Notes from history

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — July 29, 1909

“HIGHLANDERS SNAP TEN-GAME SLIDE WITH LATE SURGE OVER TIGERS, 5–2”
By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times

New York, N.Y., July 29 — The New York Highlanders finally gave their weary supporters something to cheer about this afternoon, ending a long and painful ten-game losing streak with a spirited 5–2 victory over the Detroit Tigers at Hilltop Park. The win, their first in nearly two weeks, lifts the club to a 46–50 record and restores a measure of confidence to a team that began July atop the American League standings but has since fallen on hard times.

For much of the contest, it appeared the Highlanders’ misfortunes would continue. The Tigers struck twice early, building a 2–0 lead after four innings, while the home crowd sat in anxious silence. But the Highlanders stirred to life in the bottom of that same inning, knotting the score at two apiece and hinting that perhaps their fortunes were ready to turn.

The decisive blow came in the eighth inning, when Owen Wilson, the hard-swinging right fielder, stepped to the plate with two men aboard. On a 1–1 pitch, Wilson lashed a mighty drive to deep right-center that rolled to the wall for a triple, bringing home both runners and sending the stands into joyous uproar. A third run crossed before the inning ended, sealing the victory that had so long eluded the Highlanders.

On the mound, Bill Donovan was the day’s unsung hero. The sturdy right-hander went the distance, scattering seven hits and allowing only two runs over nine determined innings. His command never wavered, and his steady presence gave the Highlanders the anchor they so desperately needed.

After the game, Wilson was visibly relieved as he spoke with reporters:

“It feels like we can breathe again,” he said with a grin. “We’ve been pressing too hard, and it’s good to finally break through. I just wanted to put a good swing on the ball and give the fellows a chance to come home — it was high time we did something right.”

Manager Ismael Garcia, who has watched his club’s fortunes turn sharply in recent weeks, praised the grit his men showed in halting their slide:

“It’s been a rough month for the boys,” Garcia admitted, “but they never quit on themselves. Today they showed the fight and spirit that got us to the top earlier in the year. If we can build on this, there’s still plenty of baseball left to play.”

Whether this marks the turning point of the Highlanders’ season remains to be seen, but for one afternoon in July, the storm clouds parted, and New York baseball faithful could once again applaud their team with pride.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — July 31, 1909

“TRADING FRENZY AS TEAMS SCRAMBLE FOR PENNANT EDGE BEFORE DEADLINE”
By Samuel T. Kingsley and Arthur H. Leland, Sporting Times

As the 1909 season barrels toward its final stretch, both major leagues have witnessed a whirlwind of trading activity. With pennant races tight and every team searching for that elusive winning combination, clubs from coast to coast have reshuffled their rosters in hopes of finding the spark to carry them through September.

From July 19th through the 31st, seven trades were completed, several involving veteran names and promising young talent alike.

The first move came on July 19th, when the New York Highlanders sent 24-year-old second baseman Red Killefer to the St. Louis Browns in exchange for 30-year-old right-hander Rube Vickers. Both men are expected to serve in reserve roles, though Highlanders manager Ismael Garcia noted the value of adding pitching depth for the stretch run.

On July 26th, the Washington Senators parted with their veteran catcher Mike Grady, shipping the 39-year-old to the Boston Doves. In return, Washington received two youthful bats — Buck Herzog (LF, 24) and Jack Lapp (C, 24). Grady, who has appeared 52 times as a pinch hitter this season while batting .306, spoke warmly of his move:

“At my age, you don’t take anything for granted,” Grady said. “Boston’s fighting hard in the National League, and if I can lend a steady hand behind the plate or with the bat, that’s all I can ask for.”

A pair of July 27th trades further stirred the pot. The New York Giants dealt Harry Felix (RHP, 34) and Bruce Petway (C, 23) to the Cleveland Naps, receiving George Perring (3B, 24) and Homer Davidson (C, 24) in return — a clear swap of reserve strength for both sides. That same day, the Boston Doves continued their active dealings by trading veteran right fielder Bunk Congalton (34) to the Chicago White Sox in exchange for Joe Lake (RHP, 28) and Bill McKechnie (3B, 22). Lake has been dependable this season, holding an 8–9 record with a 3.42 ERA.

Congalton, long admired for his professionalism, seemed content with the move to Chicago:

“It’s never easy to change cities mid-year,” he said, “but the White Sox are in the thick of the fight. If I can give them a few good swings down the stretch, I’ll be satisfied.”

Two days later, the Philadelphia Athletics dealt 22-year-old center fielder Scotty Barr to the New York Giants, who sent back veteran pitcher Jim Buchanan (33). Buchanan, who holds an 8–15 record and 4.06 ERA, gives the Athletics much-needed pitching depth for the dog days ahead.
The Giants, always eager to bolster their lineup, weren’t done. On July 30th, they shipped first baseman Jake Stahl (30) to the Chicago White Sox, acquiring pitchers Pete Wilson (LHP, 24) and Doc Martin (RHP, 21). Stahl, a dependable hitter with a .296 average over 92 starts, expressed mixed emotions:

“I’ve enjoyed every moment in New York,” Stahl reflected, “but baseball’s a game of movement. I’ll bring my bat to Chicago and do what I’ve always done — try to win.”

