Aiden Massicotte, 1B
Massicotte was a force for many years in the Royals lineup. He was a great contact hitter, speedy baserunner, and elite fielder. He is the first player to enter the Hall of Fame as a first baseman. His 2524 hits are second in MLB history, 288 doubles are first, and 1143 stolen bases are first. He won one MVP award, 6 gold gloves, 4 silver sluggers, 2 World Series, and went to 6 all-star games. He was drafted 34th overall in 1904 out of the University of Michigan.
Career Stats: 9603 PA, 2524 H, 1143 SB, .335 wOBA, 117 wRC+, 204 ZR, 62.5 WAR, 53.5 JAWS
Oliveiro Mendez, 3B
Mendez spent his entire career with the Indians, which led to three all-star teams, 4 silver sluggers, an AL Division Series MVP, and a World Series. He was drafted 8th overall out of Villanova in 1909.
Career Stats: 7169 PA, 1845 H, .342 wOBA, 115 wRC+, 5.3 ZR, 39.9 WAR, 37 JAWS
Kendrick Kalamari, SS
Kalamari was drafted 8th overall out of USC in 1908. He won two gold gloves, went to one all-star game, and won a World Series. He was a solid, steady performer at a difficult position for many years and was especially known for his glove.
Career Stats: 7815 PA, 1680 H, .307 wOBA, 94 wRC+, 184.2 ZR, 42.5 WAR, 37 JAWS
Luke McCaffrey, C
McCaffrey spent his entire career with the Blue Jays after getting drafted 61st overall in 1906 out of LSU. He won two silver sluggers and went to one all-star game. He was able to provide average offense with above average defense at catcher for many years.
Career Stats: 5442 PA, 1284 H, .311 wOBA, 102 wRC+, 12.5 ZR, 34.2 WAR, 30.2 JAWS
Walker Rosen, LF
Rosen had a very impressive peak, though his value dropped quickly after he turned 30. He was drafted 31st overall in 1911 out of the University of Michigan. He won one MVP, one gold glove, 6 silver sluggers, went to 4 all-star games, and was an AL Division Series MVP. He often led the league in triples and ranks 6th in MLB history in that category.
Career Stats: 6040 PA, 1715 H, 475 SB, .368 wOBA, 42.5 ZR, 37.8 WAR, 37 JAWS
Tucker Connally, C
Connally won two gold gloves, went to two all-star games, won two silver sluggers, and was a World Series champ. He was the Dodgers catcher from 1908 through 1922 after getting drafted 23rd overall in 1907 out of Oklahoma.
Career Stats: 6044 PA, 1244 H, .295 wOBA, 89 wRC+, 31.5 ZR, 30.6 WAR, 26.5 JAWS
Toussaint Antoine, CF
Antoine was drafted 61st overall in 1912 out of Loyola Marymount. He won a gold glove and a silver slugger and went to two all-star games. He had a very good 5-year run of 5-6 WAR but not much after he turned 30.
Career Stats: 4878 PA, 1184 H, 440 SB, .314 wOBA, 98 wRC+, 69.7 ZR, 29.3 WAR, 29.0 JAWS