Historical league question

Cubfan2001 · 01-27-2022, 11:46 AM

Hello everyone,

I apologize for creating a duplicate thread on the same question but I realized this should be asked here rather than general discussions. I looked to see if I could delete that post but couldn’t find where to do so.

I started a historical league in 1996, I set for a fantasy draft and then set it up where players come in random years rather than the year they normally would have. In 2011 the draft was completely empty. So I started looking around in settings and found “ disable automatic creation of free agents and fictional draft class” I noticed the default was check marked. When I unchecked it fake players started coming and they were good prospects, but now I’m in 2013 and the draft is empty again.

So my question is when you do a historical league set up for a certain year does the game just stop creating players at some point? I always assumed when I would get to real time then it would become a fictional league like we normally could do. Is there maybe something I can do to make the draft la populate again?

Jesus Tralfaz · 02-01-2022, 02:09 AM

I have tried to play the 1972 historical season as the Cincinnati Reds, and I am getting frustrated by my inability to throw out any runner. Are you telling me Johnny Bench's rating of 97 does not mean anything? Also, are you telling me that Joe Morgan is getting thrown by catchers with a 38 rating?

I am starting to think this game is joke.

thehef · 02-01-2022, 07:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jesus Tralfaz

I have tried to play the 1972 historical season as the Cincinnati Reds, and I am getting frustrated by my inability to throw out any runner. Are you telling me Johnny Bench's rating of 97 does not mean anything? Also, are you telling me that Joe Morgan is getting thrown by catchers with a 38 rating?

I am starting to think this game is joke.

How many games are you into your 1972 season?

Jesus Tralfaz · 02-27-2022, 06:05 AM

I'm lucky to get 2-3 weeks into the season before I delete the season due to frustration. Recently I played the 1976 Reds and quit when the AI was getting the breaks in a Reds-Phillies series. Thinking about looking into Strat-o-matic baseball.

I'm sorry I should have said the AI cheats, not getting the breaks

Reed · 02-27-2022, 07:14 AM

Game doesn’t cheat.
Just as or maybe more important is the pitcher hold rating.
There use to be a saying that great base stealers would steal against the pitcher more so than against the catcher. It’s probably a combination of the two.

Pelican · 03-01-2022, 05:33 PM

Possibly the ‘76 Phillies were simply a better team than the Big Red Machine? Certainly the Phils were on their way to dominance, and the Reds were fading.

thehef · 03-01-2022, 06:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pelican

Possibly the ‘76 Phillies were simply a better team than the Big Red Machine? Certainly the Phils were on their way to dominance, and the Reds were fading.

The Reds & Phillies were actually both outstanding teams in 1976 and pretty even in both actual wins and expected wins. (Philly took the season series, 7 games to 5.)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jesus Tralfaz

I'm lucky to get 2-3 weeks into the season before I delete the season due to frustration. Recently I played the 1976 Reds and quit when the AI was getting the breaks in a Reds-Phillies series. Thinking about looking into Strat-o-matic baseball.
I'm sorry I should have said the AI cheats, not getting the breaks

In a short series, it would not be surprising to see any team - even a very weak one - get "the breaks" and win a series. In your particular example, it would not be at all unexpected to see the Phillies outplay the Reds and win a series, perhaps even sweep it. Just as it would not be surprising to see it go the other way around. In fact, those World-Champions-to-be '76 Reds lost three separate series' to the lowly SF Giants, and lost series' to bad Cards & Padres teams. They also lost two series to the so-so Mets, dropped a 4-game set (3-1) to the Dodgers, and lost 4-out-of-5 to Philly in mid-June. Season-long dominance is not absolute. Even the best teams lose - on average - one out of three games and sometimes those come in streaks, right along with "the breaks."

Fast-sim a whole season a few times, and then you'll likely see that the results are closer to your expectations.

01-27-2022, 11:46 AM	#1
Cubfan2001 Major Leagues Join Date: Oct 2007 Posts: 415 Blog Entries: 1	Historical league question Hello everyone, I apologize for creating a duplicate thread on the same question but I realized this should be asked here rather than general discussions. I looked to see if I could delete that post but couldn’t find where to do so. I started a historical league in 1996, I set for a fantasy draft and then set it up where players come in random years rather than the year they normally would have. In 2011 the draft was completely empty. So I started looking around in settings and found “ disable automatic creation of free agents and fictional draft class” I noticed the default was check marked. When I unchecked it fake players started coming and they were good prospects, but now I’m in 2013 and the draft is empty again. So my question is when you do a historical league set up for a certain year does the game just stop creating players at some point? I always assumed when I would get to real time then it would become a fictional league like we normally could do. Is there maybe something I can do to make the draft la populate again?

02-27-2022, 06:05 AM	#4
Jesus Tralfaz Bat Boy Join Date: Feb 2022 Posts: 13	Reply I'm lucky to get 2-3 weeks into the season before I delete the season due to frustration. Recently I played the 1976 Reds and quit when the AI was getting the breaks in a Reds-Phillies series. Thinking about looking into Strat-o-matic baseball. I'm sorry I should have said the AI cheats, not getting the breaks Last edited by Jesus Tralfaz; 02-27-2022 at 06:08 AM.

02-01-2022, 02:09 AM	#2
Jesus Tralfaz Bat Boy Join Date: Feb 2022 Posts: 13	I have tried to play the 1972 historical season as the Cincinnati Reds, and I am getting frustrated by my inability to throw out any runner. Are you telling me Johnny Bench's rating of 97 does not mean anything? Also, are you telling me that Joe Morgan is getting thrown by catchers with a 38 rating? I am starting to think this game is joke.

02-27-2022, 07:14 AM	#5
Reed All Star Starter Join Date: Oct 2013 Posts: 1,942	Game doesn’t cheat. Just as or maybe more important is the pitcher hold rating. There use to be a saying that great base stealers would steal against the pitcher more so than against the catcher. It’s probably a combination of the two.

03-01-2022, 05:33 PM	#6
Pelican Hall Of Famer Join Date: Mar 2021 Location: Wilmington, Delaware Posts: 2,309 Blog Entries: 1	Possibly the ‘76 Phillies were simply a better team than the Big Red Machine? Certainly the Phils were on their way to dominance, and the Reds were fading.