You follow the actual Raccoons, you should know what a manic obsession with defensive versatility and prowess does to a team's scoring capability!
For starters, replace all the Reds and Mets in that lineup with ANY card. Serious. ANY card will do. Ervin Santana at second base? Will do!
Nah, seriously, you have to find something better than Schebler or that assortment of second basemen, and foremost a catcher. Good silver catchers are hard to find, but for LF I can recommend Yoenis Cespedes f.e.; at your level he will do lots of damage and will only cost a couple o' hundo (it's a 79 card). This lineup needs a kiss of power so I am not sure about Ichiro.
I find Buster Posey a great, "somewhat" affordable card. It's a gold card and not a cheap one; I got mine for about 2,500 PP a few seasons ago.