[Reed]

Estave also had more rbi’s and runs. A lot more stolen bases and apparently a much better defensive player. If you look primarily just at their batting then yes Pennypacker is the better player. If you look at their overall play???

IRL the player with the best combination of average, home runs, rbi’s almost always wins the MVP but until recently, they had no concept of overall value or defensive value or know the difference between batting average and on base percentage.