victory. The lads fought hard behind me, and I’m proud to have reached this milestone wearing the Giants’ colors.”

Manager George Davis, clearly buoyed by his ace’s heroics, said:
“Christy showed every bit of the class that has defined his career. Ten innings, the big hits, the winning run — it was a masterpiece. If the rest of us match his spirit down the stretch, there’s still good baseball left for this club.”

On a season of shifting fortunes, today belonged unequivocally to the Giants — and unmistakably to Mathewson.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — SEPTEMBER 13, 1910
By Arthur H. Leland, Sporting Times

RED SOX EDGE HIGHLANDERS 5–4, BUT LOSE GETZ TO SERIOUS INJURY
Boston Finds a Glimmer in a Trying Season as Infielder Hurt on Slide

Boston, Sept. 13 — The Boston Red Sox, long beset by hardship this season, found a measure of relief this afternoon as they secured a narrow 5–4 victory over the visiting New York Highlanders, improving their mark to 62–70. Yet the triumph was shaded by misfortune, for the club also suffered the loss of Gus Getz, whose day ended abruptly and painfully.

The trouble came in the bottom of the second inning, when Getz, attempting to steal into scoring position, made a hard slide into second base. The Highlanders’ second baseman received the throw and laid the tag, and in the instant of collision both men toppled to the ground. Only Getz failed to rise. The medical staff responded at once, but a brief examination made it clear that his afternoon was finished. He was ruled out on the play and then removed from the field.

Getz had begun the game brightly, going 1-for-1 with an RBI, continuing the form he has shown since joining Boston. His campaign has been a curious one: the first half spent with the Philadelphia Phillies, where he posted a .238 average in 43 games, 42 of them as a pinch hitter. His July 25th trade to the Red Sox seemed to revive him, and in 42 starts with Boston he has lifted his average to .277, becoming one of the few steadying influences in the club’s unsettled year.

After the contest, physicians delivered the sober news: a torn labrum in Getz’s shoulder, an injury that will sideline him for five months.

Postgame Words

A subdued Gus Getz spoke briefly, saying:
“It’s a hard blow. I felt I’d finally found my stride here in Boston, and to be put out like this is tough to swallow. But I’ll do what the doctors tell me and work my way back. The club has treated me well, and I mean to return the same.”

Red Sox manager Jim Manning added his own thoughts:
“Gus has been a spark for us since the day he arrived. Losing him is no small loss, but he’s a determined fellow. We’ll keep his place ready and expect him back when he’s mended. For now, the boys will rally as best they can.”

Though the Red Sox claimed the day’s victory, the injury to Getz cast a long shadow over the win — a reminder of how narrow the line can be between promise and misfortune on the diamond.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — SEPTEMBER 17, 1910
By George F. Winthrop, Sporting Times

HAMILTON REACHES 3,000 HITS AS ATHLETICS TOP TIGERS 8–2
Philadelphia Veteran Marks Milestone in Much-Needed Victory

Detroit, Sept. 17 — The long and trying campaign of the Philadelphia Athletics found a welcome moment of brightness this afternoon as the club secured an 8–2 triumph over the Detroit Tigers. Though the season ledger still reads a grim 52–83, the day offered the club and its supporters something to celebrate.

That joy came courtesy of Billy Hamilton, the Athletics’ venerable 44-year-old center fielder, who at last joined the exclusive company of men to record 3,000 career hits. The moment arrived in the top of the seventh inning, when Hamilton sent a sharp single past the shortstop. Though he was later stranded on the bases, the significance of the blow was not lost on the gathering, nor on Hamilton’s teammates, who greeted him warmly upon his return to the bench.

Hamilton finished the afternoon 1-for-4, lifting his season average to .254. His career, which began in 1888, now stands at 3,000 hits, 45 home runs, and a lifetime average of .306—a testament to both his skill and remarkable endurance across more than two decades on the diamond.

