Well, it should be clear that when you take the best player seasons of all time and compare them to the LIVE players, that the best players of all time "should" be much better than just about anybody in that crop (with a possible exception of Mike Trout, who belongs in that rarefied company).
Now go one step further and consider that most of the historical cards rated 100 are PEAK cards, so are based on more than one season.
The only issue is that they appear to have a 40-100 scale for current players AND for historical all-stars., So the OVR scales are not comparable. So, naturally a 100 for a Babe Ruth, or Joe Dimaggio, or Ted Williams, etc. PEAK card is going to be tons better than a 100 LIVE card.
|