View Single Post
Old 08-30-2020, 05:15 PM   #1
KyleM
Minors (Single A)
 
KyleM's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2019
Location: Danbury CT
Posts: 66
Want/Need two to three pitchers Dean vs Guidry vs Johnson

I am trying to make a hard decision. I am interested in both Dizzy Dean and Ron Guidry (both peak 100's) and SE Walter Johnson (100 OVR)

I play in stadium modeled after Yankee Stadium.

I have an outstanding defensive team, with plus..to very good, and great defenders at every position.

Does anyone here have any experience using these three? I love that both Dean and Guidry have three plus pitches each. Johnson stands out score wise (Using the ST rating...the move rating at 2.4...the control rating at 1.5) but I am having trouble accepting that he only has one plus pitch. But he is a groundball pitcher and I have an outstanding defensive infield and a great offensive team.

I would love/appreciate any input any of you have.

Currently in Iron 236...but after 143 win season, I am currently heading to PL level in just about three weeks.

Current team:

C-Berra Se 100 OVR vs RH Piazza SE 96 OVR vs LH
1B-Ortiz SE 100 OVR
2B-Morgan AT Legend 100 OVR
SS-Appling SE 100 OVR
3B-Schmidt FOTF 100 OVR
LF-Yastrzemski AT Legend 100 OVR
CF-Henderson SE 100 OVR
RF-Ruth SE 100 OVR (1923)
DH-Ted Williams SE 100 OVR

I Am torn. Have not seen much feedback on these three pitchers. I see the ratings. I see the Movement ratings on both Dean and Guidry...but I keep going back to the three plus pitches they each throw. But Johnson grades out better (mathematically)

I would truly love to hear some feedback on personal experience (s).

Thanks in advance.

Kyle

Last edited by KyleM; 08-30-2020 at 05:24 PM. Reason: Typo's (misspells)
KyleM is offline   Reply With Quote