Postgame Reflections

A humble Hamilton addressed the feat in quiet tones:
“I’ve been at this game a long time, and I’ve seen many a season come and go. Reaching a mark like this means a good deal, but I’m more thankful that I’ve had the chance to play this long. If it gives the club a bit of cheer in a hard year, then I’m glad for it.”

Athletics manager Chris Smith praised his veteran outfielder:
“Billy is one of the game’s true craftsmen. To see him reach three thousand is something the whole club takes pride in. We needed something to lift our spirits, and he gave it to us today. No man deserves it more.”

In a season short on triumphs, the Athletics found in Hamilton’s milestone a moment worth treasuring.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — SEPTEMBER 19, 1910
By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times

STAHL HITS FOR THE CYCLE, BUT WHITE SOX FALL TO HIGHLANDERS 8–4
Chicago First Baseman Shines in Defeat

Chicago, Sept. 19 — The Chicago White Sox suffered a setback this afternoon at South Side Park, bowing to the visiting New York Highlanders by a ledger of 8–4. The defeat drops Chicago to 77–62 as their late-season chase grows tighter. Yet amid the disappointment came one of the most remarkable individual displays seen from a White Sox man this year.

Jake Stahl, whose season has been marked by wild swings between strikeouts and sudden bursts of hitting, delivered the finest performance of his campaign by hitting for the cycle. Stahl went 4-for-5, scoring three runs and driving in another, raising his season mark to .229.

Stahl opened his afternoon with a fly out in the first, but from that point onward he struck the ball with authority. In the fourth inning, after a hard-fought twelve-pitch duel, he lashed a triple on a 3–2 offering. The sixth inning saw him follow with a solo home run, and in the eighth he lined a double. When he stepped in during the ninth, needing only a single to complete the rare achievement, he delivered it cleanly — though the rally ended there, and the Sox could not claw their way back.

Postgame Words

A modest Stahl reflected on the bittersweet nature of the day:
“It’s a fine thing to have a day like this, but it doesn’t sit quite right when it comes in a losing effort. I only wish those hits had brought us a better result.”

Manager Clark Griffith praised his first baseman’s efforts while lamenting the defeat:
“Stahl gave the crowd a show today. You don’t see a cycle every season, let alone in a game like this. He’s battled inconsistency, but when he finds his stroke, he’s as dangerous as any man out there. Still, we needed more from the rest of the club. One man’s hitting can’t win it alone.”

Despite the loss, Stahl’s feat stands as a bright note on an otherwise difficult afternoon for Chicago.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — SEPTEMBER 23, 1910
By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times

SHECKARD SCORES 1,000TH CAREER RUN IN CARDINALS’ 5–2 DEFEAT
St. Louis Outfielder Reaches Major Milestone Despite Another Tough Loss

Brooklyn, Sept. 23 — The long, trying campaign of the St. Louis Cardinals continued this afternoon as they bowed to the Brooklyn Superbas, 5–2, at Washington Park. The defeat drops St. Louis to 58–80, their struggles emblematic of a season that has rarely offered relief.

Yet amid the gloom, Jimmy Sheckard delivered a moment worthy of celebration. The veteran outfielder crossed the plate for the 1,000th run of his career, a feat achieved by only a select few in the game’s history.
Sheckard shone as the brightest figure in the Cardinals’ order, going 2-for-3, drawing a walk, and scoring two runs. His milestone tally came in the top of the third, when St. Louis briefly held a 2–1 advantage, offering a fleeting glimpse of promise before the Superbas wrested control of the contest.

This season has been a difficult one for the 31-year-old, as his .230 average stands as the lowest mark of his career. Still, his overall record remains strong — a .278 lifetime average since his debut in 1897 — and his play today showed he has plenty of baseball left in him.

Postgame Reflections

Sheckard, typically reserved, allowed himself a moment of pride:

“I’d have liked the run to lead to something better for the club, but a thousand is something a man can look back on with satisfaction. I’ve been fortunate to stay in the game this long, and I’m not near finished yet.”

