EDIT:
P1 was 35 year old Pedro Martinez of the Taiwan Explosive Go Salmon (winner)
P2 was 33 year old Jacob deGrom of the Galveston Greyhounds
~~~
Player 1 (red) has been his team's #1 starter all year.
Player 2 (gray) has been his team's #2 starter all year (yes, different team).
Both players' teams are division winners.
So - who is it gonna be?
Please explain your vote - I like to hear the reasoning.