OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post - Trade two 3.5 star SP prospects for one 5 star SP prospect?

tedstriker · 04-20-2018, 08:00 AM

I haven't advanced in my game for almost a week because I can't decide about a trade. Specifically, I have a trade opportunity to get an amazing 5 star SP prospect, but I would have to give up two 3.5 star SP prospects.

Basically, is one potential Cy Young winner worth twice as much as two above average, possibly even all-star pitchers?

My main concern is that with two prospects, I have a better chance of having at least one of them develop. I would hate to make the trade and end up having the 5 star prospect never develop.

The 5-star SP is also only 20. The two 3.5 stars are 22 and 23. One of them has started to show a little development and has a actual rating of 1.5 stars, but the other is still at 0.5 stars.

Any advice would be appreciated.

04-20-2018, 08:00 AM	#1
tedstriker Minors (Single A) Join Date: Mar 2015 Posts: 75	Trade two 3.5 star SP prospects for one 5 star SP prospect? I haven't advanced in my game for almost a week because I can't decide about a trade. Specifically, I have a trade opportunity to get an amazing 5 star SP prospect, but I would have to give up two 3.5 star SP prospects. Basically, is one potential Cy Young winner worth twice as much as two above average, possibly even all-star pitchers? My main concern is that with two prospects, I have a better chance of having at least one of them develop. I would hate to make the trade and end up having the 5 star prospect never develop. The 5-star SP is also only 20. The two 3.5 stars are 22 and 23. One of them has started to show a little development and has a actual rating of 1.5 stars, but the other is still at 0.5 stars. Any advice would be appreciated.