Manager General Stafford praised his outfielder while acknowledging the broader challenges:

“Jimmy gave us something to cheer today, and he’s earned every bit of that milestone. He plays hard, plays smart, and sets an example. We just haven’t given him enough support this year. Still, there’s no quit in this club.”

Though the Cardinals leave Brooklyn with another mark in the loss column, Sheckard’s achievement stands as a rare beam of light in a darkened season.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — SEPTEMBER 26, 1910
By Arthur H. Leland, Sporting Times

RUSS FORD SETS PITCHING APPEARANCE RECORD IN TIGERS’ 9–6 VICTORY
Detroit Rookie Works His 78th Game of the Season, Earns 31st Win

Detroit, Sept. 26 — Some hurlers swear by rest, others by relentless toil. For Russ Ford, the remarkable 27-year-old freshman of the Detroit Tigers, greatness appears to lie in answering the call as often as the manager dares to make it. Today, Ford took the mound for the 37th time as a starter, added to his 51 turns in relief, bringing his staggering total to 78 appearances this season — a new major-league record for a pitcher.

And he made it count.

The Tigers bested the New York Highlanders, 9–6, pushing the club’s mark to 80–65 and strengthening their position in the final weeks of the pennant chase. For Ford, the victory carried him to an extraordinary 31–14 record, paired with a sharp 2.07 earned run average. His ledger also includes nine saves, a testament to the versatility that has astonished observers all year.

Ford worked eight innings, yielding seven hits, four earned runs, striking out seven, and issuing five walks in another display of his relentless stamina.

Postgame Remarks

Ford, his arm bandaged but his spirits high, spoke modestly of the record:
“I just take the ball when they hand it to me. If the club needs me, I’m ready. That’s all there is to it. I’m grateful for every chance to pitch, and as long as my arm holds, I’ll keep going.”

Manager Frank Selee, who has relied on Ford more heavily than any pitcher in recent memory, lauded his rookie’s endurance:
“Ford is a marvel. You don’t see a man like this often — strong, willing, and steady every time he steps out there. He’s been the backbone of this club all season. We wouldn’t be where we are without him.”

As the season winds toward its close, Russ Ford’s iron-man campaign stands as one of the remarkable feats of 1910 — a testament to both his talent and his tireless constitution.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — SEPTEMBER 28, 1910
By George F. Winthrop, Sporting Times

JAY HUGHES NOTCHES 250TH CAREER VICTORY AS HIGHLANDERS BLANK TIGERS, 4–0
New York Veteran Turns Back Detroit with Masterful Three-Hitter

Detroit, Sept. 28 — The New York Highlanders enjoyed one of their finest afternoons of the season today, shutting out the Detroit Tigers, 4–0, behind a vintage performance from veteran right-hander Jay Hughes. The victory lifted New York to 77–68, but the greater triumph belonged to Hughes, who recorded the 250th win of his distinguished career.

The 36-year-old was in complete command from first pitch to last, scattering three hits and issuing just two walks while holding the powerful Tigers’ lineup scoreless over the full nine innings. The Highlanders’ bats supplied all the support he required, and Hughes never allowed Detroit a serious threat.

For the year, Hughes now stands at 22–12 with a 2.67 ERA, continuing a campaign worthy of his long reputation. His career totals — 250–159 with a 2.80 ERA since debuting in 1898 — place him firmly among the eminent pitchers of the age.

Postgame Remarks

Hughes, typically modest in achievement, reflected quietly on the milestone:
“I’ve been fortunate to play this game a long time, and days like this make the hard years worthwhile. The boys played sharp behind me, and that makes any pitcher’s work easier. I’m proud, but mostly I’m grateful.”

Highlanders manager Alfonso Perez offered high praise for his veteran ace:
“Jay pitched like a man who’s been here before—and he has. He knows how to win, plain and simple. He set the tone from the first inning, and the club followed his lead. It’s a privilege to manage a pitcher of his calibre.”

