How much PP is your team worth???

[Matt Arnold]

Originally Posted by Dunzie

Gryphons Red team in Diamond 382 - 220,562PP with peanuts in reserve roster
Gryphons Gold team in Perfect 413 - 292,642PP with around 10k in reserve roster
Gryphons Blue team in Perfect 413 - 470,049PP with around 40k in reserve roster

I wish I had done this before joining P413's cap league. I had to auction off a few high priced guys quickly to buy golds and silvers I didn't previously have, but at the same time shuffling I then upgraded a few diamonds to make the most of my points. Would be interesting to compare...

My main Toronto Devs team apparently is at 277k. Tulo at 650 is the lowest, with Matthewson at 28.5 the top. Part of me definitely tempted now to throw them all up for auction and then go open like 250 packs... Although I don't think I could justify dumping my Expos guys in Pedro, Carter, or Raines. Maybe when I fail in the playoffs again this year and next, I'll at least sell off 5 or 6 of the big guys and try to get up to 50 or 60 packs to open and test my luck...

[Dunzie]

Originally Posted by Matt Arnold

My main Toronto Devs team apparently is at 277k. Tulo at 650 is the lowest, with Matthewson at 28.5 the top. Part of me definitely tempted now to throw them all up for auction and then go open like 250 packs... Although I don't think I could justify dumping my Expos guys in Pedro, Carter, or Raines. Maybe when I fail in the playoffs again this year and next, I'll at least sell off 5 or 6 of the big guys and try to get up to 50 or 60 packs to open and test my luck...

I just don't trust my pack luck. As fun as that might be to try, with my luck I'd end up with a team of 7 Paxtons and a whole bunch of irons.

[mcdog512]

Originally Posted by Dunzie

I just don't trust my pack luck. As fun as that might be to try, with my luck I'd end up with a team of 7 Paxtons and a whole bunch of irons.

My pack luck has been mixed...but I did pull a couple of good historical diamonds recently that were worth about 70k total.

[HRBaker]

Here's my team at the moment. 4 seasons, 4 playoffs, 1 world series.

[zrog2000]

I'd love to be able to create leagues with average AH PP limits for each team. Then everyone would be on a completely level playing field.

[daves]

Originally Posted by zrog2000

I'd love to be able to create leagues with average AH PP limits for each team. Then everyone would be on a completely level playing field.

There is a mini whale diamond and perfect league that limits how many perfect diamond and gold players. Your 25 man roster has to score under 50 with each player rating Perfect 5, Diamond 3 and Gold 1, Silver and Bronze 0. A lot of Ozzie Smiths in this league.

But if you can have a cap of average price it would be better. There are a lot of Diamond players like Ruth selling for a lot more than Trout perfects.

[zrog2000]

Originally Posted by daves

There is a mini whale diamond and perfect league that limits how many perfect diamond and gold players. Your 25 man roster has to score under 50 with each player rating Perfect 5, Diamond 3 and Gold 1, Silver and Bronze 0. A lot of Ozzie Smiths in this league.

But if you can have a cap of average price it would be better. There are a lot of Diamond players like Ruth selling for a lot more than Trout perfects.

Yeah, I have two teams in it. But my teams are worth 1/2 or less than just about every team in it by this standard.

[stl jason]

my F2P pre-ww2 team:

-Eddie Collins: 475
-Ross Youngs: 199
-Heinie Manush: 125
-Lefty O'Doul: 5751
-Bill Terry: 299
-Johnny Frederick: 220
-Mickey Cochrane: 10001
-Pepper Martin: 124
-Luke Appling: 349
-Joe Medwick: 299
-Stan Musial: 7001
-Billy Herman: 120
-Frankie Frisch: 149
-Pat Borders: 44 (only non-pre ww2 player still around from original starter packs)
-Dizzy Trout: 16999
-Mordecai Brown: 13000
-Garland Braxton: 12000
-Sad Sam Jones: 1300
-Johnny Vander Meer: 22000 (just picked him up from AH for 4001 )
-Elmer Riddle: 1649
-Curt Davis: 1008
-Burleigh Grimes: 1250
-Red Faber: 1525
-Lefty Grove: 1150
-George Uhle: 1400

total: 98437


pretty tiny compared to a lot of others.... but managed 3 playoffs and 1 World Series victory, so not bad overall.

