Professional Baseball Replay League - 1973 Hall of Fame Ballot - Everyone Welcome!

DamnYankees · 02-14-2010, 10:32 AM

Professional Baseball Replay League
1973 Hall of Fame Ballot
League Home - Hall of Fame - League History

Eligibility Requirements: Players must have spent a minimum of 10 seasons in the major leagues. There is also a five year waiting period before any retired player can be placed on the ballot and a player is only eligible for the 20 years following their retirement. Those who spent their entire careers in the NNL will be eligible for five years once they are included on this ballot.

Players who spent most or all of their career in the PBRL Negro Leagues are being considered for induction. Please note that the Park Adjusted OPS+ numbers are for a player's PBRL stats only. The following is a link to the NNL Leaderboards as well as statistics and notes on all players with significant NNL experience currently being considered for induction: LINK

Significant NNL stats previously unlisted were added to a handful of players' resumes. Please don't overlook these new resources.

10 vote maximum, anyone can vote. Go to it!

Batters
Name - Park Adjusted OPS+ - Notable Accomplishments

1B Chet Farnsworth (1947-1962) - 127 – 6-time All-Star, 2 Gold Gloves, 351 HR

New: C Lyman Wilder (1961-1966) - NA – Negro Leaguer made debut at age 33, .313 hitters, 1-time All Star selection

New: C David Puddy (1945-1966) - 99 – 4-time All-Star, 4 Gold Gloves, 1900 hits, 102 HR

1B Willie Palmer (NNL 1950-1953, PBRL 1954-1964) - 126 - 1-time All-Star, 6 Gold Gloves, 318 home runs, 8 times top-10 RBI in the league

2B Stuart Archibald (1934-1954) - 117 - ROTY, 6-time All-Star, 1 Gold Glove, 1300+ runs and RBI, 749 SB

2B Ray Johnson (1941-1958) - 113 - 1 BOTY, 1 Gold Glove, 7-time All-Star, 1168 SB, 1328 runs

2B Toby Shaftoe (1938-1952) - 118 – 1 BOTY, ROTY, 4-time All-Star, 2 Gold Gloves, lead NL in OBP 6 times

New: SS Algernon Williams (1962-1966) - 134 – Negor Leaguer debuted in the majors at age 31, 4-time All Star,

New: SS Gideon Clarke (1953-1966) - 131 – 6-time All Star, 1962 hits, 104 triples, 112 home runs, hit .471 in 1961 World Series win

New: SS Jesse Claymore (1952-1966) - 118 – 4-time All Star, 1791 hits, 346 HR, 1213 walks

3B Ace Mackey (NNL 1949-1960, PBRL 1961-1964) - X - 1 NNL BOTY, Top 10 in NNL BA, Hits, HR, and RBI in at least six seasons

New: 3B Matt Urban (1950-1967) - 123 – 12-time All Star, 2 Gold Gloves, 1956 Batter of the Year, 2850 hits, 476 HR, 1943 RBI

LF Ralph Olney (NNL 1948-1950, PBRL 1951-1965) - 127 - NNL BOTY at age 22 (1.091 OPS), 2-time All-Star, 2 Gold Gloves, 333 HR, 1458 BB

New: LF Johnny Iosim (1951-1966) - 127 – 2-time All Star, 2088 hits, 197 triples, 317 SB

New: LF Dutch Hendricks (1954-1966) - 142 – 6-time All Star, 1954 Rookie of the Year, 378 home runs, 1202 RBI

CF Frank Bellisimo (1943-1957) - 119 - ROTY, 8-time All-Star, 10 Gold Gloves, 1254 RBI

New: CF Charlie Allnut (1953-1967) - 129 – 4-time All Star, 1953 Rookie of the Year, 2235 hits, 340 HR

RF Ray McCrory (1941-1960) - 130 – 6-time All-Star, 2 Gold Gloves, .318 BA, 1200+ runs and RBI

New: RF Jeffrey Lebowski (1950 -1967) - 132 – 5-time All Star, 1963 Batter of the Year, 1950 Rookie of the Year, 377 HR, 2764 hits

Pitchers
Name - Park Adjusted ERA+ - Notable Accomplishments

SP Gerald Boodoo (1952-1965) - 130 – 1 POTY, ROTY, 6-time All-Star, Top 5 in ERA 4 times, Threw Back-to-Back No Hitters

