First, I have never imported a season so totally new at that.
I am still playing 25 while awaiting patch on certain things (not what this post is about). There are things I REALLY do like as upgrades in 26 though and just figured I would import the 25 game later since I don't have much time to play at the moment anyway.
So decided to ask chatgpt if I would be missing out on anything importing from 25 to 26 and this is what it told me. Is this correct? If so I'll be doing fresh save later but I am not so certain chatgpt is correct since I know many of you import year after year after year.
Ok from chatgpt on what I would be missing importing vs starting brand new save. Is this correct?
"
1. New AI behavior & logic tweaks
- The AI is often rebalanced — for trades, lineups, drafts, etc. You may not see full effects unless starting fresh, since some logic is baked into how the save was set up.
2. New scouting/coaching systems or changes
- If OOTP 26 introduces a new scouting mechanic (e.g. changes to accuracy levels or coaching influence), those often require a new world to activate properly.
3. New contract and financial systems
- Any changes to how arbitration, international free agents, or team options work may not retroactively apply.
- League-wide finances, inflation, or valuation models may not update.
4. Updated default settings or rule changes
- MLB rule updates, league structure changes, or option years (like changes in minor league rules) might not take effect unless you start new.
5. New player development models
- Sometimes development arcs and aging curves are overhauled. Existing players will still follow the OOTP 25 model unless they were regenerated, meaning some of the new "life path" variety is lost.
If you’re deeply invested in your current save — like a fictional league you’ve nurtured for years — importing is fine and totally playable. But if you want to experience all the new OOTP 26 systems and balances as intended, a new save is the way to go."