I want to buy your game again, but this is unacceptable

[JSnow93]

I know I'm going to get trashed for this and it will even likely be locked and closed down. I just want to say this is coming from a good place I respect the team and realize they're a small group in advance, I just want a great hockey management game. Well here goes anyway.

I bought FHM 11 like I bought every previous version since FHM 3. That game finally brought me to the point where I was wholly disappointed by the series. Here is a review I left on Steam https://steamcommunity.com/profiles/...ended/2936410/ in the review I state

"The trades are absolutely whacky in a way I haven’t seen in previous versions, very few trades make sense, I’ve seen teams trade for a player and trade him away for less in the same day. I felt this could be due to the current start database trying to account for salary teams have take on at the trade deadline that they only were able to because of LTIR, which turns out is not the case as the same thing continues years into a save.

My most recent save got tossed because teams got compliance buyouts and the players who got bought out teams did not approach them to sign. So I was left with 3 star plus players like Forsling and Sanheim and many more with no teams willing to sign them.


I wanted to check in and see how 12 was being received as I really did want to buy it and support the group again. Only to read this review.

https://steamcommunity.com/profiles/...ended/3739670/

Which states many of the issues I pointed out haven't been touched. The reviewer states:

"-How players who get compliance buyouts will simply never get signed to another team.
-Teams signing a player in free agency to a long term deal and immediately putting them on the trade block.
-Whatever this new trade issue is where teams are trading for a player then seeing that player get traded the next day, and thrice more that same season."

Maybe the team made sure players had their right handedness this year?

[Savoie45]

Originally Posted by JSnow93

I know I'm going to get trashed for this and it will even likely be locked and closed down. I just want to say this is coming from a good place I respect the team and realize they're a small group in advance, I just want a great hockey management game. Well here goes anyway.

I bought FHM 11 like I bought every previous version since FHM 3. That game finally brought me to the point where I was wholly disappointed by the series. Here is a review I left on Steam https://steamcommunity.com/profiles/...ended/2936410/ in the review I state

"The trades are absolutely whacky in a way I haven’t seen in previous versions, very few trades make sense, I’ve seen teams trade for a player and trade him away for less in the same day. I felt this could be due to the current start database trying to account for salary teams have take on at the trade deadline that they only were able to because of LTIR, which turns out is not the case as the same thing continues years into a save.

My most recent save got tossed because teams got compliance buyouts and the players who got bought out teams did not approach them to sign. So I was left with 3 star plus players like Forsling and Sanheim and many more with no teams willing to sign them.


I wanted to check in and see how 12 was being received as I really did want to buy it and support the group again. Only to read this review.

https://steamcommunity.com/profiles/...ended/3739670/

Which states many of the issues I pointed out haven't been touched. The reviewer states:

"-How players who get compliance buyouts will simply never get signed to another team.
-Teams signing a player in free agency to a long term deal and immediately putting them on the trade block.
-Whatever this new trade issue is where teams are trading for a player then seeing that player get traded the next day, and thrice more that same season."

Maybe the team made sure players had their right handedness this year?

The trade logic is always a work in progress and will likely be included in the next patch. If people provide a list of Database errors I'm sure Jeff would be glad to correct them.

[LennoxHart]

Érdekes ötlet, hogy ennyire részletes ligastruktúrát akarsz modellezni a játékban, szerintem ettől lesz igazán életszagú a szimuláció. Ha a rájátszás és a meccsterhelés is jól van balanszolva, az hosszú távon is izgalmas marad. Én szeretem, ha statisztikailag is hihető eredmények jönnek. Kicsit olyan ez, mint amikor egy magyar online casino oddsai is reálisnak érződnek, nem csak dísznek vannak.