Hughes’ mastery today not only strengthened New York’s late-season hopes but added another shining chapter to a remarkable pitching career.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — SEPTEMBER 29, 1910
By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times

GIANTS FALL 3–2 AS JACK CRONIN'S SEASON ENDS WITH INJURY
Veteran Reliever Faces Uncertain Future After Radial Nerve Diagnosis

New York, Sept. 29 — The New York Giants’ difficult campaign took yet another hard turn this afternoon as they dropped a close contest, 3–2, to the pennant-chasing Cincinnati Reds at the Polo Grounds. The defeat left New York at 66–79, but the more painful blow came with the injury to veteran pitcher Jack Cronin.

Cronin, who has spent much of the year in quiet duty out of the bullpen — appearing in only 19 games — was summoned to open the ninth inning in hopes of keeping the Reds at bay. With New York trailing by a single run, manager George Davis turned to the steady 36-year-old to hold the line.

But after surrendering back-to-back singles to the first two men he faced, Cronin abruptly signaled for assistance, clutching at his arm. The trainer’s examination was brief, and Cronin was escorted off the field to a concerned silence from the New York faithful.

For the season, Cronin has posted a fine 2.62 ERA, with a 2–1 record and two saves, despite his limited use.

The postgame medical verdict, however, was grim: Cronin will require radial nerve decompression surgery, sidelining him five to six months and casting a long shadow over his future in the game. At 36, the question now looms whether this injury marks the end of a long professional road.

Postgame Reactions

Cronin spoke with quiet honesty about the uncertainty ahead:
“I’ve been at this game a long time, and I know when something feels wrong. I’ll take the surgery and see where it leaves me. If there’s still a place for me next spring, I’ll give it everything I have. If not… well, I’ve been fortunate to wear a big-league uniform as long as I have.”

Giants manager George Davis expressed both sympathy and admiration for his veteran pitcher:
“Jack’s a gamer. He’s answered every call we’ve made of him, even in a season where he didn’t get many chances. You hate to see a man go down like that, especially one who’s carried himself with such professionalism. Whatever he decides, he’ll have the full respect of this club.”

A somber day in New York, where the scoreline felt secondary to the fate of a respected veteran.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — SEPTEMBER 30, 1910
By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times

BROOKLYN EDGES PHILLIES 6–5 AS BILL KEISTER RECORDS 2,500TH HIT
Veteran Infielder Shines in Rare Start for the Superbas

Brooklyn, Sept. 30 — The Brooklyn Superbas, though fading somewhat in the late going, offered their supporters a lively contest at Washington Park this afternoon, securing a 6–5 victory over the pennant-hunting Philadelphia Phillies. The win lifted Brooklyn to 71–76 on the season and provided a welcome bright moment amid a modest September drift.

No moment shone brighter than that belonging to veteran infielder Bill Keister, who in a rare starting assignment collected the 2,500th hit of his long and steady career. Keister went 2-for-4 on the afternoon, his milestone blow greeted warmly by the Brooklyn faithful who recognized the achievement owed to years of perseverance.

Though he owns a respectable .275 average this season, Keister has found himself employed sparingly, with only 34 starts across 113 games, making today’s contribution all the more meaningful. Now 39 years of age, Keister’s career, which began in 1896, has produced a sturdy .295 lifetime average and a reputation for reliability whenever called upon.

Postgame Reflections

Keister, modest as ever, downplayed his personal feat:
“A ballplayer just tries to be ready when his name is written in. I’m grateful for the chance to help today, and reaching that number… well, it means I’ve been at this game a long while. I’m glad I could do my part.”

Superbas manager Ned Hanlon was quick to praise his veteran’s professionalism:
“Bill’s the sort of man every club needs — steady, prepared, and never one to complain. He came in today and gave us exactly what we needed. A milestone like his doesn’t come by accident; it comes from years of hard work.”

A rewarding afternoon for Brooklyn, and a memorable one for Keister, whose bat spoke loudly even in limited opportunity.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — OCTOBER 1, 1910
By Arthur H. Leland, Sporting Times

PENNANT RACES HEAT UP AS SEASON ENTERS FINAL STRETCH
Senators and Reds Hold Narrow Leads as Both Leagues Approach Climax

As the 1910 season nears its close, both the American and National Leagues remain poised for dramatic conclusions, with little room for error and every game carrying heightened importance.

