OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post

FuzzyRussianHat · 04-20-2026, 08:30 AM

Mahtab “The Mayor” Malik – Third/First Base – Karachi Carp – 90.0% First Ballot

Mahtab Malik was a 6’2’’, 200 pound switch-hitting corner infielder from Tando Allah Yar, Pakistan; a city of around 422,000 in the Hyderabad Division. His affable demeanor earned “The Major” as a nickname for Malik. He was incredibly likeable and a team captain known for his dedication, work ethic, and intelligence. Malik was also a rock solid contact and power hitter from both sides of the plate.

His 162 game average got you 37 home runs and 30 doubles. Malik was below average for drawing walks and avoiding strikeouts, but his high slugging and average more than made up for it. On the downside, Malik was a laughably poor and slow baserunner. Around 2/3 of his career starts came at third base with lousy defensive metrics. The rest were at first base, where he graded as actually quite good with his glove. Malik also never missed any significant time to injury in his 14-year career.

Malik was picked tenth by Karachi in the 2021 ABF Draft. He was full-time on the roster right away but used mostly as a pinch hitter with only 54 starts over his first three years. Malik finally got the full-time job in 2025 and won his first Silver Slugger that year at 1B. Karachi had been mid-tier for the last few years, but 2025 saw the Carp end a 13-year playoff drought at 100-62.

They were still second in the division to 105-win Hyderabad, but the Horned Frogs got upset in the first round by Almaty. Karachi topped Dushanbe 3-1 in the first round and rolled the Assassins 4-1 to claim the East League Championship Series. The Carp were then defeated 4-2 by Mashhad in the ABF Championship. In 15 playoff starts, Malik was solid with 14 hits, 9 runs, 3 doubles, 3 homers, 8 RBI, .801 OPS, 147 wRC+, and 0.5 WAR.

Karachi got the top seed the next year at 99-63, but lost the ELCS 4-2 to Hyderabad. This was Malik’s last playoff games as the Carp wouldn’t get back in his tenure. They were rarely outright bad going .500 or better from 2027-31 and in 2033. Malik remained steady though even as the team entered perpetual mid-ness.

Malik did get a chance to play on the World Baseball Championship stage regularly from 2025-34 for Pakistan. In 118 games and 102 starts, he had 95 hits, 47 runs, 15 doubles, 27 home runs, 63 RBI, .235/.292/.478 slash, 124 wRC+, and 3.0 WAR. Malik notably was a starter for Pakistan’s first World Championship win in 2029 with 23 hits, 9 runs, 6 homers, and 14 RBI that year.

From 2025-31, he had a Silver Slugger streak winning at 1B in 2025-27 and 3B after. Karachi gave Malik a five-year, $142 million extension in August 2028. He was the leader in RBI four times, and total bases thrice. In 2027, Malik led in hits (218), total bases (416), slugging (.685), OPS (1.076), and wRC+ (224); all career bests. Surprisingly despite his 9.4 WAR, he wasn’t an MVP finalist that year.

Malik never won MVP, but did take second in 2029, 2030, and 2031. He had 9+ WAR thrice, peaking at 9.8 in 2030. 2031 saw his career best for home runs (56) and runs scored (113). After missing the honor in 2032, Malik won his eighth and final Silver Slugger in 2033 at 3B. That winter, he signed a three-year, $75,600,000 extension to stay loyal to Karachi.

Both Malik’s and the Carp’s decline began in 2034. His contact ability plummeted in 2034 and he was benched with .631 OPS, 79 wRC+, and 0.1 WAR over 105 games and 27 starts. Malik was a bit better in 2035 but was still used only sparingly with 72 games and 9 starts. He opted to retire that winter shortly after his 37^th birthday. Karachi immediately retired Malik’s #35 uniform for his 14 years of work.

