Notes from history

[amead17]

CLARKE CROSSES 1,000 RUNS IN PIRATES’ VICTORY

By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times
June 4, 1904

Pittsburgh leader reaches milestone in win over Superbas

The Pittsburgh Pirates enjoyed a fruitful afternoon in Brooklyn today, securing a 4–2 triumph over the Superbas. Beyond the tally in the standings, the contest carried added significance, as team captain and manager Fred Clarke recorded the 1,000th run of his career. The victory improves the Pirates’ mark to 26–20, keeping them firmly in the hunt near the top of the National League table.

Clarke’s milestone came in the seventh inning, when he led off with a sharp double. Ginger Beaumont promptly advanced him to third with a single, before veteran Sam Dungan drove him home with another base hit. That run stretched Pittsburgh’s advantage to 3–1, and by inning’s close, they held a 4–1 lead that proved decisive.

For the day, Clarke went 1-for-3, drawing two walks and scoring two runs, raising his season average to .322. It was a fine performance from a man who continues to excel both with the bat and from the dugout.

Clarke, who broke into the majors with the Louisville Colonels in 1894 and has steered the Pirates since arriving in 1900, now boasts a career batting mark of .318—a testament to his enduring class at the plate.

Speaking afterwards, Clarke reflected on his achievement with characteristic modesty. “A thousand runs is a fine number, to be sure,” he said. “But no man crosses the plate a thousand times without good fellows behind him with the bat. I’ve been fortunate to play with strong clubs.”

As manager, Clarke cast his gaze forward: “This is a pleasing milestone, but what matters most is where we stand come September. The Pirates have the quality to contend, and if we keep to our work, I believe we shall be in the thick of it.”

The Pirates will continue their road stand tomorrow, buoyed not only by victory, but by the steady leadership of their player-skipper who continues to write his own chapter in the game’s history.

[amead17]

JOE KELLEY REACHES 2,000 HITS AS BEANEATERS EDGE SUPERBAS

By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times
June 25, 1904

Boston veteran marks milestone in 4–3 triumph at Brooklyn

The Boston Beaneaters came away from Brooklyn today with a narrow 4–3 victory over the Superbas, and in so doing witnessed a moment of lasting significance for one of baseball’s most reliable hitters. Veteran outfielder Joe Kelley collected the 2,000th hit of his illustrious career, cementing his place among the game’s greats.

Kelley’s milestone arrived promptly in the first inning, when he laced a clean single to center. Though the knock did not result in a run, it assured his name further distinction in the record books. On the afternoon, Kelley went 2-for-4 with a walk and a run scored, lifting his season average to .257.

For his career, Kelley is a .325 hitter, having plied his trade since 1891, when he broke into the majors as a 19-year-old. A seasoned campaigner now in his 30s, he has worn the Beaneaters’ colors since 1902, after arriving in Boston via trade.

Speaking after the contest, Kelley was quick to deflect the praise. “Two thousand hits—it sounds like a great number, and I’m proud to have reached it,” he said with a smile. “But every hit I’ve ever made only counts if it helps the club win. I’m glad today it came in a victory.”

Manager Frank Selee, who has guided the Beaneaters through many a hard-fought season, lauded his veteran’s accomplishment. “Joe Kelley has been the sort of ballplayer every manager wishes to write in the lineup,” Selee remarked. “Two thousand hits do not come by accident—it’s the result of years of discipline, steady play, and no small measure of talent. Boston is fortunate to have him.”

Though the Beaneaters remain below the break-even mark at 29–34, the club hopes that Kelley’s achievement will inspire steadier fortunes as the season presses on.

[amead17]

By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times
July 1, 1904

ATHLETICS AND CUBS SET THE PACE AS SUMMER BEGINS

Philadelphia and Chicago establish themselves as league leaders; June awards announced

As the season turns into the hot months of summer, the shape of both major leagues is becoming clearer, with a pair of strong frontrunners beginning to assert themselves.

In the American League, the Philadelphia Athletics have seized command, holding a 4½-game lead over the Boston Americans with a record of 41–26. The Detroit Tigers remain within sight, standing five games off the pace in third. At the opposite end, the Washington Senators continue their familiar struggles, trailing by 14½ games, with the Chicago White Sox only slightly better at 13½ games back.

The National League has witnessed notable shifting in June. The Chicago Cubs now stand atop the circuit at 41–27, two and a half games clear of the New York Giants. The Cincinnati Reds linger close behind, four and a half games adrift of first. Meanwhile, the Philadelphia Phillies find themselves in dire straits, rooted to the bottom with a mark of 25–42, fully 15½ games from the summit.

June’s Distinguished Performers

American League

Top Batter: Dave Brain, Chicago White Sox — .357 batting average, 4 home runs, 14 runs batted in, 19 runs scored.

Top Pitcher: Wiley Piatt, Philadelphia Athletics — 6–1 record, 1.19 earned run average.

Rookie: Mike Lynch, Cleveland Naps — 5–2 record, 1.33 earned run average.

National League

Top Batter: Bill Keister, Brooklyn Superbas — .442 average, 1 home run, 9 runs batted in, 11 runs scored.