[daves]

Originally Posted by stl jason

-Johnny Vander Meer: 22000 (just picked him up from AH for 4001 )

That is quite a deal. Must have accidently fell in the clearance rack?

[stl jason]

Originally Posted by daves

That is quite a deal. Must have accidently fell in the clearance rack?

or someone just pulled him in a pack and wanted to move him fast (and didn't pay attention to the last 5 price - 22000)... they would have done better for themselves just quick-selling the card for 4K, rather than take the 10% hit on the auction; but I'll take it...

worst case he doesn't perform and I try to move him for the last 5 price and shop for someone else with the proceeds

he might end up being one of those frustrating hot/cold pitchers (2 games so far; first game he only went 4.1 innings, gave up 4 runs with 8 walks and only 3 Ks.... second game he went 8 innings with 1 hit, 3 walks, 9 Ks... )

[Dunzie]

Originally Posted by stl jason

-Johnny Vander Meer: 22000 (just picked him up from AH for 4001 )

Wow. Nice scoop.

[Findest2001]

Originally Posted by Izz

Over how long a period? What league are you in? Average weekly PP earnings from achievements is around 5K according to the devs, which is enough for 5 regular packs or some decent low value players from AH.

I've been playing PT for maybe 2 weeks, maybe 3. I'm in bronze .302. There's no way I've ever had even close to 5k

[dodger300]

I have two gold teams. My7yr Las Vegas Outlaws are worth 64,061. Top player Randy Johnson 25,001, lowest Mark Belanger 40. They finished 88-74 taking top wildcard. I have Randy going in WC game. My 13yr Vegas Vulcans are worth 185,669. Top player Van Mungo 40,000. Lowest Andrelton Simmons 925. They finished 106-56 top record in league. Both teams built by card flipping. No cash spent.

[daves]

Originally Posted by Findest2001

I've been playing PT for maybe 2 weeks, maybe 3. I'm in bronze .302. There's no way I've ever had even close to 5k

Many users (not all) buy PP to make it to perfect. There were many discussions about lack of competitive balance because of this.

[Dogberry99]

The Midwestern State Mustangs are a No Money team that uses the Auction House exclusively (ie no packs). We are back in Perfect again, having spent the last 2 in Diamond after a particularly ugly 4 season run at the Perfect Level. This team is worth a total of 160,985 points at this moment (which, since I'm a couple days late to this party, might mean that this total might be slightly deflated). The highest valued players are all starting pitchers, such as Dallas Keuchel, Bob Gibson, and Cy Blanton.

Going through this exercise made me realize just how many deals I've gotten through patience in the AH. While this team is valued currently at 160,985, only 124,347 points were spent in their acquisition. Below is a full list of my active team (so, not counting reserves, who are mostly cheaper bronze and silver anyways), their respective values, and the points spent on them.


C Tony Pena (76) - 4300 (4000)
C Mike Scioscia (75) - 2800 (2750)
SS Corey Seager (89) - 2677 (Starter Pack)
2B Jim Gilliam (78) - 1599 (2699)
3B Buddy Bell (88) - 6599 (4800)
SS Troy Tulowitzki (75) - 500 (1001)
SS Omar Vizquel (78) - 4999 (2150)
LF Moises Alou (82) - 1349 (1493)
LF Lance Berkman (91) - 10500 (7999)
LF Ed Delahanty (92) - 14000 (13500)
CF Paul Blair (86) - 8001 (5001)
CF Vada Pinson (81) - 1655 (1800)
CF Willie Wilson (69) - 50 (77)
TOTAL: 59,029 (PAID: 47,270)

