[bear]

Your rating for him isn't far off from what I'd have done. I see him as a borderline 2 or 3. Because he has KO'd 100% of the stiffs he fought I'd consider giving him a HP of 8 and dropping his punches landed to compensate. This is debatable. One thing I would do, though, is to raise his 3 point punches a tad. Giving a fighter too many 3 point punches can inflate his rating artificially, but we try to keep the 3 point punches within certain guidelines.

HP 3pt Range
1 0 to 3
2 3 to 6
3 6 to 9
4 10 to 12
5 13 to 15
6 16 to 20
7 21 to 25
8 26 to 30
9 31 to 36
10 37 to 42
11 42 to 44
12 45 to 47
13 48 to 50
14 51 to 54

Most of the fighters in the data base conform to this scale. There are occasional exceptions. Mark (Ice Tea) and I discussed this at the last IBHOF induction weekend. We always have confabs about the game at Canastota.

Aside from trying to open up some discussion with these points I don;t see any problem adding him to my games as he stands.