The final and perhaps most notable move came on July 31st, as the Detroit Tigers sent Walter Ball (RHP, 30) and Wilbur Good (RF, 23) to the Cleveland Naps in exchange for Erve Beck (RF, 31). Ball has been one of the American League’s most reliable arms this year, with a 16–7 record and 2.44 ERA.
Beck, who now heads to Detroit, seemed eager for the fresh start:

“Cleveland’s been good to me,” Beck said, “but Detroit’s got that fight in them. I’m ready to give them every ounce I’ve got.”

As July draws to a close, one thing is clear: the trading season has reshaped the baseball landscape. Whether these moves prove decisive in the pennant chase will be revealed in the long, hot weeks of August — when heroes are made, and contenders fall away.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — August 1, 1909

“CLEVELAND AND PHILADELPHIA TAKE COMMAND AS JULY SHIFTS THE PENNANT LANDSCAPE”
By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times

The month of July has brought no shortage of drama across the baseball world, as both leagues saw new leaders rise to the top amid a flurry of tight contests and shifting fortunes.

In the American League, the Cleveland Naps have surged to first place, supplanting early-season favorites and now holding a 2½ game lead over the Boston Red Sox, with the Detroit Tigers just another game behind in third. Cleveland’s remarkable consistency, anchored by fine pitching and timely hitting, has turned them into the team to beat as summer rolls into August.

At the other end of the table, the St. Louis Browns find themselves mired in difficulty. They are 16½ games adrift of the leaders and 4½ games behind the seventh-place club, having endured a stretch of misfortune from which they have yet to recover.

Across the diamond in the National League, it is the Philadelphia Phillies who have made the loudest statement of the summer. A strong July has vaulted them into the top spot for the first time this season, now holding a 3-game lead over the Cincinnati Reds. Hot on their heels are the Boston Doves, Pittsburgh Pirates, and Chicago Cubs, each within striking distance, ensuring that the race remains far from decided. Meanwhile, the St. Louis Cardinals continue to struggle at the foot of the standings, now 20 games off the pace and searching for any sign of revival.

Monthly Honors

American League:

Top Batter: Ed Lennox, Detroit Tigers — .371 average, 2 home runs, 18 runs batted in, and 16 runs scored.

Top Pitcher: Harry Krause, Cleveland Naps — 7 wins, 1 loss, and a sterling 1.44 earned run average.

Rookie of the Month: Harry Krause, Cleveland Naps — the young southpaw claims both honors, a rare and notable feat.

National League:

Top Batter: Bill Keister, Brooklyn Superbas — .383 average, 27 runs batted in, and 18 runs scored.

Top Pitcher: Doc White, Philadelphia Phillies — a dominant 10–1 record paired with a remarkable 1.04 ERA.

Rookie of the Month: Dick Hoblitzel — hitting .376 with 1 home run, 13 RBI, and 13 runs scored, marking himself as one to watch in the coming years.

With both leagues entering the dog days of August, the races tighten and tempers flare. Cleveland and Philadelphia may hold the reins for now, but as the summer sun bears down and the games grow ever more meaningful, the chase for the flag remains wide open.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — August 9, 1909

“WHITE SOX LOSE MORE THAN A GAME AS ST. VRAIN’S SEASON ENDS IN INJURY”
By Arthur H. Leland, Sporting Times

Boston, Mass. — Misfortune continues to shadow Jim St. Vrain, the talented but luckless Chicago White Sox pitcher whose 1909 season has been marred by setbacks. What began as a year of hope has turned into one of frustration and pain, culminating today with an injury that will end his campaign entirely.

The White Sox fell to the Boston Red Sox by a score of 3–2, but the defeat itself seemed secondary to the sight of St. Vrain being led from the field in the third inning. The loss dropped Chicago to 51–53 for the season.

St. Vrain, who began the year in the bullpen before injuries opened a place for him in the starting rotation in mid-June, had only recently returned from another spell on the sidelines. Having missed nearly a month with an earlier arm strain, he was making just his second start since returning when misfortune struck again.

He had worked through two innings when, facing his second batter of the third, he released a pitch and immediately winced, clutching his elbow in visible distress. The trainers hurried to his aid, and it was quickly apparent that his day — and, as it turns out, his season — was done.

Following the game, the club confirmed the worst: a torn flexor tendon in the left elbow, requiring a recovery period of approximately five months. St. Vrain’s season ends with a 1–3 record over six starts and nine total appearances, maintaining a commendable 2.66 earned run average despite his misfortune.

St. Vrain, his arm bound in bandages, spoke briefly after the contest. “It’s hard to take,” he admitted quietly. “I worked all summer to get back, and now I’ll have to start over again. But I’ll be ready next spring — stronger if I can help it.”

White Sox manager Clark Griffith expressed both sympathy and frustration at the latest blow to his pitching staff. “The lad’s had nothing but bad luck,” Griffith said. “He’s a good pitcher and a good man to have on the club. We’ll miss him down the stretch, but we’ll make sure he’s taken care of and ready when the new season comes around.”