Top Pitcher: Doc Newton, Cincinnati Reds — 5–1 record, sparkling 0.83 earned run average.

Rookie: Frank Smith, Chicago Cubs — 4–2 record, 0.99 earned run average.

The summer campaign now promises no shortage of drama. With the Athletics and Cubs setting the early pace, challengers will need to summon their best to keep the race alive into autumn.

[amead17]

TRADING DEADLINE BRINGS FLURRY OF DEALS ACROSS THE MAJOR LEAGUES

By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times
July 31st, 1904

Giants, White Sox, Reds, and Tigers shuffle their rosters as July closes

With July proving quiet on the fronts of both injury and milestone, the final weeks of the month brought a measure of excitement as clubs across the leagues moved to strengthen themselves before the trading deadline. Supporters were given no shortage of news as several familiar faces found themselves donning new uniforms.

The first transaction of note came on July 17, when the New York Giants sent young third baseman Pep Clark, only 21 years of age, to the Chicago White Sox in exchange for veteran Frank Huelsman. Huelsman, a thirty-year-old right fielder, has appeared in 79 contests this season, though his hitting has lagged at .199.

“It’s a surprise to leave New York so soon,” Clark admitted, “but I’m eager for the chance to prove myself with Chicago.”

On July 26, the Giants again made headlines by dispatching Jack Dunleavy, 24-year-old right fielder, to the Philadelphia Phillies. In return they secured the services of Jimmy Slagle, the experienced left fielder now in his thirty-first year. Dunleavy, who has started 78 games and carries a .219 average, expressed bittersweet feelings about the move.

“The Phillies have been struggling, but I’ll do my best to give them spark,” Dunleavy remarked. “It’s never easy leaving a club, but perhaps this is where I can settle.”

Two days later, on July 28, the Chicago White Sox dealt Roy Patterson, a right-hander with a 4–5 record and 2.55 earned run average, to the Cincinnati Reds. In return they received Cy Falkenberg, a younger pitcher at 24 years of age.

“Chicago’s been my home for some time,” Patterson said, “but if Cincinnati needs me, I’ll give them all I have.”

That same day, the Detroit Tigers parted ways with their long-serving left fielder, Ducky Holmes, sending the 35-year-old to the Giants. In exchange, Detroit welcomed catcher Frank Bowerman, also 35, and 24-year-old left fielder Frank Owen. Holmes, hitting .269 in 75 starts this season, was reflective.

“I’ve worn many uniforms in my years, and I’ll wear the Giants’ with pride,” Holmes stated.

The final and most striking deal was completed on July 31, as the White Sox traded Fred Glade, a dependable right-hander with an 11–9 mark and 2.06 earned run average, to the Cincinnati Reds. In exchange, the Sox secured outfielder Sam Crawford, 24, who has been a steady bat for Cincinnati with a .279 average across 70 starts.

“It’s never easy to leave the club where you’ve made your name,” Crawford commented, “but Chicago offers new challenges, and I mean to rise to them.”

With the trading season now closed, the coming months will tell whether these maneuvers strengthen the hand of the contenders or merely shuffle the fortunes of those struggling at the foot of the table.

[amead17]

PENNANT RACES TAKE SHAPE AS AUGUST ARRIVES

By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times
August 1, 1904

Athletics cling to slim lead, Cubs begin to break away, Phillies in ruins

With the calendar turned to August, the great game enters its final stretch, and the complexion of the races in both leagues is becoming clearer by the day.

In the American League, the Philadelphia Athletics remain perched atop the table with a mark of 57–36, though their advantage has been trimmed to but two and a half games. The Boston Americans are proving relentless pursuers, while the Detroit Tigers remain within striking distance should either falter. At the foot of the ladder, the Chicago White Sox have now slipped into the cellar. Trailing the leaders by a full 18 games, they appear adrift as the season presses forward.

Across the way in the National League, the Chicago Cubs have seized firm command of the race. With a record of 60–35, they now hold a six-game cushion over their closest challengers, the resurgent Pittsburgh Pirates, who made up ground throughout July. The New York Giants, strong in the early weeks, have lost step and now look upward in frustration. For the Philadelphia Phillies, however, there is only misery. At 32–62, they own not only the league’s cellar but the poorest mark in all of baseball, sitting 27½ games behind the mighty Cubs.

Monthly Honors

American League

Top Batter: Nap Lajoie, Philadelphia Athletics — .380 average, 1 home run, 18 runs batted in, 20 runs scored.

Top Pitcher: Harry Howell, Philadelphia Athletics — 5–1 record, sparkling 1.20 earned run average.

Rookie: Pete Hill, Washington Senators — .363 average, 19 runs batted in, 19 runs scored.

National League

Top Batter: Bobby Wallace, St. Louis Cardinals — .400 average, 10 runs batted in, 16 runs scored.

Top Pitcher: Kid Nichols, Chicago Cubs — 6–1 record, 1.33 earned run average, the veteran showing no signs of wear.

Rookie: Ed Walsh, Brooklyn Superbas — 6–1 record, 3.08 earned run average, a bright star rising in Brooklyn.

