I would probably go back to ratings if they worked like how we think of things in real life, but I think they're still too accurate. And also oddly not accurate enough. It's hard to describe, but they just feel too all-encompassing, and when you see the ratings, it makes it way too easy to ignore the stats.
Going with a combination of the written scouting report and the stats I find is a great mix that gives me just enough info to judge players, but not too much that I feel like I know exactly how they will do.
|