| NL Great Gloves |
| AL Great Gloves |
| Pitcher |
| Pitcher |
| Ozzie Wadsley (Newark Eurekas) |
| Clyde Droegemueller (Philadelphia Keystones) |
| .941 PCT, 2.68 RF, +2.2 ZR, 1.077 EFF |
| .885, 1.92 RF, +1.8 ZR, 1.008 EFF |
|
|
|
| Catcher |
| Catcher |
| Dewitt Chemin (Irvington Blue Knights) |
| Eli Badilla (Boston Lowells) |
| .775 PCT, 84 PB, 22.4 CS%, 3.40 CERA |
| .864 PCT, 71 PB, 22.7 CS%, 3.93 CERA |
|
|
|
| First Baseman |
| First Baseman |
| Martino Guerra (Brooklyn Excelsiors) |
| Rigby Holaday (Cambridge Harvards) |
| .944 PCT, 9.45 RF, +5.0 ZR, 1.095 EFF |
| .979 PCT, 10.17 RF, +5.7 ZR, 1.250 EFF |
|
|
|
| Second Baseman |
| Second Baseman |
| Ron Godby (Brooklyn Bridges) |
| Lorenzo Vilela (Cambridge Harvards) |
| .912 PCT, 5.54 RF, +10.8 ZR, 1.185 EFF |
| .865 PCT, 5.67 RF, +10.5 ZR, 1.144 EFF |
|
|
|
| Third Baseman |
| Third Baseman |
| Jose Pantoja (Brooklyn Eckfords) |
| Jago Montemer (Cambridge Harvards) |
| .863 PCT, 3.02 RF, +8.2 ZR, 1.317 EFF |
| .763 PCT, 2.98 RF, +8.1 ZR, 1.171 EFF |
|
|
|
| Shortstop |
| Shortstop |
| Avery Numbers (New York Mutuals) |
| Yoslan Louzao (Cambridge Harvards) |
| .913 PCT, 5.21 RF, +17.3 ZR , 1.299 EFF |
| .840 PCT, 5.04 RF, +11.1 ZR, 1.121 EFF |
|
|
|
| Left Fielder |
| Left Fielder |
| Isaac Vander Mey (New York Actives) |
| Nestor Treybig (New York Eagles) |
| .869 PCT, 3.55 RF, +6.4 ZR, 1.077 EFF |
| .847 PCT, 3.48 RF, +8.0 ZR, 1.158 EFF |
|
|
|
| Center Fielder |
| Center Fielder |
| Burke Haars (Newark Americus) |
| Gaspar Chaires (Camden Camdens) |
| .972 PCT, 5.35 RF, +11.1 ZR, 1.075 EFF |
| .855 PCT, 5.59 RF, +4.1 ZR, 1.015 EFF |
|
|
|
| Right Fielder |
| Right Fielder |
| Ileanna Santan (Brooklyn Eckfords) |
| Way-ming Chao (New York Empires) |
| .936 PCT, 3.78 RF, +10.0 ZR, 1.105 EFF |
| .895 PCT, 3.72 RF, +1.5 ZR, 1.019 EFF |