OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post

Nick Soulis · 08-06-2025, 08:55 AM

Series #221

1907 New York Giants
Record: 82-71
Finish: 4th in NL
Manager: John McGraw
Ball Park: Polo Grounds
WAR Leader: Christy Mathewson (8.9)
Franchise Record: 8-11
1907 Season Record: 1-0
Hall of Famers: (3)
https://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/NYG/1907.shtml

2021 Minnesota Twins
Record: 73-89
Finish: 5th in AL Central
Manager: Rocco Baldelli
Ball Park: Target Field
WAR Leader: Jorge Polanco (5.0)
Franchise Record: 5-2
2021 Season Record: 2-1
Hall of Famers: (0)
https://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/MIN/2021.shtml
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name: 221 - pre.png
Views: 77
Size: 417.0 KB

Name: 221 - pre.png
Views: 77
Size: 417.0 KB

Heaven's Dugout: Series #221 Preview Special
Location: The Celestial Studio, overlooking the eternal diamonds of glory
Matchup: 1907 New York Giants (Home) vs. 2021 Minnesota Twins (Road)
Series Type: Best-of-Seven | Field of Dreams Tournament | Series #221

[Host: Mel Allen]

"Well, hello there, friends! Welcome back to Heaven’s Dugout, your front-row seat to the timeless classics of baseball's golden past and thrilling present. We’ve got a doozy lined up for Series #221 in the Field of Dreams Tournament as two vastly different teams square off: the small-ball savvy 1907 New York Giants and the long-ball loving 2021 Minnesota Twins. Buckle up—this one's going to be a fascinating clash of eras!"

Panel of Legends:

Mel Allen (Host)

Bill James (Sabermetric Analyst)

Frank Thomas (Power Perspective)

Tim McCarver (Catcher’s Corner)

Steve Stone (Pitching Insight)

Team Profiles

1907 New York Giants

Manager: John McGraw

Record (1907): 82–71, 4th in NL

Style of Play: Aggressive base running, tight defense, pitching finesse

Star Players:

Christy Mathewson – Ace pitcher, cerebral master of the mound

Art Devlin – Team catalyst with speed and smarts

Sammy Strang – Veteran presence with timely hits

Tim McCarver:
“This Giants team plays the game like a chess match. McGraw’s fingerprints are all over this club—sacrifice bunts, hit-and-runs, station-to-station ball. And don’t let the era fool you—Mathewson could carve up a modern lineup.”

2021 Minnesota Twins

Manager: Rocco Baldelli

Record (2021): 73–89, 5th in AL Central

Style of Play: Power-hitting, swing-heavy lineup, questionable pitching depth

Star Players:

Byron Buxton – Dynamic center fielder with speed and pop

Jorge Polanco – Steady switch-hitter with pop from both sides

Miguel Sanó – Boom-or-bust slugger, potential game-changer

Frank Thomas:
“The Twins can change a game with one swing, plain and simple. If Sanó and Buxton get going, that short right field fence in these heavenly dimensions might be in danger.”

Series Breakdown

Category Edge
Pitching Giants (Mathewson factor)
Defense Giants
Power Twins
Speed & Baserunning Giants
Bullpen Depth Twins
Intangibles Giants (McGraw mystique)

Bill James:
“On paper, the modern team has all the physical tools. But the Giants are the kind of team that plays every edge, every inch of grass. In a neutral setting like this Field of Dreams format, that discipline can outweigh muscle.”

Key Storylines

McGraw’s Mind Games vs. Modern Metrics

Can the 1907 Giants out-think and out-maneuver a power-centric Twins team that leans on exit velocity and launch angle?

Can the Twins Go Yard in Deadball Dimensions?

Modern bats meet softer, slower pitches—and a heavier ball. Will the long ball be neutralized or adjusted for Field of Dreams mechanics?

Mathewson vs. the Modern Slugger

A legendary hurler known for control and poise faces an all-or-nothing lineup. Can he keep them guessing with the “fadeaway” pitch?

Steve Stone:
“The pitching and defensive precision of Mathewson in this spacious outfield may just nullify the big bats of Minnesota. It’ll come down to how patient the Twins can be.”

X-Factor Players

Giants: Mike Donlin – A potential sparkplug with a .350+ average in his prime seasons. If he gets on base consistently, the Giants can manufacture chaos.

Twins: Max Kepler – If he gets hot early, his left-handed swing could exploit the shallow Polo Grounds right field and flip the series script.

Final Thoughts

Mel Allen:
“It’s the classic Field of Dreams matchup—an intelligent, tightly-coached deadball club against a hard-hitting modern lineup. The question is: will smarts and strategy prevail over brute force and big swings? That’s what makes this series so intriguing.”

Tim McCarver:
“I’ll be watching the plate discipline of the Twins. If they chase Mathewson’s stuff early, this series could be over quickly.”

Frank Thomas:
“If the Twins can launch a few bombs and get ahead early, McGraw’s style becomes less effective. Score first, slug second.”

Bill James:
“I wouldn’t count out the Giants. They didn’t just play baseball—they lived it like a religion.”

