Thread: game rating
View Single Post
Old 03-27-2013, 01:29 AM   #18
kewltalon
Minors (Rookie Ball)
 
Join Date: Mar 2013
Posts: 31
Just to clarify, I would like a game rating for a game played based on the players individual skill level. I do not like the idea of EHM's avg game rating system. For example, if a third line player played to the best of his ability he would score an '5/5'. This would not mean this player is a 5/5 player in the game. This just means this player is playing to the best of his abilities. He will not replace an all star player. A letter grade from the coach for the last game played may be a better choice, less confusion. Then if a player scores a low grade, you can then research the stats to see where he is failing.

EHM's avg rating system really ended up being an overall player rating. Higher the rating, the better the player. That was a mistake. I would rather see a rating based on his effort in game in relation to his overall skill level. Because I cannot visually see who performing, a coaches player grade would be beneficial.
kewltalon is offline