The dog days of August shall test the mettle of every club. The Cubs and Athletics hold the whip hand, yet in the long and grinding summer campaign, no lead is entirely safe until the pennant has been secured.

[amead17]

GIANTS EDGE PHILLIES, BUT LOSE HESS FOR SEASON

By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times
August 2, 1904

New York victory overshadowed by grievous blow to pitching corps

The New York Giants secured a narrow 2–1 triumph over the Philadelphia Phillies at the Polo Grounds yesterday, yet their celebration was muted by the grim loss of pitcher Otto Hess, whose injured arm has ended his campaign. The victory, decided by two tallies in the sixth frame, raised New York’s mark to 53–42 and kept them within striking distance in the National League chase.

The mishap befell Hess in the fifth inning. After delivering a pitch, he clutched at his elbow with a look of anguish and motioned for the trainer. The medical men hurried to his side, and it was immediately clear his day was done. He was led to the clubhouse to undergo further examination.

The diagnosis was dispiriting: Hess has suffered a torn ligament in his pitching arm, an injury that will require nearly ten months of recovery. The left-hander, who has carried a heavy burden for the Giants this season, finishes with a mark of 11–13 and a glittering 2.19 earned run average. His availability for the opening of the 1905 season remains in grave doubt.

Hess, though clearly disappointed, managed words of resolve when approached after the announcement. “It is a hard thing to be set aside when the club is still in the thick of the race,” he admitted. “But I shall do all that is asked of me in the way of recovery, and I mean to return as strong as ever. This game has given me my chance, and I am not through with it yet.”

Manager George Davis lamented the cruel twist of fortune for both player and club. “Otto has been one of our steadiest men, and to lose him now is a sore misfortune,” said Davis. “But the season is long yet, and we must carry on with those who remain. The fellows know what is at stake, and I expect them to answer the call.”

For the Giants, the victory over Philadelphia is small solace for the greater loss. Their pursuit of Chicago and Pittsburgh grows more difficult without their southpaw stalwart.

[amead17]

DUMMY TAYLOR FELLED BY SHOULDER INJURY IN FIRST START

By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times
August 3, 1904

White Sox hurler lost for season after long-awaited chance in rotation

It was a bitter night at South Side Park for the Chicago White Sox, who fell 4–1 to the Washington Senators, but the defeat paled beside the crueler misfortune that befell pitcher Dummy Taylor. Given his first start of the year after months of patient waiting in the bullpen, Taylor’s long-sought opportunity ended in disaster as a shoulder injury forced him from the game in the seventh inning.

Taylor had held his own through six frames before calamity struck. On his first delivery of the seventh, he winced, clutching at his shoulder in pain. The trainers hastened to the mound and, after a brief examination, escorted him to the clubhouse. The sight of the right-hander departing the field brought a hush over the Chicago faithful.

The club later confirmed the worst: Taylor has suffered a torn labrum in his pitching shoulder and will be sidelined for approximately ten months, ending his season and casting doubt on his readiness for the opening of 1905. For the campaign, Taylor departs with a mark of 1–3 in one start and nine relief appearances, carrying a tidy earned run average of 2.76.

Though clearly disheartened, Taylor spoke with determination after the announcement. “It is a cruel thing to be set aside just as I was given my chance,” he remarked. “But I have faced obstacles before, and I mean to fight my way back to the mound. Chicago has shown faith in me, and I will not let that faith go unanswered.”

Manager Clark Griffith voiced both sympathy and admiration for his stricken hurler. “Taylor worked hard, waited his turn, and when it came he gave us all he had,” Griffith said. “This game can be merciless, but the lad has the heart for the fight. We shall miss him, but I have no doubt he will return to us in due course.”

For the White Sox, now standing at 40–55, the loss of Taylor is another in a season already marked by setbacks. Yet in the words of Griffith, “the club must march on.”

[amead17]

KID NICHOLS STRIKES OUT 2,000TH BATTER IN CUBS’ VICTORY

By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times
August 3, 1904

Chicago ace reaches historic mark as Cubs down Giants, 5–2

The Chicago Cubs continue their march atop the National League, claiming a 5–2 triumph over the New York Giants today at the Polo Grounds. While the victory added another notch to Chicago’s tally, the day belonged to veteran hurler Kid Nichols, who etched his name yet again into the record books by recording his 2,000th career strikeout.

The moment came in the bottom of the eighth with the Cubs ahead 5–1. Giants outfielder Ducky Holmes strode to the plate, only to be caught looking as Nichols delivered a masterful third strike that froze the veteran in his tracks. The milestone was greeted with hearty applause from the Chicago bench, though the cheers were dampened a batter later when Nichols surrendered a solo home run.

Still, the blemish could not mar the occasion. Nichols finished the day steady and victorious, improving his season mark to 14–11 with a sterling 1.63 earned run average. His career, which began in 1890 when he was but a fresh-faced 20-year-old, now boasts a glittering 373–224 record and an ERA of 2.97. Since joining the Cubs via trade in 1902, Nichols has remained the linchpin of the Chicago staff.

