[Neags23]

The player in question is Andy Stump. Here's his scouting report, the rest of the SS's in his organization, and the rest of his team. Scouting accuracy is high.

Based entirely on ratings, the call up, even days after being drafted, makes sense. But based on such a small sample size where all he did was fall flat on his face, the call up doesn't really make sense at all. If, in such a small sample size, he was hitting .424 with a 165 OPS+ along with those ratings... then, sure, why not?

I think the small sample size of his stats is all the more of an indication the AI doesn't care about minor league stats. No human organization would do this with so few ABs in the minors, particularly ABs where he didn't show an ounce of success. Unless they were basing it entirely on ratings.