For St. Vrain, 1909 will be remembered not for triumphs on the mound but for trials endured — a year when grit met cruel circumstance, and the fates of baseball proved unkind once again.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — August 10, 1909

“TIGERS SNAP TEN-GAME SKID WITH HARD-FOUGHT WIN OVER ATHLETICS”
By George F. Winthrop, Sporting Times

Philadelphia, Pa. — After two dismal weeks that saw them tumble from contention, the Detroit Tigers at last found the tonic they needed — a much-needed victory. On this warm August afternoon, they halted a 10-game losing streak with a 5–3 triumph over the Philadelphia Athletics, a win that brought their season mark back above water at 53–51.

For Detroit, the game marked not only a return to the win column but a measure of relief for a club whose bats and confidence had both gone quiet in recent days. The Tigers struck swiftly, plating three runs in the first two innings to seize an early 3–1 lead. From there, they relied on steady pitching and timely fielding to protect their advantage. Two late insurance runs in the eighth gave them breathing room before the Athletics mounted a ninth-inning rally that fell short, closing the day’s score at 5–3.

Veteran left-hander Ed Doheny was the backbone of the victory, pitching the full nine innings with poise and endurance. He scattered six hits, allowed three earned runs, and struck out two, keeping the Athletics off balance throughout.

At the plate, Ed Lennox played a decisive role in the Tigers’ offensive spark, going 2-for-4 and contributing to three of Detroit’s five runs, a performance that helped turn the tide for a team in dire need of a lift.

Speaking after the contest, Doheny expressed quiet satisfaction. “We’ve had a rough stretch, no doubt about it,” he said. “But all it takes is one good game to set things right again. The boys played hard behind me today, and we finally caught some breaks.”

Manager Frank Selee, who has been trying to steady his club through the recent slump, praised both Doheny’s composure and his team’s resilience. “That’s the sort of baseball we needed,” Selee remarked. “Ed gave us a strong game, and the lads stayed sharp in the field. A win like this can turn things around — and it couldn’t come a day too soon.”

For Detroit, this victory may be more than just a number in the standings — it might be the spark that reignites their pennant chase as summer rolls on.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — August 17, 1909

“FRED CLARKE CROSSES 1,500-RUN MARK AS PIRATES DEFEAT CARDINALS”
By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times

Pittsburgh, Pa. — The Pittsburgh Pirates added another solid victory to their campaign today, defeating the St. Louis Cardinals by a score of 5–3 before a lively home crowd. The win marked the club’s 61st triumph of the season, bringing their record to 61–50 as they continue to press their claim in the National League race.

The day, however, belonged to Fred Clarke, whose name has long been synonymous with Pirate baseball. The veteran left fielder not only played a key role in the victory but reached a remarkable milestone — scoring the 1,500th run of his illustrious career.

Clarke wasted no time etching his name once again into the record books. In the first inning, he drew a walk and later came around to score, getting Pittsburgh on the board early. Then, in the eighth inning, with the game finely balanced, he crossed the plate again, capping the Pirates’ late surge and sealing the victory.

For the afternoon, Clarke went 1-for-2 with two walks and two runs scored, raising his season average to .282. His consistency and leadership remain vital to the Pittsburgh cause. Since making his major league debut in 1894, Clarke has built a lifetime batting average of .302 and a reputation as one of the game’s steadiest men both on and off the field.

After the contest, Clarke spoke with characteristic modesty about the achievement. “It’s just another run that helped the club today,” he said with a smile. “I’ve been fortunate to play alongside some fine hitters through the years, and they’re the reason I’ve crossed that plate so many times.”

Pirates manager Zack Brown was quick to praise his captain’s influence. “Fred’s the heart of this ballclub,” Brown remarked. “He plays the game the right way, every day. You can’t put a number on what he means to these boys — though 1,500 runs is a fine start.”

With Clarke leading the way and the Pirates continuing to find their stride, Pittsburgh’s faithful fans have every reason to believe the race is far from over.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — August 24, 1909

“BOBBY WALLACE SCORES 1,000TH CAREER RUN IN ATHLETICS’ HEARTBREAKER”
By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times

Detroit, Mich. — The Philadelphia Athletics suffered a cruel setback this afternoon, falling 6–5 to the Detroit Tigers in a contest that swung wildly from start to finish. The Athletics raced to a 4–0 lead in the first inning, only to see the Tigers claw back to 5–4 by the third. A late rally in the ninth tied the game and gave hope to the visitors, but Detroit answered in kind in the bottom half to walk away with the victory. The loss drops Philadelphia to 57–60 on the season.

Yet amid the disappointment, there was one moment worth celebrating. Veteran shortstop Bobby Wallace reached a significant personal milestone, scoring the 1,000th run of his distinguished career.

The historic tally came in the top of the ninth, as the Athletics mounted their final push. Wallace led off the inning with a clean single, then advanced steadily around the bases as successive outs moved him along. He crossed the plate on a timely single from Harry Davis, tying the score at 5–5 and briefly lifting the Philadelphia bench to its feet.

For the day, Wallace went 1-for-5 with a run scored, bringing his season average to .256. Now 35 years old, Wallace continues to show the grit and steadiness that have marked his long career since debuting in 1894. A consistent performer both in the field and at bat, he carries a lifetime average of .270 and has been with the Athletics since joining them ahead of the 1905 season.

