Quote:
Originally Posted by UKBaseballfan
Thanks for the identification proposals.
I believe being listed at 6'3" Al Kellogg is the tallest of all players we are reviewing, I prefer him as 3rd from left of the back row. Mickey Keliher is listed at 6' and as a result suggest he is second from left of the back row.
Support the placements you have provided for Ralph Capron, Hal Grover, Ham Hyatt and Howie Camnitz. Also have inserted Butts Wagner into the 1913 Spring Training image.
Attached is the exemplar I have been using for Harry Gardner, it leads me to suggest he is second from right of the bottom row.
Lefty Leifield possesses a notable chin feature which persuades me that he could be ninth from left in the top row. Candidate for extreme left of the top row suggest Bill (Rebel) Keen, top row fifth from left as Raymond Haley, top row fifth from right as Bruce Noel, top row eighth from left as Cliff Averett and bottom row extreme right as Bill Irving.
The remaining 'ballplayer' does appear to be a misfit in the bottom row third from left, looks more like a band leader to me?
|
I had thought Robinson was taller than he was (he is listed at 5'11"), so I agree now with Kellogg, and your placement of Robinson. I also agree with Leifield, Keen, Haley, Kelly, Noel, Averett, and Irving.
You've stated that you agree with my placement of Camnitz, but you've also placed Keliher there (second from left in the top row). I think it's a pretty good match for Camnitz. I still like Keliher fourth from the left.
The man third from the left in the bottom row appears to be wearing a Pirates jersey under his sweater, as well as a Pirates cap, so I do think he is a ballplayer. He is identified as Wally Rehg in your earlier post. That would leave only the third from the right in the bottom unidentified. It could be Ona Dodd; I wish there were a better image of him.
Camnitz / ? / Keliher / ?