OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post

sabotai · 10-05-2004, 08:09 PM

I ran a bunch of matches to look at this. I see a lot of decisions with the judges ruling the same way, but the larger issue I see (and possibly what is causing the same decisions) is that there are way too many rounds being scored a draw.

I ran 19 fights (3 times each) for a total of 57 fights simmed. I'd say all but about 3 or 4 had a fight in which all 3 judges had at least 1 round even (and 2 of those were 1st round KOs) with at least 1/2 of them having each judge scoring multiple rounds even. I saw one fight were 2 judges had 5 rounds scored even (the other had 4). One fight, all 3 judges scored the last 3 rounds even. (EDIT: And the vast majority of the time where a round was scored even, all 3 judges scored it even. So these draw rounds aren't all over the place. The judges are basically scoring the same rounds even)

All fights were between fighters that were within 2 Overall Rating points from each other and were 12 rounds.

10-05-2004, 08:09 PM	#4
sabotai All Star Reserve Join Date: Apr 2002 Location: South Jersey Posts: 841	I ran a bunch of matches to look at this. I see a lot of decisions with the judges ruling the same way, but the larger issue I see (and possibly what is causing the same decisions) is that there are way too many rounds being scored a draw. I ran 19 fights (3 times each) for a total of 57 fights simmed. I'd say all but about 3 or 4 had a fight in which all 3 judges had at least 1 round even (and 2 of those were 1st round KOs) with at least 1/2 of them having each judge scoring multiple rounds even. I saw one fight were 2 judges had 5 rounds scored even (the other had 4). One fight, all 3 judges scored the last 3 rounds even. (EDIT: And the vast majority of the time where a round was scored even, all 3 judges scored it even. So these draw rounds aren't all over the place. The judges are basically scoring the same rounds even) All fights were between fighters that were within 2 Overall Rating points from each other and were 12 rounds.