After the game, Wallace downplayed his milestone but expressed pride in the achievement. “It’s always better when a run helps the club,” he said quietly. “I’d trade it for a win any day, but I suppose it’s nice to know I’ve been around long enough to cross that plate a thousand times.”

Manager Chris Smith was quick to praise his veteran infielder’s durability and leadership. “Bobby’s the sort of man every manager wants in his lineup,” Smith remarked. “He plays every game like it means something, and even on a day like this, he gives the younger fellows an example to follow.”

Though the loss stung, Wallace’s milestone stood as a reminder of perseverance — a testament to a ballplayer who continues to leave his mark, one run at a time.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — September 1, 1909

“NAPS HOLD FIRM AS PIRATES RETURN TO THE TOP: PENNANT RACES REMAIN WIDE OPEN”
By Arthur H. Leland, Sporting Times

As baseball enters its final, fateful month, the picture for both the American and National League pennants remains as unsettled as ever. The coming weeks promise no shortage of drama as clubs fight to hold their ground — or make one last desperate charge for the flag.

In the American League, the Cleveland Naps have continued to display steadiness and poise, maintaining their grip on first place. They stand three and a half games clear of the Boston Red Sox, while the Detroit Tigers remain in striking distance, four games further back in third. Cleveland’s balance of timely hitting and strong pitching has thus far held off all challengers.

At the opposite end, the St. Louis Browns are enduring a miserable campaign, languishing far behind the leaders and with little left but pride to play for. Their supporters have already turned their eyes to 1910, hoping for brighter days ahead.

The National League continues to offer its own share of intrigue. The Pittsburgh Pirates have clawed their way back to the summit, holding a two-game lead over the Philadelphia Phillies after a strong August surge. The Chicago Cubs, who briefly tasted first place earlier in the month, now sit three games off the pace, but with enough strength and experience to threaten down the stretch.

At the bottom, the St. Louis Cardinals have endured a woeful season, owning the worst record in either league and already turning their focus to the rebuilding work that awaits in the offseason.

With rosters now expanded for September, teams in contention will be watching their farmhands closely, perhaps calling upon a young prospect to provide the spark that could decide a pennant. Meanwhile, clubs in the doldrums will use the opportunity to test their youth and build for the future.

Monthly Awards — August 1909

American League

Top Batter: Doc Gessler, Washington Senators — .404 average, 15 RBIs, 21 runs scored

Top Pitcher: George Mullin, Washington Senators — 6–0 record, 1.20 ERA

Top Rookie: Harry Krause, Cleveland Naps — 4–3 record, 1.63 ERA

National League

Top Batter: Ty Cobb, Philadelphia Phillies — .416 average, 1 home run, 15 RBIs, 9 runs scored

Top Pitcher: Frank Smith, Chicago Cubs — 8–1 record, 0.71 ERA

Top Rookie: Frank Baker, St. Louis Cardinals — .288 average, 1 home run, 17 RBIs, 18 runs scored

As September dawns, the stage is set. The battles to come will decide who claims the glory — and who fades into the long shadow of another lost season.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — September 7, 1909

“Maddox Lost to Superbas as Shoulder Gives Way in Extra-Inning Defeat”
By George F. Winthrop, Sporting Times

It was another long and bitter day for the Brooklyn Superbas, who fell 4–3 in twelve innings to the visiting Philadelphia Phillies this afternoon. The defeat, another in a trying campaign, drops Brooklyn to 56 wins and 74 losses for the season. But the result on the scoreboard was secondary to the far graver loss suffered in the opening frame.

Pitcher Nick Maddox, one of the few bright spots in an otherwise uneven season, saw his year come to a sudden and painful end. After easily retiring the first two Philadelphia batters of the game, Maddox delivered a pitch that caused him to recoil in pain, clutching at his shoulder. The crowd fell silent as the team’s trainers hurried to his aid. After a brief examination on the mound, the young right-hander was led from the field, his season — and perhaps much more — in doubt.

The news after the game was grim. Maddox has torn a rotator cuff, an injury that will end his season and may well sideline him through the whole of next year. It is a cruel twist for the 22-year-old, who had begun to find real consistency in his first full campaign as a starter.

Despite today’s abrupt end, Maddox’s record speaks to his importance to Brooklyn’s pitching staff. From 29 starts and 42 total appearances, he compiled a 16–15 record with a 2.29 earned run average, proving one of the most reliable arms in Manager Ned Hanlon’s rotation.

After the game, a subdued Maddox spoke briefly with reporters.

“It’s hard to take,” Maddox admitted quietly. “I’ve worked all year to keep us in ballgames, and to have it end like this—it hurts more than the shoulder does. All I can do now is rest and hope I’ll get another chance to throw next year.”

Manager Ned Hanlon, clearly disappointed, praised his young hurler’s determination.

“Nick’s been a fine lad for us,” Hanlon said. “He’s shown real fight every time he’s taken the ball. Losing him now is a heavy blow, not just to the club but to the spirit of this team. We’ll miss him badly.”

