Retire/miss seasons according to history

[Reed]

Originally Posted by twins_34

You also need to make sure transactions is on if both retire and miss seasons is on because them real transactions according to history is to fight the players that miss seasons due to war or injury cause teams had to sign the free agents they needed to replace them players and that's something you really can't do easy. This would also mean you can't have FA on, you can't have rule 5.

The settings you are turning on is better for replay mode and is the only mode they are all activated in.

If I read his post correctly, he DOES NOT have miss seasons on. Although he did ask how people play with both on.

[twins_34]

Originally Posted by Reed

If I read his post correctly, he DOES NOT have miss seasons on. Although he did ask how people play with both on.

I read this part and understood he tried it...

Originally Posted by David Watts

I've tried it and I just can't see how it's doable. Every time I've tried it, by the time I get to the second season, I have teams with only 1 SS on their roster. Only 1 guy rated to play CF. 1 catcher.

Then I see later... he said this kinda mixed in. So, makes for a very confusing post. First stating he tried what he is asking but then stating that is actually with only RATH.

Originally Posted by David Watts

This is with only retire according to history turned on. Miss seasons would result in an even bigger mess. If you play this way are you just accepting the players playing out of position with bad ratings, or do you go into each team and force trades/transactions, so team will have adequate backups?

But I think I am right, that when using both that it is probably best to also have historical transaction on? Am I not correct?
And thinking about it, if import & maintain real minor leagues is not on, that might also make for a lack of players? I know some people do like to turn that off and that can really mess up your league with lack of players.

[David Watts]

Originally Posted by twins_34

I read this part and understood he tried it...

Then I see later... he said this kinda mixed in. So, makes for a very confusing post. First stating he tried what he is asking but then stating that is actually with only RATH.



But I think I am right, that when using both that it is probably best to also have historical transaction on? Am I not correct?
And thinking about it, if import & maintain real minor leagues is not on, that might also make for a lack of players? I know some people do like to turn that off and that can really mess up your league with lack of players.

Yeah, I'm kind of all over the place at times, so sorry if I wasn't clear. I've briefly tried both options at different times. RAH by itself and RAH with miss seasons. The attempt using both combined was a total disaster. The RAH alone was much better, but I still ran into roster issues in which teams did not have backups at certain key positions.

I plan at some point to try some of the great suggestions provided in this thread.