Nichols was characteristically modest in reflecting on his achievement. “I’ve always tried to pitch to win ballgames first, and the numbers take care of themselves,” he said with a faint smile. “Two thousand strikeouts is a fine thing, but what pleases me most is helping this club stay out in front.”

Cubs manager Tom Loftus lauded both the victory and his ace’s milestone. “Kid Nichols has given this game more than a decade of greatness, and he still pitches with the fire of a man half his years,” Loftus declared. “We are fortunate to have him leading our staff as we chase the pennant.”

With the win, the Cubs now stand at 62–35, keeping themselves firmly ahead of the pack in the National League race. For Nichols, the day was a fitting testament to a career already gilded with triumphs, yet still burning bright.

[amead17]

CUPID CHILDS REACHES 2,000 HITS AS CUBS BEST PHILLIES

By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times
August 12, 1904

Veteran second baseman shines in Chicago’s 7–2 triumph

The Chicago Cubs continue to assert their dominance in the National League, turning aside the Philadelphia Phillies by a score of 7–2 today on the road. The day, however, belonged to seasoned second baseman Cupid Childs, who collected the 2,000th hit of his illustrious career in the contest.

Childs reached the milestone in the third inning, leading off with a sharp single that set the table for a four-run frame. Two batters later, he came around to score the first of his two runs on the day, giving the Cubs a commanding early lead. Chicago never looked back, moving their record to 69–36, keeping them firmly at the forefront of the pennant race.

The veteran finished a perfect day at the plate, going 3-for-3 with two runs scored, raising his season average to .241. Over the course of a career that began in 1880, Childs has fashioned himself into one of the most dependable hitters of his era, carrying a lifetime mark of .293. He has been a fixture with the Cubs since arriving in 1900.

Speaking after the game, Childs expressed both pride and humility at his achievement. “Two thousand hits is a number I could scarcely imagine when I began,” he said. “I’ve simply tried to put the ball in play and do my part for the club. To have lasted long enough to reach such a mark is something I’ll cherish.”

Cubs manager Tom Loftus was effusive in his praise for his veteran infielder. “Cupid Childs has been a rock for this ballclub,” Loftus remarked. “His bat may not always flash with power, but his steadiness, his judgment at the plate, and his leadership in the clubhouse are what set him apart. Today was a fitting reward for a great career.”

For Childs and the Cubs alike, the milestone serves as both a celebration of past accomplishments and a reminder of the steady hands guiding Chicago’s present pennant pursuit.

[amead17]

WHITE SOX LOSE EXTRA-INNING HEARTBREAKER AND THEIR BRIGHTEST ARM

By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times
August 18, 1904

Young pitcher Charles Bender shelved for the season with shoulder ailment

The Chicago White Sox endured a double blow yesterday at South Side Park, dropping a hard-fought 3–2 contest to the Boston Americans in ten innings while also losing their most promising young pitcher, Charles Bender, to a season-ending injury. The defeat lowers Chicago’s standing to 50–59 on the year, further dimming their already fading pennant hopes.

Bender, who had been carrying the load as the club’s steadiest hurler, faltered not in his skill but in his health. In the second inning, after delivering a pitch, he clutched at his shoulder in visible distress. The medical staff hurried to the mound, and after a brief consultation, removed the young right-hander from the contest.

Later examination in the clubhouse confirmed the grim report: inflammation of the shoulder will sideline Bender for five months, ending his campaign prematurely. It is a cruel blow for the 20-year-old, who was in the midst of a fine season with a 10–9 record and sparkling 2.08 earned run average.

Speaking afterward, Bender tried to put a brave face on his misfortune. “I wanted nothing more than to help this club down the stretch,” he said quietly. “To be stopped like this is hard to swallow, but I will take the time needed and come back stronger. I’ve only just begun in this game.”

White Sox manager Clark Griffith lamented the loss, acknowledging the impact on his team. “This is a sore disappointment,” Griffith remarked. “Bender has been our most dependable man on the hill, and to lose him now leaves a great gap. Still, the boy has a bright future, and I have no doubt he will return to form. For us, we must carry on with what we have.”

For the White Sox, the defeat against Boston was bitter enough. But with Bender’s absence assured, the remainder of the season may prove even more trying for the South Siders.

[amead17]

REDS RESERVE HEILEMAN RULED OUT FOR SEASON

By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times
August 20, 1904

Outfielder steps away from game, to miss nine months

The Cincinnati Reds will move forward without the services of outfielder Chink Heileman, who has yet to appear in a major league contest this year. The club announced yesterday that Heileman will be unavailable for the next nine months, effectively closing the book on his 1904 campaign. No official reason was given for his absence, and the Reds declared they would have no further comment on the matter.

Heileman, who has spent the year on the reserve roster awaiting his opportunity, was thought to be in line for a late-season chance to prove his worth. Instead, his season has ended before it truly began.

Though the club remains silent, sources close to the team suggest that Heileman’s departure is not due to any dispute with the Reds. Rather, the player is believed to be taking time away to restore both his physical condition and mental well-being, with hopes of returning to the game renewed and ready in the future.

