Yeah we have our wires crossed.
I just want to get the thing to work, it doesn't matter which year. I just found out about this utility a few days ago, after we had completed 2013 and I lost ALL of my pervious end of the year files (don't ask..).
I heard that you need to run the program at the end of the season, so I backed up my 2014 season (which is at the FA stage you are seeing) and turned all teams to CPU and simmed 2014 and ran OOTP History at the Proceed to Next Season stage. I just wanted to see if the util would wpork with our league. It still gave me that error. However, when I created a Test League (starting in 2003 with default teams) it worked fine.
I'll PM you league password.