In the American League, the Washington Senators continue to set the pace with a 3½ game lead, though four clubs remain within striking distance. Cleveland Naps and Chicago White Sox share second place, while the Detroit Tigers trail by a single game in fourth. The New York Highlanders, though eight games back, remain mathematically in the hunt. At the opposite end of the table, the once-proud Philadelphia Athletics have slipped to last place, recording the worst mark in baseball.

The National League presents a similarly tense scene. Cincinnati Reds cling to a slim 1½ game advantage over the Philadelphia Phillies, the only two teams still in contention. Behind them, the remainder of the league is effectively out of the pennant chase, while the St. Louis Cardinals linger stubbornly at the bottom.
Monthly Awards for September
American League


Top Batter: Sherry Magee, St. Louis Browns — .320 average, 4 home runs, 17 RBIs, 20 runs scored


Top Pitcher: Walter Ball, Cleveland Naps — 6–0–1 record, 0.83 ERA


Rookie of the Month: Russ Ford, Detroit Tigers — 5–1 record, 1.73 ERA


National League


Top Batter: Ty Cobb, Philadelphia Phillies — .432 average, 19 RBIs, 12 runs scored


Top Pitcher: Frank Smith, Philadelphia Phillies — 6–0 record, 0.94 ERA


Rookie of the Month: Hippo Vaughan, Pittsburgh Pirates — 4–3 record, 3.45 ERA


As the final stretch unfolds, both pennant races promise to keep fans on edge, with every swing of the bat and pitch of the ball potentially decisive. The Senators and Reds may hold the advantage, but in this tight season, nothing is certain until the last out is recorded.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — OCTOBER 5, 1910
By George F. Winthrop, Sporting Times

RED SOX SNAP FIFTEEN-GAME SKID WITH HARD-FOUGHT WIN OVER SENATORS
Camnitz Steadies, Parent Shines as Boston Finally Breaks Through

At long last, the Boston Red Sox have halted the agonizing slide that has defined their final weeks of the season. After fifteen consecutive defeats, the beleaguered club at last found relief this afternoon, toppling the league-leading Washington Senators by a score of 4–2 on the road. The victory lifts Boston to 64–86 on the year.

The afternoon began ominously, with the Red Sox falling behind 2–1, stirring uneasy murmurs among the small cluster of traveling supporters who feared yet another disappointment. But in the sixth inning, Boston at last rediscovered its spark. A burst of timely hitting brought three runs across the plate, overturning the deficit and giving the visitors a lead they would not relinquish.

A major share of credit rests with Howie Camnitz, who has struggled for consistency since returning from injury in late August. Today, however, the right-hander delivered the sort of steady performance Boston has long awaited. Camnitz worked eight strong innings, yielding just seven hits and one earned run, keeping the powerful Senators’ bats quiet and preserving the fragile lead.

At the plate, Freddy Parent proved indispensable, collecting three hits in four trips and driving home two runs, providing exactly the lift Boston’s weary offense required.

After the long-awaited triumph, the veteran shortstop sounded visibly relieved.

“We’ve been pressing for weeks,” Parent admitted. “It felt good—real good—to finally come through when it counted. A win like this reminds you the game still turns our way once in a while.”

Manager Jim Manning, who has worn the strain of the club’s struggles on his face of late, praised both effort and resolve.

“These fellows haven’t quit once,” Manning said. “Fifteen losses will test any club, but today they dug in and earned one. Camnitz gave us the outing we needed, and the bats finally answered. We’ll take this and keep fighting to the last.”

