Andrew Bixby 1856
Not sure if it's possible to get a colorization of this since its from a woodcut but I cannot find any actual photos of this player's face, though I'd suspect it is based on an actual photo that just hasn't been found yet. He played for the New York Eagles of the NABBP and according to a paper from 1866 the description is: “Uniform consists of dark blue flannel pants, check shirt and blue cap with white visor.”
__________________

They say follow your heart
Follow it through
But how can you
When it's split in two?
|