Malik finished with 1967 games, 1945 hits, 962 runs, 367 doubles, 18 triples, 450 home runs, 1191 RBI, 428 walks, 1401 strikeouts, 3698 total bases, .315/.358/.598 slash, 183 wRC+, and 77.5 WAR. Not becoming a starter until age 26 and his abrupt decline meant Malik had really only a decade worth of accumulations. Thus, he ranks 99^th in hits, 74^th in total bases, 41^st in homers, 52^nd in RBI, and 55^th in WAR among position players.

Among ABF batters with 3000+ plate appearances, Malik ranks 33^rd/63^rd/21^st and his .956 OPS is 27^th. His 183 wRC+ just misses the top 50 among all world Hall of Famers and retired locks, showing how efficient Malik was in his prime. That efficiency, his loyalty to Karachi, role in their 2025 pennant, and his high character made The Mayor an easy inductee even without big final tallies. Malik made it firmly at 90.0% as part of the Asian Baseball Federation’s 2041 class.

Ali Mahdian – Catcher – Tabriz Tiger Sharks – 71.0% First Ballot

Ali Mahdian was a 6’2’’, 200 pound left-handed hitting catcher from Behshahr, Iran; a city with about 95,000 in the north-central part of the country. Many consider Mahdian as the greatest defensive catcher in the history of the game. He was stellar at calling the game, blocking, and throwing out runners. Mahdian was also a team captain with excellent leadership and intelligence behind the plate. He also had great durabilty, starting 120+ games each year from 2020-35.

Even by catcher standards though, Mahdian wasn’t much of a hitter. He was merely decent facing right-handed pitching (.768 OPS, 110 wRC+) and was outright awful facing lefties (.596 OPS, 66 wRC+). Mahdian wasn’t devoid of power, but only got you 16 home runs and 35 doubles per his 162 game average. He was below average for drawing walks and avoid strikeouts. Mahdian was also a terrible baserunner and very slow.

In April 2014, a teenaged Mahdian signed a developmental deal with Tabriz. He was a rare 19-year old debut in 2017, although Mahdian was a part-time starter only in his first three years. Tabriz had just started a playoff streak when he arrived and won the ABF Championship in 2017. Mahdian only had one at-bat in the playoff run, but did start 10 games in the Baseball Grand Championship. He did struggle with .541 OPS and -0.1 WAR, but the Tiger Sharks shocked the field by claiming the top spot at 15-4.

He took over the full-time gig in 2020 and was a starter for 16 years. This started an 16-year streak of Gold Gloves behind the plate. Tabriz quickly gave him an eight-year, $48,620,000 extension after the 2020 season. Mahdian had his best offensive years initially with Silver Sluggers from 2020-22. 2022 had his career best for WAR (6.7), wRC+ (136), OPS (.875), and homers (21).

The Tiger Sharks’ playoff streak continued through 2024. Tabriz had the top seed from 2020-22, but failed to win the pennant. They lost the 2020 WLCS to Bursa, lost in the first round in 2021, then lost the 2022 WLCS to Baku. The Tiger Sharks were a 92-70 wild card in 2023, but got revenge on the Blackbirds to win the WLCS 4-1. Tabriz then defeated Bishkek 4-2 for their second ABF Championship win.

On the whole, Mahdian had weak playoff numbers in his career. In 96 games and 89 starts total, he had 86 hits, 37 runs, 15 doubles, 5 triples, 10 homers, 47 RBI, .252/.274/.413 slash, 87 wRC+, and 0.7 WAR. In the 2023 BGC, he had a .645 OPS, 86 wRC+, and 0.0 WAR. Tabriz couldn’t match their earlier BGC magic and finished 8-11. But Mahdian was extremely popular for his leadership and work behind the plate.

He was also nationally popular as the backstop for Iran in the World Baseball Championship from 2018-36. However, Mahdian had -0.6 WAR over 163 games with 102 hits, 45 runs, 27 doubles, 13 home runs, 66 RBI, and .193/.252/.318 slash. Iran’s deepest run was a third place finish in 2023. Despite his value elsewhere though, Mahdian’s bat didn’t hold up against the strongest competition.