For the Red Sox, the victory may not change their place in the standings, but it offers something that has been in short supply these past weeks—hope, however modest, and a reminder that perseverance can still be rewarded.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — OCTOBER 7, 1910
By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times

DAVIS REACHES 2,000-HIT MARK AS ATHLETICS EDGE HIGHLANDERS 4–3
A Rare Bright Spot in a Season Philadelphia Hopes to Leave Behind

For the Philadelphia Athletics, the 1910 campaign has been a long and discouraging march, marked by misfortune, inconsistency, and a steady slide down the league table. Yet on this early October afternoon, the club finally enjoyed a moment of celebration, edging the New York Highlanders 4–3 at Columbia Park to lift their record to 62–90.

The victory itself was a pleasant enough tonic for the home faithful, but the afternoon’s true significance belonged to Harry Davis, the veteran first baseman who at last collected the 2,000th hit of his long and distinguished career.

Davis turned in a fine performance, going 3-for-4 with a run scored. His milestone knock—a clean single to left in the bottom of the second—momentarily stirred the Athletics’ dugout and drew a warm ovation from the Philadelphia crowd. Though he was ultimately stranded that inning, the moment stood unmistakably apart in a season where little has gone right.

For Davis, the year has been as trying as any in memory. His .212 average across 151 starts reflects much of the club’s broader struggle. Still, his career mark remains a sturdy .279, the product of a professional journey that began in 1895 and has included a steady tenure with the Athletics since 1901.

After the game, Davis spoke with quiet humility about the achievement.

“Two thousand hits… it sneaks up on a man,” Davis said with a faint smile. “It’s been a hard season for all of us, but moments like this remind you why you lace up every day. I’m grateful I could give the fans something to cheer.”

Manager Chris Smith, who has weathered the frustrations of the season with as steady a hand as possible, praised his veteran leader.

“Harry’s been the backbone of this club for years,” Smith remarked. “No matter the standings, you can count on him to play the game the right way. He earned every one of those hits, and we’re proud to see him reach that mark.”

With only a handful of games remaining, the Athletics may not salvage much more from this dreary campaign—but for one afternoon, at least, Philadelphia had reason to applaud.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — OCTOBER 16, 1910
By Arthur H. Leland, Sporting Times

SENATORS AND REDS CLAIM PENNANTS AS SEASON CLOSES
Washington and Cincinnati Prepare for World Series Clash

With the final outs recorded and the dust settling upon another grand campaign, the 1910 regular season has officially drawn to its close—leaving behind triumph for some, disappointment for others, and the promise of a compelling World Series ahead.

In the American League, the Washington Senators have at last secured the pennant, completing a season marked by steady leadership and early dominance. Though their march appeared comfortable for much of the year, the Cleveland Naps mounted a fierce late charge, pulling within a mere half-game with only three contests remaining. Yet Washington steadied itself at the crucial moment, finishing three games clear and earning its first ever league championship.

At the opposite end of the table, the Philadelphia Athletics conclude the season with the poorest record in all of Baseball. Still, inconsistency elsewhere prevented them from falling entirely out of touch with their rivals.

Meanwhile, in the National League, the Cincinnati Reds proved themselves the most consistent side from April to October. Regularly perched at or near the summit, they weathered a spirited late surge by the Philadelphia Phillies and ultimately captured the flag by two games. At the basement once more reside the St. Louis Cardinals, finishing four games adrift of the remainder of the circuit.

With the standings now fixed, all attention turns to the forthcoming World Series, a best-of-seven engagement that will pit Washington’s first-time pennant winners against a Cincinnati club whose lone championship dates back to 1903.

The matchup promises intrigue. For the Senators, the burden will fall heavily upon the capable bat of Pete Hill, while on the mound the club will lean upon the formidable arms of Smokey Joe Williams and Willie Mitchell. Cincinnati, by contrast, will look to their remarkable 36-game winner Eddie Plank to anchor the staff. At the plate, the Reds will depend—as they have all year—on the strength of their collective rather than on any singular star.

Thus the stage is set. The long march of summer has reached its end, and all that remains is the crowning contest between Washington and Cincinnati—a clash certain to captivate the eyes of Base Ball men across the nation.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — OCTOBER 16, 1910
By George F. Winthrop, Sporting Times

A SEASON OF RECORDS—SOME PROUD, SOME LESS SO
Ford Sets New Pitching Mark as Stahl and Murray Enter the Ledgers for Unwanted Reasons

As the curtain falls on the 1910 campaign, the final tally of feats and curiosities has been taken. Each season leaves its imprint upon the history of the game, and this year is no exception—though not every name added to the record books will look upon the achievement with equal fondness.