SP Chip Cockburn (1946-1960) - 130 – 3-time All-Star, Top 5 in lg ERA twice, 1 No-hitter

SP Garreth Shanahan (1943-1957) - 136 – 1 POTY, ROTY, 2-time All-Star, Top 5 in lg ERA 7 times

SP George Thorogood (1941-1957) - 130 – 254 wins, 3-time All-Star, Top 5 in lg ERA 5 times, 1 Perfect Game

SP Millard Upchurch (1933-1955) - 121 - 258 wins, 8-time All-Star, Top 10 in lg ERA 8 times

New: SP Gerard Houarner (1956-1966) - 129 – 1-time All Star selection, 145-84 record, 2-time 20 game winner

New: SP Stanley Loudry (1946-1966) - 165 – 9-time All Star, 354 wins between NNL and ML, 4 rings, won 21 games at age 39

New: SP Chet Boyd (1951-1967) - Not in top 150 – 2-time All Star, 245 wins, last pick of the draft in 1951

New: SP Arthur Jackson (1955-1967) - 132 – 4-time All Star, 204 wins, 3-time 20 game winner,

Approaching Eligibility
1974 - Arturo Dueñas, Walter Hammersmith, Edward Blake, Joe Hardy, George Starkweather, Mills Robbins, Juan Rodriguez, Carl Sears, Hooper Smith, Bill Ramsey
1975 - Bob Bisby, Walter Kowalski, Terry Bollea, John Homer, Chelsey Sullenberger, Dan Huckstep, Norman Simmons
1976 - Johnny Dorian, Don Draper, Vance Ransom, Darryl Grissom
1977 - Joseph Suozzi, August Campbell, Sheldon Cooper, Tory Hurley, Pervis Floyd, Pete Poundstone
1978 - Barney Brubaker, John Kruger, Robert Howard, Fuzzy Dawkins

DamnYankees · 02-14-2010, 10:51 AM

Archibald
Johnson
Clarke

Urban
Loudry

DamnYankees · 02-15-2010, 09:59 PM

From the boards:

Quote:

Originally Posted by tlb

Williams
Claymore
Mackey
Urban
Hendricks

Loudry

Quote:

Originally Posted by spielman

Gerald Boodoo
Jesse Claymore
Jeffrey Lebowski
Stanley Loudry
Ray McCrory
Toby Shaftoe
Garreth Shanahan
Matt Urban

Quote:

Originally Posted by soxfan1

McCrory
Urban
Lebowski

Boodoo
Loudry

Quote:

Originally Posted by zoomslowik

Urban
Shaftoe
McCrory
Hendricks
Clarke

Loudry
Boodoo

Quote:

Originally Posted by buckeyetate

Gerald Boodoo
Jesse Claymore
Stanley Loudry
Toby Shaftoe
Garreth Shanahan
Matt Urban
Jeffrey Lebowski

Quote:

Originally Posted by scpride

Matt Urban
Toby Shaftoe
Ray McCrory
Jeffrey Lebowski

Stanley Loudry
Gerald Boodoo
Garreth Shanahan

metsgeek · 02-16-2010, 10:54 PM

Urban
Olney
Hendricks
McCrory
Mackey
Archibald
Bellisimo

Loudry
Boodoo
Shanahan

CatKnight · 02-17-2010, 12:16 AM

Farnsworth
Urban
Hendrick
McCrory
Lebowski

Boodoo
Shanahan
Upchurch
Loudry

DamnYankees · 02-22-2010, 05:35 PM

Bump.

DamnYankees · 03-02-2010, 09:16 AM

From the boards:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve

Chet Farnsworth
Jeffrey Lebowski
Ray McCrory
Toby Shaftoe
Matt Urban

Stanley Loudry
Gerald Boodoo
Garreth Shanahan

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vris

Urban
Shaftoe
Hendricks
Lebowski
Clarke

Boodoo
Shanahan
Loudry
Upchurch
Thorogood

Quote:

Originally Posted by Heinz

Farnsworth
Urban
Hendricks
McCrory
Allnut
Lebowski

Boodoo
Shanahan
Loudry
Boyd

Quote:

Originally Posted by Avi

Palmer
Johnson
Urban
Olney
Hendricks
McCrory
Lebowski

Boodoo
Loudry
Shanahan

DamnYankees · 03-03-2010, 09:15 AM

RESULTS!

