good news and bad news about my league...

[badrazor1167]

I'm the guy that wanted to create a historical league with teams from several different decades. The good news is someone showed me how but i have a dilema of sorts...

So one of the teams in my league is the 1906 Cubs mainly because i love that pitching staff and team speed. So i look at Three Finger Brown's ratings and i'm shocked to see them low. Stuff was 54/100, movement was 71/100, control was 72/100. The guy was 26-6 with a 1.04 ERA, 0.97 WHIP. He was a beast and would continue to do that for many years. So why isn't this guys ratings off the charts? He's rated at 3.5 stars.

Now i know in the global setting of my league there are some important options regarding how players stats are being used and i apparently must have one or more of those setting wrong.

Can anyone give some advice on which settings i need to tweak to give a more accurate historical rating?

Thanks in advance!

[badrazor1167]

bump...i'm really curious if anyone has any ideas on my post

[The Game]

Originally Posted by badrazor1167

I'm the guy that wanted to create a historical league with teams from several different decades. The good news is someone showed me how but i have a dilema of sorts...

So one of the teams in my league is the 1906 Cubs mainly because i love that pitching staff and team speed. So i look at Three Finger Brown's ratings and i'm shocked to see them low. Stuff was 54/100, movement was 71/100, control was 72/100. The guy was 26-6 with a 1.04 ERA, 0.97 WHIP. He was a beast and would continue to do that for many years. So why isn't this guys ratings off the charts? He's rated at 3.5 stars.

Now i know in the global setting of my league there are some important options regarding how players stats are being used and i apparently must have one or more of those setting wrong.

Can anyone give some advice on which settings i need to tweak to give a more accurate historical rating?

Thanks in advance!

Most historical pitchers will have low stuff since most were 3 pitch guys who topped out at 90 mph. i see no problem with 3 Finger being 3.5 stars. What is Walter Johnson or Christy Mathewson rated at? Cy Young typically sucks in most RD leagues.