With their ace gone and the season winding down, the Superbas now face a difficult final stretch — one made all the harder by the loss of a pitcher who was finally coming into his own.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — September 8, 1909

“Wiltse Fans the Phillies — Boston’s Southpaw Spins Near-Perfect No-Hitter”
By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times

For the faithful gathered at the South End Grounds this afternoon, it was a day to remember — a day when Hooks Wiltse delivered a masterpiece of pitching that will live long in the baseball annals. The Boston Doves blanked the Philadelphia Phillies 5–0, but it was Wiltse’s brilliance on the mound that turned an ordinary late-season contest into something truly historic.

The left-hander retired 27 Philadelphia batters, yielding no hits and allowing just a single baserunner — not by his own doing, but on a fielding error in the seventh inning. Up to that moment, the Boston crowd was hushed with anticipation, aware they might be witnessing the first perfect game in the history of the major leagues. The dream slipped away when first baseman John Hummell, normally sure-handed, fumbled a routine play that allowed Ty Cobb to reach safely. Still, the no-hitter stood, and the fans rose in thunderous applause as Wiltse completed the final out.

The Doves’ bats gave their hurler ample support. Three runs in the second inning provided an early cushion, and two more in the eighth sealed the triumph. With the victory, Boston improved to 68–63 on the season, keeping their hopes of a late climb in the National League standings alive.

For Wiltse, the performance capped a stellar campaign. The victory lifted his record to 19–13 with a sparkling 1.81 earned run average, cementing his reputation as one of the most dependable pitchers in the league.

A smiling but modest Wiltse spoke after the game.

“I had good command and the boys played sharp behind me,” he said. “That one error? It don’t bother me none. You can’t ask for perfection every day in this game — I’m just glad we got the win.”

Manager Kyle Jackson was effusive in his praise for his pitcher.

“Hooks was magnificent,” Jackson declared. “Every pitch had purpose, and every inning he seemed to grow stronger. The crowd knew they were seeing something special today. It’s a day Boston baseball will remember for a long time.”

Though denied perfection by the narrowest of margins, Hooks Wiltse’s performance at the South End Grounds will stand as one of the shining achievements of the 1909 season — a game of near flawlessness that reminded all present why baseball remains the grandest of contests.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — September 10, 1909

“Hawley’s Steady Hand Secures His 200th Win as Phillies Outslug Boston”
By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times

The Philadelphia Phillies kept their pennant hopes alive this afternoon at the South End Grounds, prevailing in a wild slugfest against the Boston Doves by a score of 13–8. Though the bats ruled early, the story of the day belonged to veteran hurler Pink Hawley, who entered in relief and calmly steered the contest to victory — notching the 200th win of his illustrious career.

The early going was anything but quiet. Both clubs traded heavy blows through the first few innings, with the scoreboard showing 11–7 in favor of Philadelphia before the game had even settled. Starting pitcher Doc White was relieved of duty as the Doves threatened to close the gap, and Manager Emmanuel Saavedra turned to his dependable bullpen veteran, hoping for stability amid the chaos.

Hawley answered the call in masterful fashion. Over five and two-thirds innings, he allowed no runs on just five hits, silencing the Boston bats and securing both the team’s win and his own milestone triumph. The Phillies improved to 76–57, remaining squarely in the thick of the National League pennant race.

Now in his fifteenth major league season, Hawley has transitioned gracefully into a relief role. The right-hander has appeared in 16 games this year, compiling a 2–0 record with one save and an impressive 1.07 earned run average.

After the game, a smiling but reflective Hawley spoke of what the day meant to him.

“You sit in that bullpen most days and just wait for your turn,” he said. “Sometimes it doesn’t come, sometimes it does — and when it does, you do your best to make it count. To get number two hundred like this, helping the boys win a tough one, well… that makes all those quiet afternoons out there worth it.”

Manager Emmanuel Saavedra was quick to praise his seasoned pitcher.

“Pink’s been a rock for us all year,” he remarked. “He’s the kind of man every club needs — steady, reliable, and ready when the moment calls. The way he handled those Boston bats today showed every ounce of his experience. You couldn’t script a finer way for him to reach that milestone.”

It was a day of loud bats and louder cheers, but in the end, it was Pink Hawley’s calm command that told the story — a veteran’s poise amid the storm, and a 200th victory well earned.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — September 14, 1909

“Corbett’s Season Ends in Pain as Naps Fall to White Sox”
By Arthur H. Leland, Sporting Times

The Cleveland Naps, locked in a fierce battle for the American League pennant, suffered a tough setback this afternoon at South Side Park, dropping a 10–7 decision to the Chicago White Sox. The loss leaves Cleveland with a record of 78–60, but the greater blow came not on the scoreboard, but on the mound — with relief pitcher Joe Corbett leaving the game injured after facing just two batters.

Corbett was summoned in the eighth inning, hoping to steady matters for the Naps. However, after surrendering a double and a single, the veteran right-hander grimaced in clear pain and clutched at his elbow. The trainers hurried out, but it was quickly evident his afternoon — and, as it would turn out, his season — was finished.

Both runners later came around to score, leaving Corbett charged with two hits and two runs in his brief appearance. Following the contest, the clubhouse confirmed the grim news: ulnar nerve entrapment in his pitching arm. The injury will sideline him for approximately three months, ending his 1909 campaign prematurely.

