Quote:
Originally Posted by Argonaut
Yes, the math should line up the way you say. But I still believe a 4.0 WAR defensive shortstop has much more value than a 4.0 WAR offensive shortstop in OOTP. I have admitted this is an entirely anecdotal observation. The Pirates example was just one I can think of, other things have given me the same feeling.
|
I certainly wasn't trying to "call you out" or anything such stupid thing
Just in a thread about "What do you think of WAR" trying to off any "see WAR sucks" comments at the pass.
It's entirely possible that OOTP's WAR undercounts defensive WAR.
That would *in no way* invalidate any real world WAR or WAR as a concept any more than OOTP calculating batting average incorrectly would invalidate batting average.