Billy Geer, 1874 (Major), 1884 (Minor)
Gus Alberts, 1884 (major and minor)
Ed Brown, 1884 (minor), 1882 (major)
Andy Cusick, 1884 (major and minor)
Jack Gorman, 1883 (major) and 1884 (minor)
Mortimer Hogan 1884 (major and minor)
Harry Jacoby, 1882 (major) and 1884 (minor)
Ed Kent, 1884 (major and minor)
Johnny Lavin, 1884 (major and minor)
Bill McCloskey, 1875 (major) and 1884 (minor)
Frank McLaughlin, 1882 (major) and 1884 (minor)
Ed miller, 1884 (major and minor)
Tom Morrissey, 1882 (major) and 1884 (minor)
Harry Weber, 1884 (major and minor)
Wash Williams, 1884 (major and minor)
Two different John Horan under the same name in the database for 1884
https://www.baseball-reference.com/p...oranjo01.shtml (major)
https://www.baseball-reference.com/r...=horan-003joh# (minor)
The player listed as U Laughlin is listed in Baseball Reference as Bill Loughran
https://www.baseball-reference.com/p...oughbi01.shtml