Stay tuned for Game 1 from the Polo Grounds!

08-06-2025, 08:55 AM	#277
Nick Soulis Hall Of Famer Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Chicago IL Posts: 4,265	Series #221 1907 New York Giants Record: 82-71 Finish: 4th in NL Manager: John McGraw Ball Park: Polo Grounds WAR Leader: Christy Mathewson (8.9) Franchise Record: 8-11 1907 Season Record: 1-0 Hall of Famers: (3) https://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/NYG/1907.shtml 2021 Minnesota Twins Record: 73-89 Finish: 5th in AL Central Manager: Rocco Baldelli Ball Park: Target Field WAR Leader: Jorge Polanco (5.0) Franchise Record: 5-2 2021 Season Record: 2-1 Hall of Famers: (0) https://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/MIN/2021.shtml -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Heaven's Dugout: Series #221 Preview Special Location: The Celestial Studio, overlooking the eternal diamonds of glory Matchup: 1907 New York Giants (Home) vs. 2021 Minnesota Twins (Road) Series Type: Best-of-Seven \| Field of Dreams Tournament \| Series #221 [Host: Mel Allen] "Well, hello there, friends! Welcome back to Heaven’s Dugout, your front-row seat to the timeless classics of baseball's golden past and thrilling present. We’ve got a doozy lined up for Series #221 in the Field of Dreams Tournament as two vastly different teams square off: the small-ball savvy 1907 New York Giants and the long-ball loving 2021 Minnesota Twins. Buckle up—this one's going to be a fascinating clash of eras!" Panel of Legends: Mel Allen (Host) Bill James (Sabermetric Analyst) Frank Thomas (Power Perspective) Tim McCarver (Catcher’s Corner) Steve Stone (Pitching Insight) Team Profiles 1907 New York Giants Manager: John McGraw Record (1907): 82–71, 4th in NL Style of Play: Aggressive base running, tight defense, pitching finesse Star Players: Christy Mathewson – Ace pitcher, cerebral master of the mound Art Devlin – Team catalyst with speed and smarts Sammy Strang – Veteran presence with timely hits Tim McCarver: “This Giants team plays the game like a chess match. McGraw’s fingerprints are all over this club—sacrifice bunts, hit-and-runs, station-to-station ball. And don’t let the era fool you—Mathewson could carve up a modern lineup.” 2021 Minnesota Twins Manager: Rocco Baldelli Record (2021): 73–89, 5th in AL Central Style of Play: Power-hitting, swing-heavy lineup, questionable pitching depth Star Players: Byron Buxton – Dynamic center fielder with speed and pop Jorge Polanco – Steady switch-hitter with pop from both sides Miguel Sanó – Boom-or-bust slugger, potential game-changer Frank Thomas: “The Twins can change a game with one swing, plain and simple. If Sanó and Buxton get going, that short right field fence in these heavenly dimensions might be in danger.” Series Breakdown Category Edge Pitching Giants (Mathewson factor) Defense Giants Power Twins Speed & Baserunning Giants Bullpen Depth Twins Intangibles Giants (McGraw mystique) Bill James: “On paper, the modern team has all the physical tools. But the Giants are the kind of team that plays every edge, every inch of grass. In a neutral setting like this Field of Dreams format, that discipline can outweigh muscle.” Key Storylines McGraw’s Mind Games vs. Modern Metrics Can the 1907 Giants out-think and out-maneuver a power-centric Twins team that leans on exit velocity and launch angle? Can the Twins Go Yard in Deadball Dimensions? Modern bats meet softer, slower pitches—and a heavier ball. Will the long ball be neutralized or adjusted for Field of Dreams mechanics? Mathewson vs. the Modern Slugger A legendary hurler known for control and poise faces an all-or-nothing lineup. Can he keep them guessing with the “fadeaway” pitch? Steve Stone: “The pitching and defensive precision of Mathewson in this spacious outfield may just nullify the big bats of Minnesota. It’ll come down to how patient the Twins can be.” X-Factor Players Giants: Mike Donlin – A potential sparkplug with a .350+ average in his prime seasons. If he gets on base consistently, the Giants can manufacture chaos. Twins: Max Kepler – If he gets hot early, his left-handed swing could exploit the shallow Polo Grounds right field and flip the series script. Final Thoughts Mel Allen: “It’s the classic Field of Dreams matchup—an intelligent, tightly-coached deadball club against a hard-hitting modern lineup. The question is: will smarts and strategy prevail over brute force and big swings? That’s what makes this series so intriguing.” Tim McCarver: “I’ll be watching the plate discipline of the Twins. If they chase Mathewson’s stuff early, this series could be over quickly.” Frank Thomas: “If the Twins can launch a few bombs and get ahead early, McGraw’s style becomes less effective. Score first, slug second.” Bill James: “I wouldn’t count out the Giants. They didn’t just play baseball—they lived it like a religion.” Stay tuned for Game 1 from the Polo Grounds! Last edited by Nick Soulis; 08-06-2025 at 09:03 AM.