Corbett’s year has been one of shifting roles and quiet endurance. After beginning the season in the rotation, he started 29 games between April and August, compiling a 13–13 record with a 3.18 earned run average across 38 appearances. When Irv Young reclaimed his spot in the starting four, Corbett took on bullpen duty in September — a move meant to keep his arm fresh for the stretch run. Fate, however, had other plans.

After the game, a disappointed but composed Corbett spoke from the trainer’s table.

“It’s a hard way to finish,” he said quietly. “You work all season to help the club, and just when the fight’s at its fiercest, you’ve got to step aside. I suppose that’s baseball — sometimes the game gives, sometimes it takes. I’ll mend up and be ready again when spring comes.”

Manager Tom Laney expressed his sympathy for the ailing pitcher and praised his contributions.

“Joe’s been as steady a man as I’ve had all year,” Laney said. “He’s taken the ball whenever asked — starter or reliever, it made no difference to him. Losing him now hurts, both for what he gives us on the field and for the spirit he brings to the club. We’ll keep fighting, but we’ll miss his arm, no question.”

For Cleveland, the road to the pennant has grown steeper — and the clubhouse quieter — with the loss of Joe Corbett, a trusted arm now forced to watch the season’s final act from the sidelines.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — September 16, 1909

“Chick Stahl Reaches 2,000 Hits as Red Sox Edge White Sox in Thriller”
By George F. Winthrop, Sporting Times

At Huntington Avenue Grounds this afternoon, the Boston Red Sox continued their determined pursuit of the American League pennant, defeating the Chicago White Sox by a score of 4–3 in a taut and hard-fought contest. The victory lifted Boston to 77–62 for the year, keeping them firmly in the thick of the race.

For Chick Stahl, the Red Sox’s veteran outfielder and captain, the triumph carried special significance — his 2,000th career hit.

The milestone came in fitting fashion during the fifth inning, with the Red Sox trailing 2–0. Stahl stepped to the plate with two men aboard and promptly laced a sharp double into left-center, bringing both runners home and tying the game at 2–2. The Boston faithful roared their approval as Stahl stood on second, tipping his cap in quiet acknowledgment.

Stahl finished the day 2-for-3 with a walk and two runs batted in, keying the Boston offense. His performance nudged his season average to an impressive .330, a testament to his enduring consistency at the plate.

Now 36 years old, Stahl remains one of the American League’s most reliable batsmen. Since making his debut in 1897, he has maintained a career average of .307, spending the bulk of his professional life in Boston after moving from the Beaneaters to the Red Sox in 1901.

After the game, Stahl reflected modestly on the achievement.

“Two thousand hits — I suppose it means I’ve been around a while,” he said with a grin. “But I’m more pleased that it helped us win today. At this stage of the season, that’s all that matters. The personal marks are nice, but the pennant’s the real prize.”

Red Sox manager Jim Manning was full of praise for his veteran’s leadership.

“Chick’s been the backbone of this club for years,” Manning remarked. “He leads by example — steady at the plate, smart in the field, and as dependable a man as you’ll ever find. Hitting two thousand is no small feat, but the way he did it — driving in the runs we needed — that’s pure Stahl.”

As the sun set over Boston, the Red Sox left the field buoyed by both victory and sentiment — a day when experience and excellence combined to keep their pennant hopes alive.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — September 16, 1909

“Fred Clarke Steals 500th Base Despite Pirates’ 4–3 Defeat in Cincinnati”
By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times

The Pittsburgh Pirates, in their determined push to capture a second straight National League pennant, suffered a narrow setback this afternoon, falling 4–3 to the Cincinnati Reds at League Park. The defeat dropped Pittsburgh to 82–56 for the year, trimming their lead at the top of the standings but doing little to dampen their overall momentum.

While the result went against them, the day still brought a measure of satisfaction for Fred Clarke, the Pirates’ veteran left fielder and captain, who marked a new milestone in his long and distinguished career — his 500th stolen base.

The moment came in the seventh inning, with the Pirates trailing 4–3. Clarke had reached first with a single and took a long lead as Reds catcher stumbled slightly after a pitch. Seeing his chance, Clarke was off in a flash. The throw to second came too late — the steal was clean, and Clarke had etched his name further into baseball’s record books.

Though the rally fizzled there, the feat underscored Clarke’s enduring sharpness and daring on the basepaths, even in his fifteenth season in the majors. For the day, he went 1-for-5 with one run scored, keeping his season average at .289.

Since debuting in 1894, Clarke has been one of baseball’s most reliable men at the plate and in the field. Now hitting .302 over his career, he has been a fixture with Pittsburgh since joining the club in 1900, a constant presence both as a player and leader.

After the game, Clarke spoke with his usual quiet determination.

“You play this game long enough and you reach a few marks along the way,” he said. “But what I really wanted was the win. We’re still in this race, and one game won’t change that. We’ll be ready tomorrow.”

Pirates manager Zack Brown praised his captain’s longevity and spirit.

“Fred’s the kind of ballplayer every manager dreams of,” Brown said. “Five hundred steals — that tells you everything about his instincts and his will to win. He’s been setting the pace for this club for nearly a decade, and he’s still doing it.”