For now, Reds supporters must set aside any anticipation of seeing the young man in uniform this year. His absence may not alter the standings, but it underscores the truth that ballplayers face challenges beyond the diamond, and sometimes the hardest battles are those unseen by the crowd.

[amead17]

SEPTEMBER DAWN FINDS PENNANTS STILL UNDECIDED

By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times
September 1, 1904

Athletics and Americans in dead heat, Cubs keep Pirates at bay

As the season enters its final month, the battle lines are sharply drawn in both leagues, and the contests for the pennant promise a stirring conclusion.

In the American League, the Philadelphia Athletics cling to a slender advantage, their record putting them just one game clear of the Boston Americans. Through the dog days of August the lead has changed hands, and no follower of the game dares predict who shall prevail in October. Beyond these two rivals, no other club has kept within striking distance, leaving the stage set for a duel certain to thrill the faithful. At the other end of the ledger, the Washington Senators have stumbled to a mark of 50–69, a full 21 games adrift, and once again consigned to the league’s cellar.

In the National League, the Chicago Cubs continue to hold sway, standing 5½ games to the good over the fast-closing Pittsburgh Pirates, with the New York Giants still lurking, though 10 games removed from first. The Cubs have shown the steadiness of champions, but September is long, and the pennant is not yet secure. Meanwhile, the Philadelphia Phillies have endured a season of misery, already eliminated from contention and burdened with the worst mark in the league. Now 36 games back, the club faces the sobering prospect of a winter devoted to rebuilding.

Monthly Honors

American League

Top Batter: Harry Davis, Philadelphia Athletics — .371, 5 home runs, 22 runs batted in, 21 runs scored.

Top Pitcher: Jay Hughes, New York Highlanders — 5–1, 2.35 earned run average.

Top Rookie: Frank Corridon, St. Louis Browns — 3–4, 2.38 earned run average.

National League

Top Batter: Willie Keeler, Boston Beaneaters — .410, 17 runs batted in, 10 runs scored.

Top Pitcher: Jack Chesbro, Pittsburgh Pirates — 6–1, 1.25 earned run average.

Top Rookie: Frank Smith, Chicago Cubs — 5–2, 1.32 earned run average.

With autumn at hand, the races are finely balanced, and September promises to test the mettle of players and managers alike. By month’s end, the names etched atop the standings will have earned their laurels through fire and perseverance.

[amead17]

BECKLEY SCORES 1500th RUN AS REDS BEST PIRATES

By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times
September 3, 1904

Veteran first baseman reaches milestone in Cincinnati’s 7–5 triumph

Cincinnati’s venerable first baseman Jake Beckley added another laurel to his long career yesterday, crossing the plate for the 1,500th time as the Reds defeated the Pittsburgh Pirates 7–5 on the road. The victory lifted the Reds to 67–57, keeping their faint pennant hopes alive in the crowded National League race.

The moment came in the seventh inning, with Cincinnati trailing by a run. Beckley’s base hit set the table for a three-run rally that turned the contest, and his crossing of home plate marked the milestone tally. He would score twice on the day, finishing 1-for-5 with an RBI. His batting mark for the year now rests at .325, while his career average stands at a lofty .311.

Beckley, who began his major league service in 1888 and has worn Cincinnati’s colors since 1897, was in a reflective mood after the game.

“Fifteen hundred runs is a great many trips ‘round the bases,” Beckley said with a smile. “I’ve been fortunate to play this game a long while, and it pleases me most that I can still help the club in the heat of a pennant chase. The numbers are fine, but it’s the wins that matter.”

Manager Bid McPhee, himself no stranger to long service in the game, praised his first baseman’s durability and steady hand.

“Jake has been the anchor of this club for years,” McPhee remarked. “You know what you’ll get from him each day — a sharp bat, sure glove, and the wisdom of a veteran. I daresay no man in the league has crossed the plate with more consistency these past years. It is a worthy milestone, and the whole club salutes him.”

As September play begins, Beckley’s achievement is a reminder of the endurance and skill that have defined one of baseball’s most reliable figures. And for the Reds, every run he scores down the stretch will be as vital as the last.

[amead17]

BURKETT’S 1000th RBI WINS GAME FOR REDS

By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times
September 7, 1904

Veteran outfielder drives in winning run in dramatic 9th

Cincinnati supporters had reason to cheer today as Jesse Burkett, the steady veteran outfielder, marked his 1,000th career run batted in in the most dramatic fashion possible — by delivering the game-winning hit in the bottom of the ninth. His timely single to left secured a 7–6 triumph over the Pittsburgh Pirates at League Park and kept the Reds’ hopes, however faint, alive in the National League pennant chase. The victory lifted the club to 71–57.

Burkett, now 35 years of age, went 2-for-5 on the afternoon, also crossing the plate once himself. His winning base knock drove home the decisive tally, sending the home crowd into a roar. For the campaign, Burkett is batting .264, while over the course of his long career — begun in 1890 — he has compiled a glittering .344 lifetime average. The St. Louis native came to Cincinnati last winter in a trade and has quickly won favor with the Reds’ faithful.

