View Single Post
Old 01-17-2018, 12:20 PM   #17
Silfir
Minors (Double A)
 
Join Date: May 2016
Posts: 137
Quote:
Originally Posted by thehef View Post
I don't know if OOTP does this to a small degree or not at all (because I don't play with any long-term injuries), but it seems that few CEI's should be instantly reported as such, and most CEI's should follow something like this:

1) player suffers a serious injury to [body part], diagnosis pending
2) injury is fully diagnosed as season-ending, surgery-required
3) at some point - probably at least a few months after the diagnosis, often longer in order to account for surgery and some rehab - the player either:

a) returns with significantly lessened ratings (suggesting a guy who is trying to come back but simply no longer has it) that will, through the natural course of things, result in his unemployment & retirement, or
b) simply retires (suggesting that the player gave rehab a shot but it just wasn't in the cards)

The success or lack thereof of the player's recovery should partially be determined by his age.

I would think that most of the mechanism to support this is already in OOTP. But we gamers like to make OOTP program changes sound simpler than they really are...
The mechanism not only is already in OOTP, all of these already happen with some regularity - both the players on a long-term injury that suffer a setback in rehab some months down the line that ends up career-ending, as well as pitchers who come back a shadow of a former self.

If injuries that are immediately deemed career-ending upon diagnosis happen a little more often in OOTP than they do in real life, it's a concession to the players - there's little more maddening than having a character with a season-ending injury make it past the once-a-year retirement date, only for his injury to turn career-ending later, saddling you with another year of paying their salary.

Last edited by Silfir; 01-17-2018 at 12:28 PM.
Silfir is offline   Reply With Quote