[Whitey]

I haven't read this entire thread, so I'm sorry if this point has been made, but to me the only time you are asked is if there is a question as to whether the runner can make it or not. Sometimes runners only advance one base on hits to the outfield. I'm assuming that is a hard hit ball right at the fielder. Sometimes they score easily from second. Obviously this is a deep enough base hit that anybody could have scored. The prompt to me is only on questionable advancement.

Same goes for sac flies. The game doesn't ask you on some fly balls. The runner tags and scores. Therefore that was a deep fly ball. If the game asks, we should know that there is a possibilty the runner could be thrown out.