Jim Donnelly has long been confused with James Henry Donnelly, who played briefly for the Kansas City Cowboys of the Union Association in 1884. The two are in fact discrete players. This Jim Donnelly also began his career in 1884, but played until 1898, while the other James Donnelly returned to his hometown of Boston after his brief stint in the Union Association.
The OOTP database mixes the two together and a note regarding this has been posted in the Historic Database thread.
This Jim is also my third baseman in my new Random Debut game. Redid the facegen as the old one was one of those placeholder faces. Love his Eraserhead hair. Ahead of his time