Tabriz had a first round exit in 2024 to cap off their nine-year playoff streak. They missed the playoffs on a tiebreaker in 2025 at 94-68, then spent the next four years at or just below .500. With the rebuild in process and Mahdian in the final year of his deal for 2028, the Tiger Sharks traded him at the deadline to Bishkek in a six-player deal.

Mahdian played 48 games for the Black Sox with 1.1 WAR, .615 OPS, and 83 wRC+. Despite their push, Bishkek finished 87-75, missing the last wild card by three wins. Mahdian was now a free agent at age 31 and was still extremely popular in Tabriz and fond of the city and franchise. He returned to the Tiger Sharks on a five-year, $25 million deal.

From this point, he was pretty firmly a well-below average batter, but still a positive value player on defense. He even saw a batting resurgence in 2031 that led to a 6.2 WAR season. Tabriz’s rebuild ended and they got a wild card in 2030 at 97-65, ultimately falling in the WLCS as Baku began its dynasty. The Tiger Sharks lost in the first round in 2031 and 2032 as a wild card, then just missed the cut in 2033. Mahdian was a free agent again after the 2033 season, but in January 2034 signed a new two-year, $12,400,000 deal with Tabriz.

In 2034, Tabriz won the Central Division at 105-57. Baku was the heavy favorite with a historic 124-win season, but Ahvaz ousted them with two different series wins in the double-elimination format. The Tiger Sharks cruised to a later WLCS sweep of the Athletics, then beat Rawalpindi 4-2 for the ABF Championship. Tabriz finished 11-10 in the Baseball Grand Championship with Mahdian posting -0.2 WAR.

Tabriz got the #1 seed in 2035 at 113-49, but fell to Gaziantep in the WLCS. This was Mahdian’s final year and saw his 16^th Gold Glove. He’s one of only five players in all of world history at any position with 16+ GGs. Mahdian has the most of any ABF player and any catcher. No other catcher had won more than 12 in any league. Mahdian wanted to play in 2036 but went unsigned, eventually retiring that winter at age 39.

Mahdian finished with 2244 games, 2093 hits, 845 runs, 485 doubles, 24 triples, 216 home runs, 923 RBI, 446 walks, 1770 strikeouts, .266/.309/.416 slash, 99 wRC+, and 65.6 WAR. He ranks 54^th in games, 69^th in hits, 42^nd in doubles, and 84^th in WAR among position players. On the downside, Mahdian is the only Hall of Fame position player in world history with a wRC+ below 100 and he has the lowest OPS of any inductee.

However, Mahdian also finished with a career 165.6 zone rating, 1.052 EFF, 3.25 catchers’ ERA, and 49.7% runners thrown out. No other catcher in world history has even cracked 100+ ZR, which shows how impressive he was with his glove. Some guys had been better but had far shorter careers with worse bats and poor longevity. Mahdian was at least passable offensively for the position.

Still, even among Asian Baseball Federation catchers, Mahdian was 3^rd in WAR. His candidacy was a tricky especially as offensive value makes up the lion’s share of a position player’s worth for most. Catchers also generally run into the issue of lower accumulations with the position even for strong batters, making their resumes look weak relatively.

Mahdian had those qualities though which don’t register as obviously on the stat sheet. He made each of the pitchers he caught for better, which in turn helped Tabriz emerge as a regular contender in his career. Over his career, they made the playoffs 15 times with three ABF titles, a Grand Championship, eight LCS trips, and nine division titles. He was also a critical clubhouse leader and captain.

While the skeptics rightly noted he was a middling bat, Mahdian’s supporters had Tabriz’s team success to point to along with his incredible defense. Most informed scholars rank Mahdian as the greatest defensive catcher in baseball history, but even that didn’t guarantee induction. It was ultimately enough though as he earned 71.0%, narrowly breaching the 66% requirement for a first ballot nod to cap off ABF’s 2041 class.

