Quote:
Originally Posted by RUKen
OK; I agree with Fullerton and Watson, but you have Mike Mitchell where I have Joe Conzelman. I have Mitchell in the rear, seventh from the left, and Wilbur Cooper eighth from the left, and you have Cooper and Conzelman, respectively, in those places. (All three are wearing dark caps.)
At this moment, our differences are top row 6th, 7th, 8th, 12th, and 17th from left, and bottom row, 1st, 5th, 6th, 10th, 11th, 12th, and 16th from left. I think the graininess of the photo, and the similarity in appearances of some of the players, may make it hard to resolve all of these.
|
Both Conzelman and Mitchell appear to be wearing the tartan jacket. A small minority of players appear to be wearing a plain dark jacket. The player 8th from left appears to be one of those wearing a plain jacket. So my suggestion of Conzelman appears to be wrong, it is more difficult to establish the jacket Cooper is wearing but the sleeve above his hand appears to show a pattern indicating he is wearing a tartan jacket which would indicate that he is more likely to be seventh from left than eighth. 9 players are wearing the plain jacket. So the next stage should be to pick out the 9 players wearing a plain jacket in the second photo.
First person working from the top and left to right wearing a plain jacket is Watson who also has a white cap. This combination validates the position we have for him.
Second player wearing a plain jacket is Brenegan that also validates the position we have for him.
Third player wearing a plain jacket is Wagner which also validates his position, I don't think we needed that validation.
Fourth player in the bottom row wearing a plain jacket and also capless is Jim Kelly which validates his position.
Fifth player wearing a plain jacket and also a white cap is Daley which again validates his place.
Sixth player wearing a plain jacket and also a white cap is Kantlehner which would validate a position 3rd from right in the top row but not sixth from left in the top row.
Seventh player wearing a plain jacket and also a white cap is Waite who I now have as 6th player in the bottom row.
Eight player wearing a plain jacket and also a white cap is Toby Fullerton which validates his position.
Struggling to find the 9th plain jacket Gibson, McArthur or Cooper is a possibilty.