Though the Pirates came up short on the scoreboard, Clarke’s milestone was a reminder of why Pittsburgh remains a formidable force — a team led by a man whose blend of skill and leadership continues to define an era.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — September 22, 1909

“Nap Lajoie Reaches 2,500 Hits as Athletics Down Browns 7–1”
By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times

It was a fine afternoon of baseball at Columbia Park, where the Philadelphia Athletics turned in one of their more complete performances of the year, defeating the St. Louis Browns by a score of 7–1. The victory brought the Athletics’ record to 73–71, and for the home crowd, it came with an added measure of satisfaction as Nap Lajoie, the club’s veteran second baseman and captain, collected the 2,500th hit of his illustrious career.

The milestone came in the fifth inning, with the Athletics already holding a comfortable 5–1 advantage. Lajoie led off the frame and lashed a double to left center, a cleanly struck ball that drew a hearty round of applause from the Philadelphia faithful. He later came around to score, adding yet another run to a game that was well in hand.

For the afternoon, Lajoie went 2-for-5, scored two runs, and drove in one, lifting his season average to .295. It was the kind of steady, confident performance that has defined his remarkable career.

Since joining the Athletics in 1901 following his celebrated jump from the Philadelphia Phillies, Lajoie has been the heart and soul of the club. A professional in every sense, he now stands as one of the most accomplished hitters in the game, owning a career average of .332 since his debut in 1896.

After the game, Lajoie was typically modest when asked about his achievement.

“It’s just another day at the park,” he said with a smile. “I’m pleased to have reached that number, sure, but what pleases me most is seeing the club play good ball. The hits only matter if they help us win.”

Athletics manager Chris Smith was quick to praise his veteran leader.

“Nap is the kind of player who sets the tone for everyone else,” Smith remarked. “Two thousand five hundred hits — that’s a mark very few men will ever see. He’s a credit to the game and to this ball club.”

It was, all told, a satisfying day for the Athletics — a convincing win, a historic moment for their captain, and a timely reminder of the enduring excellence of one of baseball’s great craftsmen.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — September 28, 1909

“Tigers Snap Late-Season Slump with Ninth-Inning Rally”
By Arthur H. Leland, Sporting Times

It was a long and trying September for the Detroit Tigers, who had hopes of mounting a late pennant push in the American League, only to find the month proving unkind. Today, however, at Hilltop Park in New York, the Tigers managed to end a ten-game losing streak with a hard-fought 5–2 victory over the New York Highlanders, improving their record to 69–80. Though the win brought temporary relief, the Tigers’ season is now firmly out of pennant contention.

For much of the contest, Detroit appeared headed for another loss, trailing 2–1 going into the ninth inning. It was there that the Tigers’ bats finally found life. Charles Earle stepped to the plate and delivered a solo home run to lead off the inning, sparking the rally. The rest of the lineup followed with a combination of three hits and a walk, producing four runs and sealing the win.

Aside from Earle’s late-inning heroics, the Tigers’ day was quiet. Their pitching struggled, and the offense was largely subdued until that decisive final frame.

Earle, still catching his breath after the pivotal blast, reflected on the moment:

“I was just trying to see the ball and make solid contact. Lucky it went out and gave the boys a spark — we needed it.”

Manager Frank Selee acknowledged the difficulty of the season but praised his team’s perseverance.

“It’s been a long, hard year, and these boys have fought through plenty. Today’s rally shows their heart. We may be out of the pennant race, but this win is a good way to close the season.”

Though the Tigers’ aspirations for the pennant have faded, today’s late-inning surge provided a measure of pride and a reminder that Detroit can still swing with the best — even in the twilight of a difficult season.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — September 28, 1909

“Davis Sparks Athletics to Victory, Claims 1000th RBI”
By George F. Winthrop, Sporting Times

Philadelphia baseball fans had cause for celebration today as the Philadelphia Athletics held their heads above .500 with a thrilling 5–4 victory over the league-leading Cleveland Naps at Shibe Park. The win improves the Athletics’ record to 75–74, a small but significant bright spot in a season of ups and downs.

The day belonged to veteran first baseman Harry Davis, who notched the 1000th RBI of his career in spectacular fashion. With the bases loaded in the first inning, Davis smashed a triple into deep left-center, sending three runners home and giving Philadelphia an early 3–0 advantage. He later crossed the plate himself, extending the lead to 4–0 by the end of the inning.

Davis finished the game 1–3 with a run scored and 3 RBI, raising his season average to .275. A stalwart of the Athletics since joining them from Philadelphia in 1901, Davis has maintained a .285 career average since his debut in 1895.

Speaking modestly of his milestone, Davis said:

“I’ve been fortunate to be part of good teams over the years. This one triple meant a lot, but it’s the win for the Athletics that really counts.”

Manager Chris Smith praised his veteran leader’s performance:

“Harry Davis has carried this club through many seasons, and today he showed why. That triple and those runs gave us just the spark we needed to get the win.”

With the season winding down, the Athletics will lean on their veterans like Davis to finish strong, keeping themselves competitive as the final games of 1909 approach.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — September 30, 1909

“Pirates’ Pennant Hopes Take a Hit as Mordecai Brown Injured”
By Charles H. Wentworth, Sporting Times

Pittsburgh fans were treated to a tense 2–1 victory over the New York Giants at Forbes Field today, yet the win came at a steep price for the Pirates’ pennant aspirations. Star pitcher Mordecai “Three Finger” Brown suffered a serious elbow injury, putting a cloud over the team’s hopes for a World Series run. The Pirates maintain their league lead with a record of 87–62, but losing Brown is a heavy blow.

