|
I can see giving it to the injured guy, but honestly, those other dudes pitched a lot more than he did and it's not their fault they didn't get hurt and could be judged on half a resume.
#2, #3 and maybe your injured guy at #3 as recognition of how dominant his year was. When I pick award winners, it's usually based on an approximation of how real voters vote, rather than solely on stats anyway.
|