Hall of Fame Threshold Spreadsheet

[spartacus007]

I've been working on a spreadsheet to help me easily determine who to vote for in the Hall of Fame.

Open this link in Google Sheets and make a copy. Instructions are on the first tab. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets...it?usp=sharing

For the current real-life ballot, it suggests voting for Carlos Beltran, Adrian Beltre, Todd Helton, Andy Pettitte, Manny Ramirez, Alex Rodriguez, Jimmy Rollins and Garry Sheffield.

Please tell me what you think! Right now it is not position-relative, something I'd like to add in the future.

[kq76]

I think you're undervaluing Wagner, Mauer, and Utley. I would think Billy Wagner is "maybe" even a small hall guy. All 3 of them are probably getting voted in IRL, but your SS doesn't seem to agree, probably due to position.

You probably have too many 1st ballot big hall guys and too many maybe big hall guys.

Critiques aside, I like all that you've done with this! It's very interesting. Tweak it just a little bit and you could make some good predictions.

[spartacus007]

Thanks! I think you're definitely write about position being needed.

I'm going to tweak some more to make the criteria a bit more strict.

[kq76]

I thought you might be interested in Jason Sardell's work, if you haven't come across him already. Here's a video from today with him, but you might want to search out and look at his stuff.