04-20-2026, 08:30 AM	#2814
FuzzyRussianHat Hall Of Famer Join Date: Dec 2020 Posts: 3,406	2041 ABF Hall of Fame (Part 2) Mahtab “The Mayor” Malik – Third/First Base – Karachi Carp – 90.0% First Ballot Mahtab Malik was a 6’2’’, 200 pound switch-hitting corner infielder from Tando Allah Yar, Pakistan; a city of around 422,000 in the Hyderabad Division. His affable demeanor earned “The Major” as a nickname for Malik. He was incredibly likeable and a team captain known for his dedication, work ethic, and intelligence. Malik was also a rock solid contact and power hitter from both sides of the plate. His 162 game average got you 37 home runs and 30 doubles. Malik was below average for drawing walks and avoiding strikeouts, but his high slugging and average more than made up for it. On the downside, Malik was a laughably poor and slow baserunner. Around 2/3 of his career starts came at third base with lousy defensive metrics. The rest were at first base, where he graded as actually quite good with his glove. Malik also never missed any significant time to injury in his 14-year career. Malik was picked tenth by Karachi in the 2021 ABF Draft. He was full-time on the roster right away but used mostly as a pinch hitter with only 54 starts over his first three years. Malik finally got the full-time job in 2025 and won his first Silver Slugger that year at 1B. Karachi had been mid-tier for the last few years, but 2025 saw the Carp end a 13-year playoff drought at 100-62. They were still second in the division to 105-win Hyderabad, but the Horned Frogs got upset in the first round by Almaty. Karachi topped Dushanbe 3-1 in the first round and rolled the Assassins 4-1 to claim the East League Championship Series. The Carp were then defeated 4-2 by Mashhad in the ABF Championship. In 15 playoff starts, Malik was solid with 14 hits, 9 runs, 3 doubles, 3 homers, 8 RBI, .801 OPS, 147 wRC+, and 0.5 WAR. Karachi got the top seed the next year at 99-63, but lost the ELCS 4-2 to Hyderabad. This was Malik’s last playoff games as the Carp wouldn’t get back in his tenure. They were rarely outright bad going .500 or better from 2027-31 and in 2033. Malik remained steady though even as the team entered perpetual mid-ness. Malik did get a chance to play on the World Baseball Championship stage regularly from 2025-34 for Pakistan. In 118 games and 102 starts, he had 95 hits, 47 runs, 15 doubles, 27 home runs, 63 RBI, .235/.292/.478 slash, 124 wRC+, and 3.0 WAR. Malik notably was a starter for Pakistan’s first World Championship win in 2029 with 23 hits, 9 runs, 6 homers, and 14 RBI that year. From 2025-31, he had a Silver Slugger streak winning at 1B in 2025-27 and 3B after. Karachi gave Malik a five-year, $142 million extension in August 2028. He was the leader in RBI four times, and total bases thrice. In 2027, Malik led in hits (218), total bases (416), slugging (.685), OPS (1.076), and wRC+ (224); all career bests. Surprisingly despite his 9.4 WAR, he wasn’t an MVP finalist that year. Malik never won MVP, but did take second in 2029, 2030, and 2031. He had 9+ WAR thrice, peaking at 9.8 in 2030. 2031 saw his career best for home runs (56) and runs scored (113). After missing the honor in 2032, Malik won his eighth and final Silver Slugger in 2033 at 3B. That winter, he signed a three-year, $75,600,000 extension to stay loyal to Karachi. Both Malik’s and the Carp’s decline began in 2034. His contact ability plummeted in 2034 and he was benched with .631 OPS, 79 wRC+, and 0.1 WAR over 105 games and 27 starts. Malik was a bit better in 2035 but was still used only sparingly with 72 games and 9 starts. He opted to retire that winter shortly after his 37^th birthday. Karachi immediately retired Malik’s #35 uniform for his 14 years of work. Malik finished with 1967 games, 1945 hits, 962 runs, 367 doubles, 18 triples, 450 home runs, 1191 RBI, 428 walks, 1401 strikeouts, 3698 total bases, .315/.358/.598 slash, 183 wRC+, and 77.5 WAR. Not becoming a starter until age 26 