Why the pitcher stamina problem ruins sims and really needs to be fixed - Page 2

Brad K · 02-28-2024, 04:18 PM

Concerning the stamina edits making those SPs already rated with SP stamina perform poorly, edits aside, the LTM system over rides any deviations from historical talent and makes MLB perform as it did real life. This apparently is a result of leagues not performing as they did historically. This is an unreasonable expectation when the talent in a league is different from historical.

Implementing the extra step - testing the LTM routine against the actual league - and then adjusting LTM based on that test is a solution to a non problem. People should realize that if input is different output will be different.

However perhaps the rating system doesn't create talent levels that result in plausible output. In that case the LTM solves a problem in a heavy handed way when the actual solution lies elsewhere.

02-28-2024, 04:18 PM	#21
Brad K Banned Join Date: May 2016 Location: St Petersburg Florida USA Posts: 6,693 Infractions: 0/2 (4)	Concerning the stamina edits making those SPs already rated with SP stamina perform poorly, edits aside, the LTM system over rides any deviations from historical talent and makes MLB perform as it did real life. This apparently is a result of leagues not performing as they did historically. This is an unreasonable expectation when the talent in a league is different from historical. Implementing the extra step - testing the LTM routine against the actual league - and then adjusting LTM based on that test is a solution to a non problem. People should realize that if input is different output will be different. However perhaps the rating system doesn't create talent levels that result in plausible output. In that case the LTM solves a problem in a heavy handed way when the actual solution lies elsewhere.