OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post - Roster set issues (2024 MLB / MiLB / KBO / Honkbal / NBL) go here.

TrapperJohn · 03-13-2024, 10:31 AM

Thanks for everything you do, Lukas. In case it's helpful — and not sure how much of this is under your control vs. how much comes from outside databases — here are some notes primarily on the Red Sox org based on a default new game with scouting at 100%. Some of these are quite minor, but figured better to err on the side of being annoying on the off-chance any of this is helpful as things take shape.

The biggest issue for me so far is over-inflated ratings for free agents. The minute I start a new game, teams are climbing all over themselves to sign Eric Jokisch, a 60/60 starting pitcher who in real life hasn't sniffed the majors in a decade. There are a bunch of these guys scattered throughout the FA list (not only international journeymen, but guys like Tyler Dearden (40/50 in-game) who in real life are fringy minor leaguers). The realism suffers off the bat when teams like the Dodgers and Phillies are dumping good players on day two to sign Adam Plutko to a big contract.

As for the Sox:

Michael Fulmer is healthy and on the active roster when a new game loads — he underwent UCL surgery and will miss the whole year.

Brainer Bonaci has been suspended for the season.

Bunch of guys who show up on the team who are no longer in the org:
Yusniel Padron-Artiles
Alex Erro (retired)
Deundre Jones
Nate Tellier
Jorge Rodriguez
Luis De La Rosa
Connor Butler
Bryant Zayas
Wandy Abreu
Enmanuel Martinez
Yizreel Burnet
Ali Ascanio
(Plus a bunch of DSL guys)

I hesitate to nitpick ratings too much, but two thoughts for consideration:

1) Seems odd that minor league org guys like Eddy Alvarez are 50/50 overall, above guys competing for the Majors at the same position (namely Enmanuel Valdez at 45/50). Similarly, Boston's third and... maybe sixth catchers, Roberto Perez & Mickey Gasper, are at 50/50 while their big-league guys, Wong and McGuire, are both 45/45. Not the end of the world, but it has some screwy implications for the AI.

2) Guys who are not considered viable major-league prospects seem to have awfully high potentials (see, e.g., Max Ferguson at 35/50; Albert Feliz at 25/45; Bryan Gonzalez at 30/45), while others who are on track to be major leaguers seem deflated (see, e.g., Luis Guerrero at 40/40; David Sandlin at 25/35; Kristian Campbell at 20/35; Angel Bastardo at 30/30).

Again, really appreciate all you do, and thanks for humoring us. I only point this stuff out in case it's helpful for refining the game — not to be a pest — so feel free to ignore, of course.

03-13-2024, 10:31 AM	#25
TrapperJohn Minors (Triple A) Join Date: Dec 2018 Posts: 252	Thanks for everything you do, Lukas. In case it's helpful — and not sure how much of this is under your control vs. how much comes from outside databases — here are some notes primarily on the Red Sox org based on a default new game with scouting at 100%. Some of these are quite minor, but figured better to err on the side of being annoying on the off-chance any of this is helpful as things take shape. The biggest issue for me so far is over-inflated ratings for free agents. The minute I start a new game, teams are climbing all over themselves to sign Eric Jokisch, a 60/60 starting pitcher who in real life hasn't sniffed the majors in a decade. There are a bunch of these guys scattered throughout the FA list (not only international journeymen, but guys like Tyler Dearden (40/50 in-game) who in real life are fringy minor leaguers). The realism suffers off the bat when teams like the Dodgers and Phillies are dumping good players on day two to sign Adam Plutko to a big contract. As for the Sox: Michael Fulmer is healthy and on the active roster when a new game loads — he underwent UCL surgery and will miss the whole year. Brainer Bonaci has been suspended for the season. Bunch of guys who show up on the team who are no longer in the org: Yusniel Padron-Artiles Alex Erro (retired) Deundre Jones Nate Tellier Jorge Rodriguez Luis De La Rosa Connor Butler Bryant Zayas Wandy Abreu Enmanuel Martinez Yizreel Burnet Ali Ascanio (Plus a bunch of DSL guys) I hesitate to nitpick ratings too much, but two thoughts for consideration: 1) Seems odd that minor league org guys like Eddy Alvarez are 50/50 overall, above guys competing for the Majors at the same position (namely Enmanuel Valdez at 45/50). Similarly, Boston's third and... maybe sixth catchers, Roberto Perez & Mickey Gasper, are at 50/50 while their big-league guys, Wong and McGuire, are both 45/45. Not the end of the world, but it has some screwy implications for the AI. 2) Guys who are not considered viable major-league prospects seem to have awfully high potentials (see, e.g., Max Ferguson at 35/50; Albert Feliz at 25/45; Bryan Gonzalez at 30/45), while others who are on track to be major leaguers seem deflated (see, e.g., Luis Guerrero at 40/40; David Sandlin at 25/35; Kristian Campbell at 20/35; Angel Bastardo at 30/30). Again, really appreciate all you do, and thanks for humoring us. I only point this stuff out in case it's helpful for refining the game — not to be a pest — so feel free to ignore, of course.