and his abrupt decline meant Malik had really only a decade worth of accumulations. Thus, he ranks 99^th in hits, 74^th in total bases, 41^st in homers, 52^nd in RBI, and 55^th in WAR among position players. Among ABF batters with 3000+ plate appearances, Malik ranks 33^rd/63^rd/21^st and his .956 OPS is 27^th. His 183 wRC+ just misses the top 50 among all world Hall of Famers and retired locks, showing how efficient Malik was in his prime. That efficiency, his loyalty to Karachi, role in their 2025 pennant, and his high character made The Mayor an easy inductee even without big final tallies. Malik made it firmly at 90.0% as part of the Asian Baseball Federation’s 2041 class. Ali Mahdian – Catcher – Tabriz Tiger Sharks – 71.0% First Ballot Ali Mahdian was a 6’2’’, 200 pound left-handed hitting catcher from Behshahr, Iran; a city with about 95,000 in the north-central part of the country. Many consider Mahdian as the greatest defensive catcher in the history of the game. He was stellar at calling the game, blocking, and throwing out runners. Mahdian was also a team captain with excellent leadership and intelligence behind the plate. He also had great durabilty, starting 120+ games each year from 2020-35. Even by catcher standards though, Mahdian wasn’t much of a hitter. He was merely decent facing right-handed pitching (.768 OPS, 110 wRC+) and was outright awful facing lefties (.596 OPS, 66 wRC+). Mahdian wasn’t devoid of power, but only got you 16 home runs and 35 doubles per his 162 game average. He was below average for drawing walks and avoid strikeouts. Mahdian was also a terrible baserunner and very slow. In April 2014, a teenaged Mahdian signed a developmental deal with Tabriz. He was a rare 19-year old debut in 2017, although Mahdian was a part-time starter only in his first three years. Tabriz had just started a playoff streak when he arrived and won the ABF Championship in 2017. Mahdian only had one at-bat in the playoff run, but did start 10 games in the Baseball Grand Championship. He did struggle with .541 OPS and -0.1 WAR, but the Tiger Sharks shocked the field by claiming the top spot at 15-4. He took over the full-time gig in 2020 and was a starter for 16 years. This started an 16-year streak of Gold Gloves behind the plate. Tabriz quickly gave him an eight-year, $48,620,000 extension after the 2020 season. Mahdian had his best offensive years initially with Silver Sluggers from 2020-22. 2022 had his career best for WAR (6.7), wRC+ (136), OPS (.875), and homers (21). The Tiger Sharks’ playoff streak continued through 2024. Tabriz had the top seed from 2020-22, but failed to win the pennant. They lost the 2020 WLCS to Bursa, lost in the first round in 2021, then lost the 2022 WLCS to Baku. The Tiger Sharks were a 92-70 wild card in 2023, but got revenge on the Blackbirds to win the WLCS 4-1. Tabriz then defeated Bishkek 4-2 for their second ABF Championship win. On the whole, Mahdian had weak playoff numbers in his career. In 96 games and 89 starts total, he had 86 hits, 37 runs, 15 doubles, 5 triples, 10 homers, 47 RBI, .252/.274/.413 slash, 87 wRC+, and 0.7 WAR. In the 2023 BGC, he had a .645 OPS, 86 wRC+, and 0.0 WAR. Tabriz couldn’t match their earlier BGC magic and finished 8-11. But Mahdian was extremely popular for his leadership and work behind the plate. He was also nationally popular as the backstop for Iran in the World Baseball Championship from 2018-36. However, Mahdian had -0.6 WAR over 163 games with 102 hits, 45 runs, 27 doubles, 13 home runs, 66 RBI, and .193/.252/.318 slash. Iran’s deepest run was a third place finish in 2023. Despite his value elsewhere though, Mahdian’s bat didn’t hold up against the strongest competition. Tabriz had a first round exit in 2024 to cap off their nine-year playoff streak. They missed the playoffs on a tiebreaker in 2025 at 94-68, then spent the next four years at or just below .500. With the rebuild in process and Mahdian in the final year of his deal for 2028, the Tiger