Aiden Shelton, CF
Aiden Shelton retires as one of the best batters ever to play the game and easily the top CF, surpassing Yun-ho Chun. He won two MVP awards, went to 6 all-star games, and won two silver slugger awards in his MLB career after getting drafted 1st overall out of Pendleton High School in Oregon. His 2531 hits is the current MLB career record and his 1069 SB are 2nd most in MLB history. He played good CF defense most of his career until he turned 33, when his value became very negative, taking away all of his career value at the position.
Career Stats: 10321 PA, 2531 H, 1069 SB, .341 wOBA, 119 wRC+, -27.3 ZR, 65.8 WAR, 55.0 JAWS
Benny Wurdeman, SS
Wurdeman's strength came from his ability to stick at the shortstop position for over a decade while providing around average offensive output. He had a career year in 1910, winning the NL MVP. He also went to 6 all-star games in his career. He was drafted out of College Station High School in 1904 in the Supplemental 1st Round.
Career Stats: 6861 PA, 1574 PA, .313 wOBA, 102 wRC+, 694 SB, 145.9 ZR, 52.3 WAR, 45.5 JAWS
Goran Williams, LHP
The second-best LHP in history after J.P. Avila. He put up consistent 5+ WAR seasons from 1907 through 1919, going to 6 all-star games and winning a gold glove. He was also part of the Phillies 1919 championship team. He was drafted in the 4th round out of the University of Pittsburgh in 1903.
Career Stats: 3658 IP, 694 BB, 1464 K, 2.38 FIP, 83 FIP-, 77.4 WAR, 54.2 JAWS
Ryder Jackson, RHP
Jackson's value closely mirrors that of Hall of Famer Jeff Marcum. He had a great peak, winning the Pitcher of the Year in 1913, making two all-star teams, and winning three world series. He was drafted in the Supplemental 1st round in 1903 out of Arizona.
Career Stats: 3501.7 IP, 949 BB, 1557 K, 2.59 FIP, 94 FIP-, 55.5 WAR, 49.7 JAWS
Joseph Williams, C
Williams had a very good career as a catcher - 4 all-star teams, 3 silver sluggers, one AL Division Series MVP, and one World Series championship. He spent a majority of his career with the Houston Astros, getting drafted by them 11th overall in 1905 out of Oklahoma.
Career Stats: 5565 PA, 1259 H, .311 wOBA, 100 wRC+, -10.5 ZR, 30.5 WAR, 26.5 JAWS
Chris Adams, RHP
Adams was born in Fond du Lac, WI and attended McFarland High School, where he was drafted in the 2nd round of the 1907 draft. He had a great start to his career and was on the Hall of Fame path until injuries took over his body and forced him to retire. He won one Pitcher of the Year award and went to 6 all-star games.
Career Stats: 2095 IP, 384 BB, 1004 K, 2.32 FIP, 80 FIP-, 48.8 WAR, 44.3 JAWS
Kyle Martin, RHP
Martin put together a solid career, always hanging out just below the elite pitching level for over 10 years, most of those with the Yankees. He was drafted in the 4th Round out of Boston College in 1904 and won a Gold Glove as well as a World Series.
Career Stats: 3229 IP, 733 BB, 1209 K, 2.58 FIP, 94 FIP-, 50.6 WAR, 42.5 JAWS
Connor Demetriou, 3B
Demetriou was a slugging 3B, winning the silver slugger 4 times over his career along with a World Series. He was drafted 21st overall in 1906 by the Red Sox out of Missouri.
Career Stats: 5906 PA, 1765 H, .385 wOBA, 150 wRC+, -20.3 ZR, 33.4 WAR, 28.5 JAWS
Mike Strauch, RHP
Strauch was actually part of the initial players at league creation - starting in Rookie ball in 1900. He worked his way up to the Major Leagues and played until he was 40 as a steady average pitcher.
Career Stats: 2927.7 IP, 776 BB, 919 K, 2.90 FIP, 103 FIP-, 34 WAR, 35.5 JAWS
Dwain Noftle, RHP
Noftle won the World Series with the Dodgers in 1906 and was also part of the initial players at league creation, starting in A.
Career Stats: 2307.3 IP, 629 BB, 924 K, 2.65 FIP, 103 FIP-, 25.5 WAR, 31.8 JAWS
Simon Frasco, LHP
Frasco won the Reliever of the Year in 1916 and was sent to one all-star game. His 285 saves ranks 10th all-time. He was drafted with the 14th pick of the 2nd round in 1906 out of Boston College.
Career Stats: 742.7 IP, 284 BB, 509 K, 285 SV, 2.35 FIP, 84 FIP-, 22.3 WPA, 17.2 JAWS
Sean Becker, LHP
Becker also won one Reliever of the Year and was selected to one all-star game - both in 1912. He was drafted by the Tigers in 1902 with the 58th pick out of Sheldon High School in Oregon.
Career Stats: 673.3 IP, 196 BB, 364 K, 128 SV, 2.20 FIP, 79 FIP-, 19.8 WPA, 13.7 JAWS