|
The thing that was said about perfect team being all over the place, honestly what did you expect. The year Babe Ruth hit 60 homers, he faced a boat load of pitchers that were either average or slightly above average but in perfect team, 99% of the teams have great pitchers and much better fielders so stats will be skewed. How can Bob Gibson maintain 1.12 ERA when he faces the best 9 hitters of all time? How does Joe Jackson hit .400 when all the pitchers in the whole league are superstars and need their stats to be as good as they were. You're expectations of perfect team are way off, not the game or engine.
I didnt say fictional makes it so bad trades are ok but if you look through the history of baseball or any sport for that matter there are so many "bad" trades. They happen all the time. In this, the team picked up a good hitting catcher with decent defense and moved their good hitting catcher to third to make room. I have no idea who was at third but if he was average and that made the team better then it's really not a bad deal or a bad move.
When it happens in fictional leagues, I've seen this kind of thing and yes it's way way way easier to look at a Joe Catcher and wonder why he got moved for Jim Catcher to replace Bob Thirdbase. When you just look at ratings and take out names and history, it's a way easier time making the trade make sense but that doesn't mean that they will all make sense.
Do all trades have to make sense though? Like I said, teams make trades all the time that on the surface make little sense but are done anyways.
I actually kind of like weird and odd trades and see how they play out in my sims
Sent from my SM-G998W using Tapatalk
|