Guess which Sheff is mine? Yep, -0.7 WAR Sheff. The very bottom. I'm telling you, there either has to be some hidden rating that affects their performance, or I just have horrible luck. As the repeatedly bad performances build up, I can't help but think it's a hidden attribute. Or it's my "strategy" which I doubt would put all of my players into the bottom 3rd in performance.
My Yount is in the bottom 25% in pretty much all categories of the 21 Younts in my league. My Halladay is in the 4th worst Halladay of 24 teams who are using him as a regular starter. My Carew, who only plays in about half my games, has the 2nd worst WAR and BABIP of about 26 "ACTIVE" Carews in my league. My Honus Wagner is in the bottom third of Wagers. I've even given up and brought in Luke Appling because, eff it, why bother playing players who aren't performing? The only thing keeping me from being the 2003 Tigers in the league is that I'm finally getting good performances out of Sale and Whitey this season. And to put some perspective to this, I'm in the easiest division in the league in terms of opposing team win % and RDIFF.
I think I might sell off every good player on my team at this point and just open packs for a day, at least I'll get some enjoyment out of it.