For my inaugural Hall of Fame. I picked 6 pitchers from the past, sort of committee. Comments
James Burke: Played from 1882 to 1898 for the New York Mutuals/Giants. 10 POY, 3 Pitching Triple Crowns. 396-227 record
Ice Box Chamberlain: 1886-1903 for Louisville/Boston Americans. 377-269 record.
Charlie Ferguson: 1884-1900 for Providence/St Louis Cardinals. 364-309 record.
Jim Handiboe: 1886-1908 with Boston Beaneaters/Doves/Braves. Won 30 games in 1890. 404-427 record.
Bill Sweeney: 1882-1899 for Chicago White Stockings/Cubs. 409-287 record. Won over 33 games twice in his career. 3 time POY.
Cy Young: 1890-1910 for Syracuse Stars/Washington Senators. Most wins by any player with 511. 6 POY awards. Won over 40 games twice (1892 and 1893). 57 career shut outs.