Another dry run for C-Town as Billy Williams comes agonisingly close but misses out and Whitey Ford's time on the ballot ends unsuccessfully.
- LF Billy Williams 73.5 (2nd year)
- SP Jim O'Toole 41.5 (3rd year)
- SP Whitey Ford 33.6 (10th year) Dropped
- LF Lou Brock 27.9 (1st year)
- C Bill Freehan 25.7 (1st year)
- 1B Norm Cash 23.0 (4th year)
- RF Rocky Colavito 22.1 (7th year)
- RF Tony Oliva 20.2 (2nd year)
- SP Juan Marichal 19.1 (4th year)
- CF Willie Davis 19.1 (1st year)
- SS Rico Petrocelli 17.2 (3rd year)
- 3B Ron Santo 14.5 (3rd year)
- 1B Boog Powell 10.9 (1st year)
- CF Vada Pinson 10.7 (3rd year)
- CL Jim Brewer 9.8 (2nd year)
- CF Jim Wynn 7.9 (1st year)
- 1B Orlando Cepeda 7.9 (3rd year)
- CF Bob Allison 7.9 (8th year)
- SP Ken Holtzman 7.4 (1st year)
- 1B Ernie Banks 6.0 (8th year)
- SP Pat Jarvis 3.8 (1st year) Dropped
- SP Larry Dierker 3.6 (1st year) Dropped
- 2B Dick McAuliffe 2.5 (3rd year) Dropped
- SP Chris Short 2.5 (4th year) Dropped
- SP Don Wilson 1.9 (1st year) Dropped
- SP Jim Merritt 1.6 (1st year) Dropped
- SP Ray Sadecki 0.3 (1st year) Dropped
- RP Dave Vineyard 0.0 (1st year) Dropped