Foremost among the notable marks is the astonishing workload of Russ Ford of the Detroit Tigers, whose durability has set a new high-water mark for pitchers. The 27-year-old rookie, seemingly immune to fatigue, took the field 80 times—a major league record—splitting his duties between 39 starts and 41 relief appearances. His efforts yielded a formidable 33–14 record and 9 saves, a testament to both stamina and skill.

On the other side of the ledger fall two records earned under less cheerful circumstances.

Jake Stahl of the Chicago White Sox, whose season has been punctuated by fits of brilliance and bouts of frustration, now finds himself the holder of the all-time single-season strikeout record. His 153 strikeouts, a product of his tendency to chase pitches best left alone, easily surpassed the previous mark of 134 and contributed heavily to his modest .230 average.

The year’s second unenviable distinction belongs to Red Murray of the Boston Red Sox, whose aggressive pursuit of stolen bases too often ended with a tag instead of triumph. Murray was caught stealing 41 times, edging past the prior record of 39. He was not alone, however, as Ty Cobb of the Phillies fell short 40 times, and Hans Lobert of the Browns matched the old record with 39.

Though these marks differ in nature, each now forms part of the story of 1910—a season long to be remembered.

Ford, reflecting on his unprecedented workload, remarked:
“I just took the ball whenever they handed it to me. A man can’t ask for more than the chance to pitch, and I aimed to make good on every one.”

Stahl, confronted with his place in the record book, offered a wry acknowledgment:
“It ain’t the sort of record a fellow dreams of, but all a man can do is square up and try to strike fewer breezes next year.”

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — OCTOBER 24, 1910
By Samuel T. Kingsley & Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times

WASHINGTON SENATORS CLAIM FIRST WORLD TITLE — PITCHING PROWESS TOPPLES REDS IN FIVE

The 1910 World Series has been decided, and for the first time in their history, the Washington Senators stand atop the baseball world. In a tightly contested but low-scoring affair, the Senators dispatched the Cincinnati Reds by a margin of four games to one, their triumph built upon the surest of foundations—dominant pitching.

From the outset it was clear that runs would be scarce, and the crown would fall to the club whose hurlers could maintain their nerve across the week. Washington’s staff proved equal to the task, with Willie Mitchell rising above all others. The left-hander secured two victories and allowed but one earned run across his appearances, a performance that earned him the Most Valuable Player laurels.

Equally vital was Jack Pfiester, who in the pivotal third contest spun a masterful effort, yielding no earned runs in a 3–1 triumph that swung momentum firmly to the Capital City club.

At the plate the Senators found no singular hero, but rather a steady contribution throughout the order—enough to scrape the few runs needed to back their superior pitching.

The Reds, so strong throughout the regular year, found themselves uneven when the games mattered most. Eddie Plank alone secured a victory for Cincinnati, but without consistent support from the remainder of the rotation, the club struggled to match Washington’s measured precision. Their bats, usually reliable, were stifled time and again by the Senators’ relentless staff.

Thus ends a series defined not by spectacle, but by resolve—and Washington, steady and sure, now claims its place among champions.

Willie Mitchell, series MVP, reflected modestly on his triumph:
“A pitcher’s job is to keep his head and throw his best. The fellows behind me did the rest. I’m proud to have done my part for Washington.”

Senators manager Chase Stone praised his club’s fortitude:
“These men earned every inch of this title. They pitched hard, fielded clean, and took their chances. That’s winning baseball, and they delivered it all week.”

From the opposing clubhouse, Eddie Plank offered his thoughts on Cincinnati’s defeat:
“We fought, but Washington’s arms were too strong this time. You tip your cap and come back ready next season.”