Speaking after the contest, Burkett was modest about both his personal mark and his heroics.

“I didn’t think about the number when I stepped in,” Burkett admitted. “All I wanted was to bring that run across and win the game. To have it be the thousandth is a fine honor, but nothing pleases me more than seeing the lads shake my hand after the winning run touched home.”

Manager Bid McPhee praised his veteran’s reliability in the game’s tensest moment.

“That is why you want a man like Burkett at the plate in the ninth,” McPhee declared. “He has seen every sort of pitcher in his years and he knows how to keep his nerve. A thousand runs batted in is proof enough of his value, but today he showed again why he is one of the finest ballplayers of his generation.”

With September now upon them, the Reds will need every ounce of Burkett’s experience and timely hitting if they are to keep pace in the race.

[amead17]

HICKMAN HITS FOR CYCLE AS GIANTS EDGE PIRATES 11–10

By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times
September 26, 1904

New York slugger’s heroics keep pennant hopes alive

New York — It was a day of rare achievement at the Polo Grounds today, as Charlie Hickman, the 28-year-old New York Giants outfielder, hit for the cycle in a thrilling 11–10 victory over the Pittsburgh Pirates. The triumph, secured in dramatic fashion, allowed the Giants to cling to their pennant hopes with a record of 83–61.

Hickman, known for his powerful bat and bustling style of play, was in splendid form. He went 4-for-5, scoring four runs and driving home four more. The sequence began with a triple in the third inning, followed later by a towering two-run home run in the fifth. He added a sharp single in the seventh and capped his day with a ringing double in the ninth to complete the rarest of hitting feats. His only blemish came on a groundout in the third.

For the season, Hickman is now batting .270, and his performance on this September afternoon may well be remembered as one of the highlights of the Giants’ campaign.

Speaking after the contest, Hickman was characteristically modest.

“I don’t keep much account of what kind of hits I string together,” Hickman remarked with a smile. “All I know is that every time I came to bat, the boys needed a knock. If my cycle helps us stay in the hunt, then it’s worth remembering.”

Manager George Davis was quick to laud his slugger’s accomplishment.

“A cycle is a rare sight in any age of baseball,” Davis declared. “Hickman gave us everything today — power, speed, and grit. This club has fought hard all summer, and performances like his remind us why we are still in the race.”

With the season dwindling, the Giants will need every ounce of Hickman’s hot bat if they are to challenge the mighty Chicago Cubs down the stretch.

[amead17]

ATHLETICS AND AMERICANS LOCKED IN DEAD HEAT; CUBS ON VERGE OF TITLE

By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times
October 1, 1904

Pennant races tighten as season nears its dramatic conclusion

With the curtain about to fall on the 1904 season, the two great leagues of professional base ball remain alive with intrigue. Both pennant chases hold stories of triumph, heartbreak, and suspense, none more so than in the American League, where the Philadelphia Athletics and Boston Americans stand level atop the standings at 85–60.

The race between these two titans has been nothing short of remarkable, each club trading blows throughout the summer, and now poised for a finish that promises to grip the base ball public until the last out of the year is recorded. The rest of the league has long since fallen from contention, while the Washington Senators remain marooned at the bottom.

In the National League, the matter appears closer to settled. The Chicago Cubs, with a glittering record of 91–56, hold a commanding six-and-a-half game lead over the New York Giants. One more Chicago victory will all but secure the championship and crown the Cubs as the kings of the senior circuit. For the Giants, hopes of overtaking their rivals grow dimmer with each passing contest. At the opposite end, the Philadelphia Phillies continue to bring up the rear, though September was mercifully less cruel as they dropped only modest further ground. Still, at 39 games back, they are the clear cellar-dwellers of the campaign.

Monthly Honors

American League

Top Batter: Harry Davis, Philadelphia Athletics – .435 average, 4 home runs, 31 RBIs, 19 runs scored

Top Pitcher: Jay Hughes, New York Highlanders – 6–1 record, 1.74 ERA

Rookie: Pete Hill, Washington Senators – .411 average, 1 home run, 21 RBIs, 14 runs scored

National League

Top Batter: John Ganzel, New York Giants – .415 average, 2 home runs, 19 RBIs, 26 runs scored

Top Pitcher: Christy Mathewson, New York Giants – 6–0 record, 2.25 ERA

Rookie: Ed Walsh, Brooklyn Superbas – 3–3 record, 1.79 ERA

As the season winds to its conclusion, all eyes now rest upon the Athletics and Americans to see who will emerge as champion of the junior circuit, and upon the Cubs to see if they can close the door on the Giants. October promises to deliver a final chapter worthy of one of the most gripping seasons the game has yet seen.

[amead17]

ATHLETICS AND CUBS CLAIM PENNANTS; WORLD’S CHAMPIONSHIP AWAITS

By Samuel T. Kingsley & Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times
October 11, 1904

Philadelphia and Chicago faithful prepare for historic clash

The long grind of the regular season has at last reached its end, and the two pennant winners have emerged from the fray.

