[mcdog512]

Originally Posted by kingcharlesxii

An all-iron team is different than the one that was brought up as the example. I think everybody would agree that is tanking.

That said, a player playing out of position could easily put out less value than an iron player. Don't put too much value on card ratings. There are bronzes that can play well at Diamond and Silvers that can play at Perfect.

EDIT: Basically, what I'm saying is that a team that is making the 1899 Cleveland Spiders look like a quality ballclub, clearly that's tanking. I'm not sure if I'd say a team with a decent amount of non-irons that loses 100 games is tanking. I've said my piece, feel free to disagree. Ultimately it's up to the OOTP crew to make that distinction and I don't envy them finding that fine line.

I would agree with that.

Cheers.