Sharks traded him at the deadline to Bishkek in a six-player deal. Mahdian played 48 games for the Black Sox with 1.1 WAR, .615 OPS, and 83 wRC+. Despite their push, Bishkek finished 87-75, missing the last wild card by three wins. Mahdian was now a free agent at age 31 and was still extremely popular in Tabriz and fond of the city and franchise. He returned to the Tiger Sharks on a five-year, $25 million deal. From this point, he was pretty firmly a well-below average batter, but still a positive value player on defense. He even saw a batting resurgence in 2031 that led to a 6.2 WAR season. Tabriz’s rebuild ended and they got a wild card in 2030 at 97-65, ultimately falling in the WLCS as Baku began its dynasty. The Tiger Sharks lost in the first round in 2031 and 2032 as a wild card, then just missed the cut in 2033. Mahdian was a free agent again after the 2033 season, but in January 2034 signed a new two-year, $12,400,000 deal with Tabriz. In 2034, Tabriz won the Central Division at 105-57. Baku was the heavy favorite with a historic 124-win season, but Ahvaz ousted them with two different series wins in the double-elimination format. The Tiger Sharks cruised to a later WLCS sweep of the Athletics, then beat Rawalpindi 4-2 for the ABF Championship. Tabriz finished 11-10 in the Baseball Grand Championship with Mahdian posting -0.2 WAR. Tabriz got the #1 seed in 2035 at 113-49, but fell to Gaziantep in the WLCS. This was Mahdian’s final year and saw his 16^th Gold Glove. He’s one of only five players in all of world history at any position with 16+ GGs. Mahdian has the most of any ABF player and any catcher. No other catcher had won more than 12 in any league. Mahdian wanted to play in 2036 but went unsigned, eventually retiring that winter at age 39. Mahdian finished with 2244 games, 2093 hits, 845 runs, 485 doubles, 24 triples, 216 home runs, 923 RBI, 446 walks, 1770 strikeouts, .266/.309/.416 slash, 99 wRC+, and 65.6 WAR. He ranks 54^th in games, 69^th in hits, 42^nd in doubles, and 84^th in WAR among position players. On the downside, Mahdian is the only Hall of Fame position player in world history with a wRC+ below 100 and he has the lowest OPS of any inductee. However, Mahdian also finished with a career 165.6 zone rating, 1.052 EFF, 3.25 catchers’ ERA, and 49.7% runners thrown out. No other catcher in world history has even cracked 100+ ZR, which shows how impressive he was with his glove. Some guys had been better but had far shorter careers with worse bats and poor longevity. Mahdian was at least passable offensively for the position. Still, even among Asian Baseball Federation catchers, Mahdian was 3^rd in WAR. His candidacy was a tricky especially as offensive value makes up the lion’s share of a position player’s worth for most. Catchers also generally run into the issue of lower accumulations with the position even for strong batters, making their resumes look weak relatively. Mahdian had those qualities though which don’t register as obviously on the stat sheet. He made each of the pitchers he caught for better, which in turn helped Tabriz emerge as a regular contender in his career. Over his career, they made the playoffs 15 times with three ABF titles, a Grand Championship, eight LCS trips, and nine division titles. He was also a critical clubhouse leader and captain. While the skeptics rightly noted he was a middling bat, Mahdian’s supporters had Tabriz’s team success to point to along with his incredible defense. Most informed scholars rank Mahdian as the greatest defensive catcher in baseball history, but even that didn’t guarantee induction. It was ultimately enough though as he earned 71.0%, narrowly breaching the 66% requirement for a first ballot nod to cap off ABF’s 2041 class. __________________ Baseball: The World's Game fictional world reports The Level Playing Field: Alternate MLB History From 1884-Onward Continental Baseball Federation world reports (8-tier promotion/relegation sim and college feeder)