SP Bob Gobson (93) - 22501 (22501)
SP Cy Blanton (94) - 17002 (20000)
SP Dallas Keuchel (86) - 30001 (8800)
SP Gary Peters (90) - 8000 (7208)
SP George Uhle (84) - 1400 (1200)
TOTAL: 78,904 (PAID: 59,709)

CL Blake Treinen (96) - 8999 (6000)
CL Wilcy Moore (88) - 3555 (2900)
RP Zack Britton (88) - 6000 (4369)
RP Jeurys Familia (83) - 1249 (1100)
RP Robert Stock (79) - 349 (Starter Pack)
RP Patrick Corbin (89) - 1700 (1999)
RP Carlos Martinez (80) - 1200 (1000)
TOTAL: 23,052 (PAID: 17,368)

TOTAL TOTAL: 160,985 (PAID: 124,347)

[daves]

Originally Posted by Dogberry99

The Midwestern State Mustangs are a No Money team that uses the Auction House exclusively (ie no packs). We are back in Perfect again, having spent the last 2 in Diamond after a particularly ugly 4 season run at the Perfect Level. This team is worth a total of 160,985 points at this moment (which, since I'm a couple days late to this party, might mean that this total might be slightly deflated). The highest valued players are all starting pitchers, such as Dallas Keuchel, Bob Gibson, and Cy Blanton.

Going through this exercise made me realize just how many deals I've gotten through patience in the AH. While this team is valued currently at 160,985, only 124,347 points were spent in their acquisition. Below is a full list of my active team (so, not counting reserves, who are mostly cheaper bronze and silver anyways), their respective values, and the points spent on them.


C Tony Pena (76) - 4300 (4000)
C Mike Scioscia (75) - 2800 (2750)
SS Corey Seager (89) - 2677 (Starter Pack)
2B Jim Gilliam (78) - 1599 (2699)
3B Buddy Bell (88) - 6599 (4800)
SS Troy Tulowitzki (75) - 500 (1001)
SS Omar Vizquel (78) - 4999 (2150)
LF Moises Alou (82) - 1349 (1493)
LF Lance Berkman (91) - 10500 (7999)
LF Ed Delahanty (92) - 14000 (13500)
CF Paul Blair (86) - 8001 (5001)
CF Vada Pinson (81) - 1655 (1800)
CF Willie Wilson (69) - 50 (77)
TOTAL: 59,029 (PAID: 47,270)

SP Bob Gobson (93) - 22501 (22501)
SP Cy Blanton (94) - 17002 (20000)
SP Dallas Keuchel (86) - 30001 (8800)
SP Gary Peters (90) - 8000 (7208)
SP George Uhle (84) - 1400 (1200)
TOTAL: 78,904 (PAID: 59,709)

CL Blake Treinen (96) - 8999 (6000)
CL Wilcy Moore (88) - 3555 (2900)
RP Zack Britton (88) - 6000 (4369)
RP Jeurys Familia (83) - 1249 (1100)
RP Robert Stock (79) - 349 (Starter Pack)
RP Patrick Corbin (89) - 1700 (1999)
RP Carlos Martinez (80) - 1200 (1000)
TOTAL: 23,052 (PAID: 17,368)

TOTAL TOTAL: 160,985 (PAID: 124,347)

Good deal for perfect.

[Westheim]

Made a few changes, and suffered some depreciation…

I really need to pull a historical diamond one of these days.

[Maddox]

My best team is worth 99,653

25% of that total is perfect Trout

They are currently leading their division in Diamond. In their 7 1/2 seasons they have an overall record of 729-485.

[elutz31]

Total 1,757,101

Starting pitching is 920,998 (perfect Pedro is most of that)
Relievers 163,000
Hitters 673,103

[daves]

Originally Posted by elutz31

Total 1,757,101

Starting pitching is 920,998 (perfect Pedro is most of that)
Relievers 163,000
Hitters 673,103

$1,000 team!