In the American League, the Philadelphia Athletics proved the steadier hand in the final fortnight, pulling clear of the Boston Americans to capture their first league crown by three full games. It marks a glorious moment for the Philadelphia faithful, who have waited eagerly for their club to assert itself atop the new circuit.

Meanwhile, in the National League, the Chicago Cubs secured the single victory they required early in October and never looked back, keeping their margin over the New York Giants intact at six games. For the Cubs, it is a triumph of consistency and resolve, and the promise of a greater test yet to come.

The base ball public now turns its eyes to the forthcoming World’s Championship Series, a fresh chapter in the sport’s history. It will pit two new claimants to the crown against one another, promising intrigue and excitement in equal measure.

Philadelphia will depend heavily upon the brilliance of Nap Lajoie, who struck for a .347 average this year, and upon the power of Harry Davis, whose .348 mark made him one of the league’s most feared hitters. On the mound, the Athletics will look to Eddie Plank, Harry Howell, and Wiley Piatt to deliver when it matters most.

The Cubs, for their part, boast a formidable arsenal. The veteran arm of Kid Nichols and the promising rookie Frank Smith are expected to shoulder the bulk of the pitching duties, while the bats of Grant Johnson and Frank Chance will be leaned upon to supply the runs.

Managers Speak

Athletics skipper Chris Smith, in his first season at the helm, could scarcely hide his pride:

“To guide this club to its first pennant is a privilege beyond words. These men have played with heart and purpose all summer. Boston pressed us hard, but our lads never faltered. Now we must carry that same spirit into the Championship, for we know Chicago will give us no quarter.”

For the Cubs, seasoned manager Tom Loftus, now in his fifth year directing the Chicago nine, spoke with equal confidence:

“This pennant is the fruit of steady labor and stout character. Our fellows earned every victory, and I could not be prouder. The Athletics are a worthy adversary, but I believe our blend of pitching and timely hitting can carry us through. Chicago is ready for the challenge.”

With both clubs primed for the grandest stage, the World’s Championship Series promises to be a spectacle fitting the stature of the game itself. Fans in Philadelphia and Chicago—and indeed across the nation—await the first pitch with eager hearts, for history is soon to be written.

[amead17]

ATHLETICS CROWNED WORLD’S CHAMPIONS AFTER HUMBLING CUBS

By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times
Additional Reporting by Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times
October 19, 1904

Plank’s masterful pitching and timely hitting secure Philadelphia’s first title

The much-anticipated World’s Championship Series has concluded, and it proved a decidedly one-sided affair. The Philadelphia Athletics stifled the vaunted bats of the Chicago Cubs and emerged as champions, carrying the contest four games to one.

The Athletics’ pitchers held the Cubs to but two runs in their four defeats, with Chicago’s lone triumph—a resounding 15-run outburst—standing as the exception rather than the rule. More often than not, the Cubs’ bats fell silent in the face of Philadelphia’s superior pitching.

At the heart of the triumph stood Eddie Plank, the Athletics’ left-handed marvel, whose commanding presence on the mound secured him two victories, 15 strikeouts, and a flawless earned run record of 0.00 across the series. His efforts rightly earned him the honor of Most Valuable Player.

At the plate, Monte Cross (.385) and Dave Fultz (.353) provided the steady hand that pushed Philadelphia over the line. While the A’s bats did not overwhelm, they proved timely and sufficient, taking advantage of Chicago’s faltering defense.

For the Cubs, fate proved cruel. Veteran Kid Nichols entered the series nursing an ailment that dulled his customary edge, while rookie hurler Frank Smith—though himself yielding no earned runs—suffered two defeats thanks to costly miscues in the field. At the plate, only Topsy Hartsel rose above the malaise, batting .357 and fighting gamely in a losing cause.

Players Speak

Eddie Plank, the hero of the hour, said with characteristic modesty:

“I simply tried to keep the ball where they could not drive it, and the fielders did their part behind me. To be named the best of the series is an honor, but the glory belongs to every man in this clubhouse.”

Monte Cross, whose bat rang true all week, reflected:

“We knew runs would be scarce with Chicago’s pitchers, so every chance had to count. I am proud to have done my part, but it was Plank who made the difference.”

On the losing side, Frank Smith bore his misfortune with composure:

“I pitched as well as I know how, but the breaks went against us. A man can do only so much when the ball is kicked around behind him. I shall learn from this and come back stronger.”

Topsy Hartsel, the Cubs’ lone bright spot at the plate, remarked:

“It is hard to tip one’s cap after such a series, yet Philadelphia earned it. They kept us quiet, and that is the truth of it.”

Managers Reflect

Philadelphia skipper Chris Smith, a champion in his very first year in charge, could scarcely contain his pride:

“To guide these men to the pinnacle in my first season is beyond anything I might have dreamed. They played with heart, discipline, and unity, and the city of Philadelphia can take pride in its champions.”

For the Cubs, manager Tom Loftus offered no excuses but spoke with respect:

“We were beaten by the better club this week, plain and simple. Our fellows fought, but the Athletics never gave us an opening. We shall take this disappointment and turn it into resolve for next year.”