Code:

13 BALLOTS CAST

13	100.0%	Loudry
13	100.0%	Urban
11	84.6% 	Boodoo

*****************

9 	69.2%	Lebowski
9 	69.2%	McCrory
9 	69.2%	Shanahan
7 	53.8%	Hendricks
6 	46.2%	Shaftoe
3 	23.1%	Clarke
3 	23.1%	Claymore
3 	23.1%	Farnsworth
2 	15.4%	Archibald
2 	15.4%	Mackey
2 	15.4%	Olney
2 	15.4%	Upchurch
1 	7.7% 	Bellisimo
1 	7.7% 	Johnson
1 	7.7% 	Williams
1 	7.7% 	Thorogood
1 	7.7% 	Allnut
1 	7.7% 	Boyd
1 	7.7% 	Palmer
1 	7.7% 	Johnson

******************

0 	0.0% 	Wilder
0 	0.0% 	Puddy
0 	0.0% 	Iosim
0 	0.0% 	Cockburn
0 	0.0%	 Houarner
0 	0.0% 	Jackson

Congrats to Loudry, Urban, and Boodoo for their induction. The 6 guys with 0 votes fall off the ballot to the VC.

02-14-2010, 10:32 AM	#1
DamnYankees All Star Starter Join Date: Jun 2004 Posts: 1,644	Professional Baseball Replay League - 1973 Hall of Fame Ballot - Everyone Welcome! Professional Baseball Replay League 1973 Hall of Fame Ballot League Home - Hall of Fame - League History Eligibility Requirements: Players must have spent a minimum of 10 seasons in the major leagues. There is also a five year waiting period before any retired player can be placed on the ballot and a player is only eligible for the 20 years following their retirement. Those who spent their entire careers in the NNL will be eligible for five years once they are included on this ballot. Players who spent most or all of their career in the PBRL Negro Leagues are being considered for induction. Please note that the Park Adjusted OPS+ numbers are for a player's PBRL stats only. The following is a link to the NNL Leaderboards as well as statistics and notes on all players with significant NNL experience currently being considered for induction: LINK Significant NNL stats previously unlisted were added to a handful of players' resumes. Please don't overlook these new resources. 10 vote maximum, anyone can vote. Go to it! Batters Name - Park Adjusted OPS+ - Notable Accomplishments 1B Chet Farnsworth (1947-1962) - 127 – 6-time All-Star, 2 Gold Gloves, 351 HR New: C Lyman Wilder (1961-1966) - NA – Negro Leaguer made debut at age 33, .313 hitters, 1-time All Star selection New: C David Puddy (1945-1966) - 99 – 4-time All-Star, 4 Gold Gloves, 1900 hits, 102 HR 1B Willie Palmer (NNL* 1950-1953, PBRL 1954-1964)* - 126 - 1-time All-Star, 6 Gold Gloves, 318 home runs, 8 times top-10 RBI in the league 2B Stuart Archibald (1934-1954) - 117 - ROTY, 6-time All-Star, 1 Gold Glove, 1300+ runs and RBI, 749 SB 2B Ray Johnson (1941-1958) - 113 - 1 BOTY, 1 Gold Glove, 7-time All-Star, 1168 SB, 1328 runs 2B Toby Shaftoe (1938-1952) - 118 – 1 BOTY, ROTY, 4-time All-Star, 2 Gold Gloves, lead NL in OBP 6 times New: SS Algernon Williams (1962-1966) - 134 – Negor Leaguer debuted in the majors at age 31, 4-time All Star, New: SS Gideon Clarke (1953-1966) - 131 – 6-time All Star, 1962 hits, 104 triples, 112 home runs, hit .471 in 1961 World Series win New: SS Jesse Claymore (1952-1966) - 118 – 4-time All Star, 1791 hits, 346 HR, 1213 walks 3B Ace Mackey (NNL* 1949-1960, PBRL 1961-1964)* - X - 1 NNL BOTY, Top 10 in NNL BA, Hits, HR, and RBI in at least six seasons New: 3B Matt