[BMW]

You don't need to get anywhere close to Diamond card pitchers to throw out a starting rotation of five Cy Young caliber pitchers.

I could build a rotation of these Cy Young level players for about the PP I got from one guy striking out 4 guys in an inning, or getting two guys voted to the all-star game in PT.

These are Silver starting pitchers:
Mark Fidrych '76 - All Star, ROY, 2nd in CY voting, got MVP votes
Jerry Koosman '68 - All Star, 2nd in ROY voting, got MVP votes
Tom Seaver '67 - All Star, ROY, got MVP votes
Jim Turner '37 - no CY or ROY yet, got MVP votes
Juan Marichal '66 - All Star, got MVP votes
Andy Pettite '96 - All Star, 2nd in CY voting, got MVP votes
Randy Jones '75 - All Star, 2nd in CY voting, got MVP votes
Johnny Antonelli '54 - All Star, got MVP votes
Catfish Hunter ' 75 - All Star, 2nd in CY voting, got MVP votes
David Cone '94 - All Star, Cy Young, got MVP votes
David Wells '98 - All Star, 3rd in CY voting, got MVP votes
Dock Ellis '71 - All Star, 4th in CY voting
Sam Jones '56
Wilbur Wood '72 - All Star, 2nd in CY voting, got MVP votes
Vic Raschi '51 - got MVP votes
Sad Sam Jones '21
Mark Langston '89
Mike Witt '84
Bob Ojeda '86 - 4th in CY voting, got MVP votes
Jim Abbott '91 - 3rd in CY voting
Rick Ankiel '00 - 2nd in ROY voting
Justin Thompson '97 - All Star
Herman Pillette '22
Todd Ritchie '99
John Maine '07