Thus the curtain falls on the 1904 campaign, with the Philadelphia Athletics standing tall as champions of the base ball world, while the Cubs retreat to Chicago humbled but not broken. The Sporting Times tips its hat to the victors and eagerly awaits the next chapter in this growing tradition.

[amead17]

FOUR CLUBS PART WAYS WITH MANAGERS IN POST-SEASON UPHEAVAL

By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times
Additional reporting from Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times
October 20, 1904

Duffy, McGraw, Manning, and Selee shown the door as clubs chart new courses

The day after the final game of a season often brings with it as much activity as the season itself, for it is then that clubs turn their eyes toward the future. This autumn has proven no different, with four clubs announcing sweeping changes at the helm in hopes of brighter fortunes to come.

The greatest surprises come from the American League, where two respected figures have been relieved of their managerial duties.

In St. Louis, Hugh Duffy was dismissed after four campaigns guiding the Browns. His first three seasons brought finishes of sixth, sixth, and eighth, but a spark of promise emerged last year when the club rose to fourth with a 76–78 record. That progress was not enough to save him, though Duffy will remain with the club as an outfielder.

“I had hoped last season’s improvement might allow me more time,” Duffy said with quiet dignity, “but I will not let this end my base ball journey. For now, I shall return to my playing duties with full vigor, and when the right chance to manage again presents itself, I’ll be ready.”

Meanwhile, the New York Highlanders parted ways with John McGraw, who had shepherded the franchise through its move from Baltimore to New York in 1902. In his four years at the helm, McGraw’s teams placed second, eighth, third, and fifth, respectable marks but not enough to satisfy the club’s ambitions. McGraw, too, will continue as a player.

“It has been a privilege to guide this club through a challenging transition,” McGraw remarked. “Though my time as manager here is finished, I intend to give my full effort on the field. When the proper opportunity arises elsewhere, I will return to managing with greater determination.”

As expected, the Washington Senators dismissed Jim Manning, whose tenure has been marked by frustration. The Senators have finished eighth, fifth, seventh, and eighth during his four years in charge, and the capital club will seek a new voice to lift them from the cellar.

“I gave my best to the Senators,” Manning reflected, “but the results did not come. I wish the players well and hope the next manager finds the success that eluded me.”

In the National League, the axe fell hardest in Boston, where Frank Selee was relieved after a remarkable fourteen years leading the Beaneaters. Under his guidance, Boston claimed multiple championships in the 1890s and stood among the giants of the game. Yet recent seasons have been less kind, with finishes of fourth, eighth, third, and seventh. The steep drop this year proved decisive.

“I have had the honor of leading Boston through both triumph and disappointment,” Selee said. “Though this chapter has closed, I remain grateful for the years we spent at the top. I still believe I can manage winning ball, and I shall be ready should another chance come.”

Thus, as autumn deepens, these four men—Duffy, McGraw, Manning, and Selee—step aside, leaving their clubs to chart new courses for 1905. The winter will tell who takes up their mantles, and whether fresh leadership can alter fortunes long in decline.

[amead17]

SIX VETERANS TAKE THEIR LEAVE AS BASEBALL BIDS FAREWELL TO FAMILIAR FACES

By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times
Additional Reporting by Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times
October 20, 1904

Jennings, Breitenstein, Weyhing among notable names to retire from the diamond

As the curtain falls upon the 1904 campaign, the game of base ball finds itself pausing to salute a half-dozen men whose playing days have now reached their conclusion. While each season brings fresh talent to the fore, it is in October that the departures weigh heaviest, and this year six well-known figures have declared they will take no further part as players.

Foremost among them is Hughie Jennings, the fiery left fielder whose steady bat and relentless style made him a fixture in the game for twelve seasons. Jennings departs with a career batting mark of .311, a tally of 17 home runs, and 1,016 runs scored—numbers that secure his place among the memorable men of his generation.

Another to hang up his spikes is Ted Breitenstein, the left-handed hurler whose career stretched a decade. His ledger of 160 victories against 168 defeats, and an earned run average of 4.03, may not place him among the immortals, but his heart and competitive spirit were never in question.

Gus Weyhing, known to many as one of the game’s most durable pitchers, also takes his leave. Over the years he compiled a record of 267 wins against 234 defeats, with an ERA of 3.88. Few could match his willingness to shoulder the burden of innings, and he exits the diamond with the respect of all who saw him toil.

Jimmy McAleer, meanwhile, steps aside as a player but remains very much in the sport, continuing in his role as manager of the Cleveland Naps. His leadership in the dugout ensures his influence upon the game will be felt for years to come.

The other two retirees are no less deserving of note. Frank Foreman, a dependable pitcher whose career ledger closes at 89–88 with a 3.93 ERA, proved a steady hand for numerous clubs. Morgan Murphy, who departs with a lifetime batting average of .220, was long admired for his service and perseverance across many seasons.

As these six men depart the playing field, their absence will be felt keenly by teammates, supporters, and rivals alike. Base ball endures through its new stars and its young hopefuls, but it is the veterans—the men who have given their best summers to the game—who remind us each autumn that no season lasts forever.