Reds manager Patrick Pinnow echoed the sentiment while looking ahead:
“We came up short, no denying it. Our pitching didn’t match theirs when it counted, and our bats never quite woke. But this club has heart, and we’ll be back in the hunt soon enough.”

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — OCTOBER 25, 1910
By Arthur H. Leland, Sporting Times

BOSTON AND BROOKLYN CLUBS SHED OLD NAMES IN BID FOR NEW FUTURES

What value lies in a name? In the world of base ball, it can be the weight of tradition—or the anchor of misfortune. Today two National League clubs have cast off their long-worn titles in hopes that a fresh banner may herald a fresh beginning.

The Boston Doves, long in search of firmer footing both on the field and in public affection, have elected to adopt a new identity. Beginning next season they will be known as the Boston Rustlers, marking the second change in name for the club since the leagues joined in 1901. The Boston management believes that a new moniker will not only restore interest among the city’s faithful but also expand commercial opportunities at a time when competition for the Boston sporting public grows ever sharper.

Manager Kyle Jackson addressed the shift with measured optimism:
“A club needs spirit, and a name ought to carry that spirit. ‘Rustlers’ speaks to industry and fight, and that’s the brand of ball we mean to play. If a new name helps stir the hearts of our supporters, then it’s a step worth taking.”

Further south, the Brooklyn Superbas—a team only recently risen from the league’s cellar—have likewise chosen to reinvent themselves. Hoping to sever ties with seasons best forgotten, they shall now be known as the Brooklyn Dodgers. The club believes the updated style better reflects a squad on the rise, eager to shake off old disappointments and aim higher in the standings.

Manager Ned Hanlon welcomed the change with confidence:
“Brooklyn needed a name that matched our new direction. The fellows have fought their way back toward respectability, and ‘Dodgers’ gives us a clean slate. We mean to build on what we started this year and chase a pennant under this new banner.”

Whether these fresh identities prove the spark each club seeks remains to be seen, but for now both Boston and Brooklyn greet the future with renewed resolve and renewed names.

[amead17]

SPORTING TIMES — OCTOBER 25, 1910
By George F. Winthrop, Sporting Times

RED SOX AND ATHLETICS DISMISS THEIR SKIPPERS AS SEASON ENDS

The close of the base ball season brings not only the tallying of records but, for some, the reckoning of judgment. Today two American League managers—each with championship laurels in his past—found himself out of a job as clubs seek fresh direction after disappointing campaigns.

Jim Manning Dismissed in Boston

The first and perhaps most surprising dismissal came in Boston, where Jim Manning has been relieved of his duties after four seasons at the helm of the Red Sox. Manning’s tenure was, until this year, one of the most successful stretches in club history: two pennants and a world series title in his first two seasons, followed by a strong second-place finish last year.

But 1910 brought a collapse to seventh place, and with the general manager also shown the door, Boston ownership elected to “clean house” entirely. Club officials stated that it was better to reset now, during a downturn, in hopes of rapidly restoring the club to its former championship form.

Manning admitted the decision came as a blow:
“I won’t pretend it doesn’t sting. I believed the work we’d done—the titles we’d won—had earned me a chance to right the ship. But base ball moves quick, and sometimes yesterday’s victories don’t carry into tomorrow.”

Chris Smith Let Go in Philadelphia

The second dismissal occurred in Philadelphia, where Chris Smith has been removed after seven seasons guiding the Athletics. Smith led the club to back-to-back world series triumphs in 1904 and 1905, but the years since have trended steadily downward, ending in a last-place finish this season—the worst record in the major leagues.

Athletics ownership stated plainly that a change was required to “reverse the club’s direction” and rebuild toward competitiveness.

Smith accepted the news with grace:
“This game gives and it takes. I’ve had the great fortune to lead a fine club to championships, and I’ve seen hard years too. If the owners believe a new hand is needed, I can only tip my cap and wish the fellows well.”

With these two long-tenured skippers departing, the winter months will bring not only roster moves but managerial hunts in both cities—each seeking a leader to guide them back toward the top.