Players who are too good/bad

[Bamford]

Hey Guys,

I was wondering who you had on your save games who you thought have been overpowered and people who are not so good. For example for my Astros career

Good: Ventura - traded a relief pitcher and an AAA player for him and ive found him to be really good.

Bad: Altuve - pains me to say it as an Astros fan but ive found that Altuve just doesnt have the necessary power to get consistent base hits

Who have you found to be really good/underperforming?

[ra7c7er]

It's really hard to say personally because with the randomness of player development a bad player in your version may not be the same as in my league.

Without giving specific people though I can say it's pretty common to see people out perform their ratings consistently over their career. The opposite also.

[The Game]

Originally Posted by Bamford

Hey Guys,

I was wondering who you had on your save games who you thought have been overpowered and people who are not so good. For example for my Astros career

Good: Ventura - traded a relief pitcher and an AAA player for him and ive found him to be really good.

Bad: Altuve - pains me to say it as an Astros fan but ive found that Altuve just doesnt have the necessary power to get consistent base hits

Who have you found to be really good/underperforming?

some players from my EBL vs MLB league that I was surprised at how good they were vs RL.
Hee Sop Choi something like a .280 lifetime hitter with around 250 career HR
Brandon McCarthy winning the 2022 CBF POTY at age 40. Has the most wins in that league over the last 12 sns.

Players that sucked.
Sammy Sosa .231 255 HR
Mark Buehrle a RP most of his career. Now my league was started in 1999 and has been on OOTP since 13.