Quote:
Originally Posted by r0nster
@ ActionJackson …
HOF means TOP tier players he doesn't look like he had a career that could be even consider be the cream of the crop as the saying goes. Even in real life the HOF is being whittled down some and hard pressed as the BEST of the BEST. Even if you only do post WW2 only players. Yes I have HIGH standards and I have not lowered them and I wont.
|
And that's why I said different strokes for different folks. Personally I would for sure lop off 12 of his 27 HoF SP, keep 9 of them, and have to take a deeper look at the other 6. But, it's not my HoF. The best of the best for me is the top 1% to ever play the game. IMHO, Mr. Toner, thanks to his insane peak, is a top one percenter, so, he would go in for me, and he wouldn't go in for you. That's fine. There has never been 100% consensus on any RL HoFer until Mo this year, and that's the way it should be. Doesn't mean either one of us is wrong. Just means that we view HoFers differently.
