Starting Pitchers & Injuries

kcroyalty29 · 04-03-2020, 01:53 PM

Hi Guys!

I started with my Royals in 2020 and am currently in 2023 - finally nearing .500.

I thought I was going to compete this year after clearing payroll to go out and sign Aroldis Chapman, who has five stars at the time I signed him.

He became 4 by Opening Day and by week two of the season, he had Tommy John. So that $15 mil on a one year deal was wasted and he became a 2 star.

Ignore that - I'm more upset because BOTH pitchers I grew on the farm (inherited 3 star SP Brady Singer and traded for 3 star SP Forrest Whitley) ALSO had Tommy John surgery this year. Both were 3 stars with 3.5 potential.

I've had other pitchers in this game lose a full star or more after surgeries.

So my question is: Obviously I'm not re-signing Chapman and he's toast because of age.

But guys like Singer and Whitley - both around 26 years old and 3 star SP's with 3.5 potential - are both now basically screwed and will automatically drop to 2.5 star potential? Should I even plan on them being in my 2025 rotation? I had planned on them anchoring it for years to come and now I'm not only looking for new SP options in 2024, but thnking they may not even be core players after that.

How do younger pitchers normally respond to Tommy John in this game?

Also, do the freaking major injuries to pitchers EVER end in this game? I'm not turning injuries off - they're a part of the game and I like them - but this seems a little unfair in one year.

Thanks

Dave

slugga27 · 04-03-2020, 02:18 PM

The short answer here is--the injuries don't automatically mean life is over for the player, just like in real life. Look at Stephen Strasburg--early TJ surgery and he's still a pretty good pitcher.

Younger players should generally have a better chance of bouncing back than older players, but there are certainly exceptions.

jimmysthebestcop · 04-04-2020, 01:29 AM

Don't get hung up on stars. You also need stats for all these players to see what happens.

If none of their injury ratings changed to wrecked or anything then there is hope. But you need some stats. So they going to need to rehab at least a month of games in AAA to see what they got.

04-03-2020, 01:53 PM	#1
kcroyalty29 Minors (Single A) Join Date: Mar 2020 Posts: 81	Starting Pitchers & Injuries Hi Guys! I started with my Royals in 2020 and am currently in 2023 - finally nearing .500. I thought I was going to compete this year after clearing payroll to go out and sign Aroldis Chapman, who has five stars at the time I signed him. He became 4 by Opening Day and by week two of the season, he had Tommy John. So that $15 mil on a one year deal was wasted and he became a 2 star. Ignore that - I'm more upset because BOTH pitchers I grew on the farm (inherited 3 star SP Brady Singer and traded for 3 star SP Forrest Whitley) ALSO had Tommy John surgery this year. Both were 3 stars with 3.5 potential. I've had other pitchers in this game lose a full star or more after surgeries. So my question is: Obviously I'm not re-signing Chapman and he's toast because of age. But guys like Singer and Whitley - both around 26 years old and 3 star SP's with 3.5 potential - are both now basically screwed and will automatically drop to 2.5 star potential? Should I even plan on them being in my 2025 rotation? I had planned on them anchoring it for years to come and now I'm not only looking for new SP options in 2024, but thnking they may not even be core players after that. How do younger pitchers normally respond to Tommy John in this game? Also, do the freaking major injuries to pitchers EVER end in this game? I'm not turning injuries off - they're a part of the game and I like them - but this seems a little unfair in one year. Thanks Dave

04-03-2020, 02:18 PM	#2
slugga27 All Star Starter Join Date: Jun 2011 Posts: 1,249	The short answer here is--the injuries don't automatically mean life is over for the player, just like in real life. Look at Stephen Strasburg--early TJ surgery and he's still a pretty good pitcher. Younger players should generally have a better chance of bouncing back than older players, but there are certainly exceptions.

04-04-2020, 01:29 AM	#3
jimmysthebestcop Banned Join Date: Jun 2018 Posts: 1,728 Infractions: 0/2 (5)	Don't get hung up on stars. You also need stats for all these players to see what happens. If none of their injury ratings changed to wrecked or anything then there is hope. But you need some stats. So they going to need to rehab at least a month of games in AAA to see what they got.