Replacing Simmons with a terrible fielder doesn't change the fact that the SS himself isn't costing you more than one game. You're talking about something else entirely. And if he is, likely his bat is so amazing that he's winning you more games with his bat than he costs you with the gloves. It if he's legitimately that had he's moved off the position.
Either way it's extremely unlikely a guy costs you two wins defensively at SS.
|