Urban (1950-1967) - 123 – 12-time All Star, 2 Gold Gloves, 1956 Batter of the Year, 2850 hits, 476 HR, 1943 RBI LF Ralph Olney (NNL 1948-1950, PBRL 1951-1965) - 127 - NNL BOTY at age 22 (1.091 OPS), 2-time All-Star, 2 Gold Gloves, 333 HR, 1458 BB New: LF Johnny Iosim (1951-1966) - 127 – 2-time All Star, 2088 hits, 197 triples, 317 SB New: LF Dutch Hendricks (1954-1966) - 142 – 6-time All Star, 1954 Rookie of the Year, 378 home runs, 1202 RBI CF Frank Bellisimo (1943-1957) - 119 - ROTY, 8-time All-Star, 10 Gold Gloves, 1254 RBI New: CF Charlie Allnut (1953-1967) - 129 – 4-time All Star, 1953 Rookie of the Year, 2235 hits, 340 HR RF Ray McCrory (1941-1960) - 130 – 6-time All-Star, 2 Gold Gloves, .318 BA, 1200+ runs and RBI New: RF Jeffrey Lebowski (1950 -1967) - 132 – 5-time All Star, 1963 Batter of the Year, 1950 Rookie of the Year, 377 HR, 2764 hits Pitchers Name - Park Adjusted ERA+ - Notable Accomplishments SP Gerald Boodoo (1952-1965) - 130 – 1 POTY, ROTY, 6-time All-Star, Top 5 in ERA 4 times, Threw Back-to-Back No Hitters SP Chip Cockburn (1946-1960) - 130 – 3-time All-Star, Top 5 in lg ERA twice, 1 No-hitter SP Garreth Shanahan (1943-1957) - 136 – 1 POTY, ROTY, 2-time All-Star, Top 5 in lg ERA 7 times SP George Thorogood (1941-1957) - 130 – 254 wins, 3-time All-Star, Top 5 in lg ERA 5 times, 1 Perfect Game SP Millard Upchurch (1933-1955) - 121 - 258 wins, 8-time All-Star, Top 10 in lg ERA 8 times New: SP Gerard Houarner (1956-1966) - 129 – 1-time All Star selection, 145-84 record, 2-time 20 game winner New: SP Stanley Loudry (1946-1966) - 165 – 9-time All Star, 354 wins between NNL and ML, 4 rings, won 21 games at age 39 New: SP Chet Boyd (1951-1967) - Not in top 150 – 2-time All Star, 245 wins, last pick of the draft in 1951 New: SP Arthur Jackson (1955-1967) - 132 – 4-time All Star, 204 wins, 3-time 20 game winner, Approaching Eligibility 1974 - Arturo Dueñas, Walter Hammersmith, Edward Blake, Joe Hardy, George Starkweather, Mills Robbins, Juan Rodriguez, Carl Sears, Hooper Smith, Bill Ramsey 1975 - Bob Bisby, Walter Kowalski, Terry Bollea, John Homer, Chelsey Sullenberger, Dan Huckstep, Norman Simmons 1976 - Johnny Dorian, Don Draper, Vance Ransom, Darryl Grissom 1977 - Joseph Suozzi, August Campbell, Sheldon Cooper, Tory Hurley, Pervis Floyd, Pete Poundstone 1978 - Barney Brubaker, John Kruger, Robert Howard, Fuzzy Dawkins Last edited by DamnYankees; 02-20-2010 at 10:45 AM.

02-16-2010, 10:54 PM	#4
metsgeek Hall Of Famer Join Date: Dec 2002 Location: Norwood, MA Posts: 5,450	Urban Olney Hendricks McCrory Mackey Archibald Bellisimo Loudry Boodoo Shanahan __________________ Commissioner - PBRL - Just finished 2009 109 seasons and still running strong!!!

02-14-2010, 10:51 AM	#2
DamnYankees All Star Starter Join Date: Jun 2004 Posts: 1,644	Archibald Johnson Clarke Urban Loudry

02-17-2010, 12:16 AM	#5
CatKnight All Star Starter Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Cleveland, OH Posts: 1,199	Farnsworth Urban Hendrick McCrory Lebowski Boodoo Shanahan Upchurch Loudry

02-22-2010, 05:35 PM	#6
DamnYankees All Star Starter Join Date: Jun 2004 Posts: 1,644	Bump.