Brown had been dominant through the first five innings, allowing just one hit and an unearned run, when he finished the bottom of the fifth and suddenly appeared in pain, clutching his elbow as he walked from the mound. He did not return for the sixth inning, and it quickly became evident that the injury was severe.

The Pirates later confirmed that Brown had torn a flexor tendon in his pitching elbow, requiring 8–9 months of recovery. This timetable means the 32-year-old is likely to miss the start of the 1910 season as well. For the year, Brown’s record stands at 26–12 with a 1.63 ERA, underscoring his importance to the Pirates’ pitching staff.

Speaking from the clubhouse after the game, Brown acknowledged the severity of the situation:

“It’s a hard blow to the team and to me personally. I’ll do everything I can to come back strong, but I know this will take time.”

Manager Zack Brown expressed both concern and resolve:

“Mordecai has been the backbone of our pitching this season. Losing him now is a serious setback, but we must pull together and continue the fight for the pennant.”

While Pittsburgh celebrated the narrow victory over New York, fans and players alike are left to wonder how the Pirates will cope without their ace on the mound as the season draws to a close.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — October 1, 1909

“Pennant Races Enter Final Stretch as Leaders Hold Narrow Margins”
By Samuel T. Kingsley, Sporting Times

As the baseball season nears its close, the fight for the pennant in both leagues remains as tight as ever, with every game carrying tremendous consequence.

In the American League, the Cleveland Naps continue to hold a 3-game lead over the Boston Red Sox, with just three games remaining. A single win in any of these contests will secure the pennant and a place in the World Series for the Naps. Meanwhile, the St. Louis Browns have endured another difficult season, now trailing eight games behind seventh place, firmly established as the league’s cellar-dwellers.

Over in the National League, the Pittsburgh Pirates lead the chase with a 2½-game advantage over the Philadelphia Phillies, with five games left to play. The Pirates are in a favorable position but must continue winning to clinch their second consecutive pennant. The Phillies remain a formidable threat, ready to capitalize on any slip-ups. At the bottom, the St. Louis Cardinals have managed to string together some wins, moving up to seventh place, while the Brooklyn Superbas have slipped to eighth.

As the season draws to a close, outstanding performances have been recognized with monthly awards:

American League:

Top Batter: Sam Crawford, Chicago White Sox — .345, 2 HR, 19 RBI, 21 runs scored

Top Pitcher: Charles Bender, Chicago White Sox — 5–2, 1.11 ERA

Rookie of the Month: Jim Scott, New York Highlanders — 4–3, 2.97 ERA

National League:

Top Batter: Honus Wagner, Pittsburgh Pirates — .376, 3 HR, 25 RBI, 27 runs scored

Top Pitcher: George McQuillan, Philadelphia Phillies — 5–1, 1.36 ERA

Rookie of the Month: Frank Baker, St. Louis Cardinals — .364, 2 HR, 18 RBI, 20 runs scored

With only a handful of contests remaining, fans across the country can expect a thrilling finish as the leaders fight to secure glory and the laggards test the mettle of their young talent.

[amead17]

THE SPORTING TIMES — October 1, 1909

“Delahanty’s Season — and Perhaps Career — Ends in Pain as Athletics Win 3–0”
By Arthur H. Leland, Sporting Times

Philadelphia, Pa. — What should have been a routine late-season victory for the Philadelphia Athletics turned somber this afternoon at Columbia Park, as the club’s veteran right fielder, Ed Delahanty, suffered a severe injury that may spell the end of his illustrious career.

The Athletics bested the Washington Senators by a score of 3–0, lifting their record to 77–76, but the win was overshadowed by the sight of the 41-year-old star collapsing just as he crossed home plate in the fourth inning.

Delahanty had raced from third, sliding across the plate safely to give the Athletics a 2–0 lead. But as the umpire signaled him safe, the crowd’s cheers turned to anxious silence when Delahanty failed to rise. Teammates rushed to his side, joined quickly by the club’s medical staff. It was clear from the outset that the injury was serious.

After the game, the Athletics announced grim news: Delahanty has suffered a ruptured Achilles tendon, an injury expected to keep him out for eight to nine months. The setback not only ends his 1909 campaign but will likely cause him to miss the start of the 1910 season. Given his age and long career, speculation has already begun as to whether this may mark the end of the great slugger’s time on the diamond.

Delahanty, who went 1-for-2 with a run scored on the day, has proven this season that he can still compete with younger men, batting .286 across 115 games and 68 starts.

Speaking quietly after the game, Delahanty said, “It’s a hard way to end a season, maybe even a career, but I’ve been fortunate to play this long. I’ll do what I can to heal and see where it takes me.”

Manager Chris Smith expressed both admiration and concern for his veteran outfielder. “Ed’s been a leader in every sense — on the field and in the clubhouse,” Smith remarked. “You never want to see a man like that go down. If this is the end for him, he’s left a mark on this game that won’t be forgotten.”

While the Athletics celebrated their shutout victory, the day will be remembered less for the score and more for the possible close of one of baseball’s great careers.